The Bacchae Ramble Review
While Euripides' The Bacchae presents a Dionysus who's terrifying and morally unsettling, it doesn't make his divinity any less legitimate than that of other gods.
Pentheus doesn't just reject Dionysus' worship, but denies his godhood, mocks his followers, imprisons him, and assumes that his own authority is higher.
And, admittedly, Dionysus doesn't make it easy. He was born to a mortal mother, raised in foreign lands, and returns as a cult-leading stranger.
There is no grand proclamation from Zeus announcing his son, so to Pentheus, he's no more than foreign charlatan.
But Cadmus thinks different. He reminds Pentheus of Actaeon, whose arrogance against Artemis cost him his life, and argues that if Dionysus truly is a god, it is far more dangerous to deny him than it is to honor him.
Mortals don't get to decide which gods deserve reverence.
So when the punishment passes, Cadmus tells Dionysus that he didn't need to punish Pentheus this way.
Dionysus didn't need to come disguised. He didn't need to let Pentheus insult and threaten him. He didn't need to persuade him to dress as a woman before leading him to his death.
But that's exactly the point.
Dionysus wanted Pentheus humiliated.
Pentheus spends the entire play policing boundaries. Men must be men. Women must stay indoors. Foreigners are suspicious. Gods must fit his expectations.
Dionysus dismantles every one of them.
The women of Thebes abandon the city for the mountains. The king who mocked Dionysus' appearance willingly dresses as a woman. The hunter becomes the hunted, torn apart like a wild beast by his own mother.
As he says to the Chorus:
"I want him to be laughed at by the Thebans;
"I'll lead him through the city in a dress,
after those dreadful threats he made before.
But I will fashion Pentheus in the dress
he'll wear to go to death, a trip to slaughter,
killed at his mother's hands. He'll recognize
the true god, Dionysus, son of Zeus,
most dreadful and most gentle to mankind."
- Line 854-861
That's what makes The Bacchae so unsettling. Euripides doesn't ask us whether Dionysus is a good god.
After all, Dionysus calls upon his dual nature.
It's what happens when a god is called a fraud, for whether it's from peasant or king, the result is all the same.
They end torn like an animal.