How would Baby Dark Cacao Cookie react if someone took his toy away. Would he be grumpy with a tear? Would he just sadly cry, like how babies would cry when something out of their hands removed? Would he do a puppy face? Would he just try to get it back but fail miserably with a tear?
If someone like Caramel Arrow or Crunchy Chip were to take it, he'd feel too self-concious to tell them he wants it back. He's an adult after all. He shouldn't need a comfort blanket. So he'd just find a quite place to sulk
(Caramel Arrow didn't mean any harm. She just greatly underestimated how attached Cacao got to that plushie. Luckily peach blossom was there to tell her to give it back)
Alternatively, if Mystic Flour were to take it...