30 days was a slap on the wrist for soldiers who handed the world a viral propaganda gift while Israel's most important allies are Christians.
Sick of hearing about it? Good! Join us in demanding that the IDF punish such behavior with more than a slap on the wrist so we never have to hear about this sort of thing again.
"It's a fucking statue, it's been replaced"
The act, however, is still online.
The IDF can't un-upload the clip. The international damage wasn't caused by the broken statue, but by the posting. These are two different problems, and fixing one does not fix the other.
"And for some reason, Jews on this fucking site can't stop self-flagellating about it"
We're not self-flagellating. We're calling assholes assholes, same as we did when ISIS or the Taliban destroyed the religious iconography of others. We're being morally consistent and we urge you to give moral consistency a try.
The IDF (rightly, IMO) calls itself the most moral army in the world. Holding it to its own stated standard is the minimum required for the claim to mean anything. Demanding that it not behave like ISIS, the Taliban, or any of the desecrators in our own history is a very @#$%ing low bar to clear.
"...even when they knew that antisemites are going to use said self-flagellation against any Jew they don't like.
Yes, my clueless friend. That's one of the reasons we condemn it. It was an unforced error. It was shooting Am Yisrael in the foot. It was a gift to Jew haters that they'll use to generate more hate.
We're not pleased about that. It's weird that you don't understand why.
"imagine if the world had gotten as upset over the murder of over 1,000 Jews and the destruction of entire Jewish towns as they're getting over a chunk of plaster."
A thousand Jews were murdered. Entire communities were destroyed. The world's response to this was and remains obscene.
But people are getting away with murdering Jews is not a counter-argument to soldiers who desecrate religious icons on camera should face serious consequences.
Crimes should not be committed against Jews is not in conflict with IDF soldiers should not emulate the @#$%ing Taliban and ISIS.
Anon doesn't seem to understand why this so violated Jewish values.
Anon, two things can be true at the same time:
Violence against Jews is unacceptable to Jews.
Violently destroying the religious iconography of others is unacceptable to Jews.
Most Jews have no difficulty holding these two ideas simultaneously in mind - without any cognitive dissonance - because it violates our values and ignores the parts of our history when people desecrated our sacred places.
That's why they rightly condemn this behavior.
Interestingly, Anon can't hold these two ideas simultaneously in mind.
This isn't a condemnation of Jews on Tumblr, Anon...but it sure says a lot about you.