silly spn polls

yes

no

one of the boys has to step in as a last minute understudy

claire novak also attends this high school

sam and dean get cast shirts at the end of it

marie sends them a dvd copy of the performance in the mail

a rival boys school is ALSO doing a supernatural musical

the episode takes place at either the glee or high school musical schools

becky publishes a review

dramatic ballad version of the ghostfacers theme song

marie actually sends dean links to fics

chuck sues marie anne rice style

clue style follow up bottle episode trying to find the demon at the wrap party

one or both of the boys gets called zaddy

just throw it in my purse and hope i can find it later

under my arm like a football

pinching it between two fingers so i’m barely touching it (yucky!!!)

trap it under a cup like a bug

wrap it up burrito style to keep it from kicking and squirming

scoop it up with a little net like i’m transferring a goldfish

tissue paper

those net claw things they use to grab stray cats off the street

doggie waste bag

strapped to my chest like a babybjörn

princess carry

fireman carry

alastair was giving him weekly updates a la tiger beat magazine

he downloaded it from sam’s brain when visiting him in dreams as jess

chuck put a tv in there and it has excellent reception

that was his first priority upon escaping the cage

it’s a lingering effect from nick’s personality

he could get visitors in the cage and one of his brothers told him

he was trying to tap into angel radio and tapped into E!News on accident

the cage does not prevent him from being able to observe humanity

chuck was sending him drafts of carver edlund’s supernatural w/ footnotes

he doesn’t - he has no idea what he’s saying but it feels right

he has an english to winchester dictionary to speak their language

he is directly responsible for pop culture and it all somehow stems from him

john winchester

castiel

claire novak

jack kline

donna hanscom

kevin tran

mary winchester

jo harvelle

victor henriksen

arthur ketch

adam milligan

rowena

powerpoint presentation

formal email from his stanford.edu email account

postcard from california after the fact

spell it out with the bullets his college savings account bought

cryptic riddle that john spends years obsessing over figuring out

alphabet fridge magnets

the worst game of pictionary you can imagine

one of those singing telegram people

an actual telegram. STOP.

he shouldn’t tell him at all. just leave. see how long it takes john to realize

start a rumor for the hunter gossip mill

write an entry for himself in john’s journal

10.05 Fan Fiction takes places at McKinley High from Glee

2.01 In My Time of Dying takes place in the Greys Anatomy hospital

Shawn Spencer from Psych is one of Azazel’s special children

The Bailey School Kids investigate Castiel

4.13 After School Special takes place at the school from Degrassi

Sam and Dean hunt Danny Phantom

The town that Sam & Cas investigate in 14.15 Peace of Mind is Riverdale

Demon!Dean and Crowley go for a night out with the demons from The Good Place

6.20 The Man Who Would Be King but everyone except Cas is a muppet

Kuzko from The Emperor’s New Groove commentates on an episode of your choice

It’s a regular episode but at the end Rod Serling comes out

Jesse Pinkman is Endverse!Castiel’s dealer in 5.04 The End

pro

anti

a surviving special child angry at sam for killing azazel and taking their power

*sigh* somehow… lucifer has returned

jesse the antichrist is back and he may have gone a teeny bit power hungry

worlds first murder victim MAY have a bit of a grudge about it - abel

godstiel part two - this time it’s jack being controlled by chuck’s power

uh oh! getting cas out of the empty accidentally released everything in there!

another men of letters chapter house from a country of your choice

monsters unionize and it’s a “hunters become the hunted” type thing

jesus christ has risen and HE wants to be the new god

did anyone ever follow up on that online monster organ trafficking thing

eric kripke

we are - the fan base that doesn’t want carver edlund’s supernatural to be over

wanted to look nice for the michael sword and took too long getting ready

got lost because SOMEBODY 👀 wasn’t willing to stop and ask for directions

the guy responsible for checking on dean was in the bathroom when dean died

they very politely asked hell about dean and hell said they’d never heard of him

they didn’t know which one dean was

they kept pulling over for tourist traps like hell’s biggest ball of twine

castiel had the hell rescue double-booked with his 10,000th lobotomy

michael prefers his meatsuit well-done over medium-rare

anna was originally supposed to do it and she had all the instructions

whatever the angelic version of a flat tire is - flat halo? clipped wings?

king bitch zachariah voice: it’s called fashionably late for a reason

slept through their alarm

there were they were just in a separate warehouse

cas had no compunctions about killing sam and did not need the practice

naomi didn’t know there was a second brother

castiel needed so much time with the dean clones they didn’t have time for sam

those weren’t even dean clones naomi just thinks that’s what humans look like

naomi doesn’t remember which one is sam and is which is adam

naomi couldn’t find the sam clones in heavens supply closet

naomi couldn’t remember what sam looks like (hair… tall……….jeans?)

they started with sam and all those clones got buried by the dean ones

the sam clones are on the ceiling mary winchester style and we just didn’t see

naomi somehow knew sam and cas would not get into that situation

cas lost against the sam clones and naomi had to wipe them away

sam names the dog he adopts in between s7 and s8 “dean”

daphne allen is a man

benny lafitte is a werewolf instead of a vampire

garth killed santa claus not the tooth fairy

carver edlund’s supernatural is a comic book series

1976!john bought that van instead of the impala and that’s what they drive

dean has a pirate fetish instead of a cowboy one

sam goes bald

rufus and bobby live together but still aren’t speaking in s3

castiel wears the ugliest sweater you’ve ever seen instead of the trenchcoat

sam is an actual literal dexter-style serial killer (i’m thinking stanford era)