Private Eyes IX
Pairing: Joel Miller x f!reader
Summary: When you woke up this morning in the arms of a certain chief of police you did not think even for a second the day would end in the way it did. With you and Joel Miller on a date - just not with each other.
Note: I'm back (and hopefully) better than ever.
Part 1 , Part 2 , Part 3, Part 4, Part 5, Part 6, Part 7, Part 8
Tag List: @kellyxo1 @alitaar @suzysface @brinapedroswife
"You slept with him?" Lucy screams so loudly that you have to lift the phone from your ear in order to avoid your eardrum from rupturing.
"Jesus, Lucy," you sigh, pulling another shirt from the trash bag and looking at it.
"I can't believe you slept with Joel Fucking Miller!"
"Keep it down," you hiss, throwing the shirt on the donation pile. "And I didn't sleep with him!"
You hear a ruffling and some animal sounds on the other side of the line. "Who is supposed to hear, huh? It's just the Mean Girls and me out here."
The "Mean Girls" are a couple of feisty, older chickens that don't really lay eggs anymore, but Lucy keeps in a little coop near her house to roam free and get up to all kinds of mischief. You can hear her sit down and exhale. "So did you or did you not take our trusted chief for some afternoon delight?"
"Why did you just say that? You sound like my uncle Jeff."
"Answer the question, babe."
You sigh. "We did sleep next to each other, but nothing really happened."
"What do you mean by really?" Lucy asks.
"Well," you start, sitting down on the chair by the window. "Something minor happened, but he was sleeping or dreaming or whatever so it doesn't really count."
"I'm sorry, did you just say minor? Please, elaborate on that."
You sigh and tell her what happened this morning. There is a long stretch of silence where you wonder whether Lucy has fallen into a ditch and then she screams again.
"Oh my god!" Lucy exclaims. "We definitely need to reevaluate your system for ranking the kind of somethings that happen with other people. And if it happened, it counts."
"He was dreaming. It wasn't real," you say.
"He obviously was acting out his own dream, which means he was dreaming about you, which means you have made it into his subconsciousness, which makes it even more major," Lucy says, some of the chickens shrieking in the distance, "way to go, femme fatale."
"It was just a dream," you insist, "I dream about all kinds of stupid stuff that I don't necessarily want to happen in real life."
"I can totally call Tara and hear what she has to say about it. She usually does like card readings, but she can definitely do a dream reading for you."
"Please don't tell a soul," you say, "you have to promise me, Lucy."
"I was joking, I won't tell anyone," she says. "And I'll have a stern word with the Girls about their silence on this."
"What the fuck am I doing, Luce?" You say, burying your head in your left hand. "They're all downstairs. If my brother knew, he'd-"
"But he doesn't," Lucy interrupts, "and he won't suspect anything weird, if you just keep it together for another twenty minutes and then you're out of there. Don't you also have to be ready soon for later?"
Right. Later. You had almost forgotten in all of this mess. The mess that had started a while back but probably only really made you rethink your position when Joel opened his front door this morning.
The silence is deafening. It is so quiet that even the sound of the birds announcing the day is unsettling. There are exactly four pairs of eyes staring at you right this moment. Each of them oozing that particular shade of confusion when you have no idea what the fuck is going on. Except one pair, which is just staring with a twinkle that suggests amusement rather than shock.
Maybe this is why Tommy is the first to speak out of all of them. The moment he opens his mouth you feel Joel tense up next to you even more.
"Oh great, you came!" Tommy exclaims and starts to make his way up the porch. He quickly closes the distance between you two and engulfs you into a tight hug that leaves his mouth very close to your right ear, where he whispers an almost silent "Smile and nod" into it.
So you do as you're told for once and smile, moving your head in a nodding motion. Tommy lets go of you and turns back to the boys.
"What are you doing here?" Casey asks, setting down the cooler hanging over his shoulder.
You open your mouth to say something, but Tommy grabs your shoulder. "I told her to come."
"Why?" Casey frowns.
"I've got all this shit stored in Joel's guest room because of the renovations and I told her she could come and look through it while we all play."
"Clearly she's already started," Casey says, pointing to your pants, "what are you even wearing?"
You shrug, looking down at Joel's pyjama pants. "I needed new loungewear."
Casey shakes his head, grinning. "You've always been a bit of a snoop, I guess."
"Do you even know how much vintage clothes are worth these days?" You say and try to sound as casual as you can.
"But this is boys brunch," one of the other guys says.
"You'll just have to endure the presence of a woman for once, Charlie," Tommy says.
Charlie huffs and the others chuckle, while making their way into the house. When Casey passes you, he shakes his head. "If you want to eat, you will have to help make breakfast."
"Aye, brother," you say and salute him playfully.
Once everyone has shuffled inside, Joel shuts the door, a firm, tight grip on the handle. He exhales audibly, but does not turn toward you. You can hear the men talking in the kitchen, rummaging around, the sound of a table being set filling the air.
"Why didn't you tell me they were coming?" You say.
"I forgot." Joel closes his eyes for a couple of seconds, then opens them. "It was supposed to be next week, Casey moved it up so he could take the league out of state for a game next weekend."
"Jesus," you say, running your hands over your face.
"I think you should go," he says.
You frown. "Are you crazy? If I leave now, my brother will definitely think something is off."
"And now he doesn't?"
"Now he just thinks I may have hit my head a little too much as a child," you say, leaning back against the wall. "So nothing out of the ordinary."
Joel hums and turns around. "Okay."
"Okay?" You say, "that's it?"
"Yes, that's it." He gives you a stern glance and walks toward the kitchen without another word.
And now you're sitting up here in Joel's guest room that has now turned into Tommy's storage unit, sorting through old clothes, sports equipment and CDs, while trying to convince Lucy that you definitely did not take the older Miller brother for any kind of delight. At least consciously, on purpose.
"You still there?" Lucy takes you out of your spinning mind.
"Yes, sorry," you say, "I should probably get going."
"Sure, sure," she says. "Let me know how everything turns out and definitely text me later."
You tell her you will and hang up the phone right as someone knocks on the door.
"Yes?" You say and the door of the guest room opens slowly. You don't think you do, but once you see who is standing in the doorway, you realise that you'd wished for someone else to come looking for you up here.
Tommy grins and steps into the room. "Find anything worth saving yet?"
"Tons," you say, pointing toward the pile in front of you. "You've got some cool stuff."
"I'm glad," Tommy says, taking a glance over his shoulder and taking another step into the room, leaving the door ajar.
"Thanks by the way," you say, "for your help."
"Don't mention it." Tommy waves it off. "Listen-"
"It's not what it looks like," you say and Tommy's eyebrows rise.
"It's not?"
You shake your head. "No, it's not."
"So you guys didn't almost get killed on a routine check up by some crazy dude out in the field and Joel let you stay here so you wouldn't have to explain that to your parents?"
Your eyes widen at his deduction.
"Oh, yes, then it's exactly what it looks like," you correct and Tommy nods.
"Thought so," he says, pushing his longer locks behind his ears.
"How did you know?" Your eyebrows drawing into a frown.
"Tyler is a friend of mine."
"Oh right, the paramedic. Who else knows?"
"No one," Tommy says, "the boys in blue are a tight knit bunch."
"Good," you exhale.
Tommy crosses his arms. "You could have been killed."
"I know," you say. "Did you tell Casey?"
Tommy chuckles. "If your brother knew, do you really think you would be sitting here right now?"
"Fair enough."
"You need to be more careful."
"Please," you lift a hand. "I've already had enough lectures from your brother on this topic."
"Figures," Tommy says.
"Then please spare me the speech."
"Listen," Tommy says, "I know what he can be like, you know. But- but he's just trying to-
"Protect me, I know," you say.
Tommy shakes his head. "That too. But I meant to say that it's his way of showing that he cares."
"About what?"
"About you."
You hold Tommy's gaze. He's almost got the same eyes as Joel, just not as dark, always light, always friendly, always giving you a good feeling while you're looking at them. But now they're conveying a notion that you might not be ready to comprehend yet.
"He's doing his job, Tommy. Nothing more, nothing less."
"He's not made of stone, Darling. Keep that in mind," Tommy says and turns to open the door. "Now let's get you home, shall we? I'll have Casey pick up those clothes some other time."
You nod and get up to follow him down the stairs into the living room where you can already hear the boys laughing from the adjacent dining area. Trying to catch Joel's eye, you look around the table, but find him cleaning dishes in the kitchen. Casey spots you first.
"Find some good stuff?"
"Sure did", you say, walking past him into the kitchen.
Joel's back is turned to you, his shoulders flexing with every move of his arm, scrubbing the pan in the sink. He doesn't look up, his face taut.
"Do you need any help with that?" You ask, tentatively.
A quick shake of his head. "No, I got it." His eyes flash to the side, barely grazing you before focusing on the sink again. The sound of the water splashing against the metal fills the room, mixing with Casey's voice resounding from behind.
"Let's go, you don't want to be late for your hot date later," Casey calls into the kitchen.
The sound of the pan dropping loudly into the sink startles all of you, as Joel curses under his breath.
"Neither hot, nor a date, Casey," you correct him and again try to find Joel's gaze, who now is scrubbing at that pan like he's trying to make a genie pop out. You can't deny yourself the short peak at his hands, dripping wet, covered in remaining bits of foam carelessly sliding across, probably slightly warm from the water.
"Agree to disagree," Casey says and knocks on the door frame. "Thanks again for hosting, Joel."
Joel grunts something and Casey leaves the kitchen, shouting another lets go across his shoulder.
"Listen-" You start, but Joel cuts you off.
"You sure move fast, Darlin'," he drawls, so viciously, it wouldn't surprise you if venom were dripping from his teeth.
"Are you serious?" You say, crossing your arms.
He shakes his head, a single lock slipping into his eyes. "And here I thought I was getting special treatment."
Despite his words, Joel's face is a trained mask of indifference.
"Is that it?" You say, "Want me to tell you you're special, Joel? That you're a good boy?"
He turns off the faucet and meets your gaze, eyes like ice. "You get on your knees for him too or is that just for me?"
You scoff. "Maybe I will," you say, "and I'll make sure he'll be awake to enjoy it."
The mask slips for a split second, his jaw ticking just the slightest bit, a wave of uneasiness grazing across his face.
"He will as much as the next guy."
As you hear Casey honk outside a couple of times, you shake your head and turn to walk out of the kitchen.
"I hope you were paying attention while it lasted, Miller," you say, "because to you, it's never going to happen again."
You don't wait for his answer, but make your way out of his house in quick long strides toward your brother's car, hoping that your pride wasn't the only thing you've left behind in Joel Miller's house.
Sebastian is waiting for you in front of the restaurant. He had offered to pick you up, but you felt like giving him your home address would make this outing much less official than it needed to be. Lori had reminded you a week ago that his office had called multiple times to schedule a date and she needed you to confirm one of three suggested time slots. You reminded yourself that this was all for a good cause and even though Joel had told you repeatedly to refrain from letting the mayor cash in his prize, you figured that a dinner wouldn't hurt. And you had promise Lori, whose bad side you definitely did not want to be on.
As if on cue, his eyes light up in a sparkle as he spots you walking towards him.
"Hello there," he says and without any hesitation engulfs you in a hug that isn't necessarily intimate but definitely unprofessional. "You look like a vision."
"Thank you, Sebastian," you say, glancing down at your dress. In the end Lucy had decided on this one. After a long time of going back and forth whether smart casual or casual would be the best choice, instead Lucy had decided on a dress long enough to be decent, but short enough to be lit up by fire upon entering a church.
"Shall we?" He asks and you take his arm. You're surprised to find that the place is packed and as you prepare to wait in the line in front of the reception desk, Sebastian leads you past it and with a nod toward the waiter, walks straight toward the back of the restaurant. At the table in the very corner of the back end, Sebastian comes to a halt and motions for you to slide into the booth, facing the restaurant.
"I've taken the liberty of having my team preselect our menu for tonight. I hope that agrees with you," he says, "I made sure to check with your secretary for any allergies."
"You mean Lori?"
"Yes," he says.
You shrug, never liking people making decisions for you. "That's okay."
"So tell me, are you already bored of the field work and can't wait to join my team?"
You chuckle. "And what makes you think that?"
Sebastian leisurely leans back in his chair. "The last time I recall your boss being pretty adamant about you not leaving the station or his sight for that matter."
"He doesn't take well to disrespect."
"He doesn't take to respect either, it seems."
Obviously, you're fed up with the chief today, but the way this conversation is headed does not suit you in the slightest.
"He's always been respectful with me," you say.
Sebastian waves it off. "Enough talk of your boss. I'd rather know how you ended up back here for the summer after deciding to leave."
So you tell him. The conversation is easy and flows, attributing mainly to Sebastian's skilled way of questioning and your decision to be open and honest. He does not speak much of himself and by the main course you don't think you've learned anything else about him apart his love for the X-Files and that he grew up with two sisters.
He's just interested enough, funny enough and smart enough to not be boring. The swoop of his hair is straight out of a hallmark movie and looking at him makes you wish there was something at least a little crooked in his appearance. It's a charming enough date and as you're wondering if he's actually thinking this might lead to something, Sebastian excuses himself to take a call.
After a couple of minutes he returns, looking a little flushed.
"Everything okay?"
"Yes," he nods his head and chuckles, "I mean, it is a small town, but what are the odds, huh?"
You frown. "I'm not following."
"It's funny because we just talked about him."
"About whom?"
"Your boss, the chief," Sebastian declares, "I just ran into him at the entrance. I think he's on a date."
The noise of the restaurant morphs into a distant murmur in the back of your head. "He is what?"
Sebastian leans in a little, as if your question gave the impression of a secret to be discussed between you two, an alliance about to be formed. "He was standing with a woman, waiting to be seated. Oh, and she was holding onto his arm. Seemed like a date to me."
You shake your head. "I can't believe it," you mutter.
"Right? I don't think I've ever seen him on a date since I've started in local politics. And that was like fifteen years ago."
You look up at Sebastian. "Would you excuse me for a moment?"
He seems surprised but immediately covers his expression with that of calm understanding. "Of course."
You nod and slide out of the booth. You can't believe it. The fucking nerve that man has. It's not even been two hours. How on earth did he get a date this quickly?
You make your way toward the front of the restaurant and are sure Sebastian has made a mistake, has seen some other man looking just like Joel from the back, but when your eyes scan the room, they find themselves stopping at a table by the window. The woman has her back toward you as you walk past at a safe distance, her dark brown hair falling in soft waves across her back. She's wearing a long flowery dress and at least from behind, she looks lovely. He's telling a story, smiling easily.
Nothing could have prepared you for the way your stomach drops as his eyes flick up to yours. You now realise that there had been an easiness to him before, a calm, sort of collected demeanour that disappeared right as he caught your glance. He is wearing a pitch black long-sleeve, making him look like a different person you haven't met, like he could be anyone. A trimmed beard and neatly tucked hair. An almost boyish allure to him. You see him lowering his glass of wine back onto the white tablecloth, a certain confusion on his face that is replaced by something entirely different almost immediately. Something you cannot quite place. You just know that you can't hold his gaze for longer and break away toward the restrooms before you make a fool out of yourself.
The cold water on your cheeks does little to actually cool the temper you feel rising up inside your chest. What the fuck is he even doing here? How did he know? And did he know or is this just some fucked up way of the universe to make me face the consequences of my decisions? Why now, Jesus?
Regaining the minimum amount of composure, you step out of the restroom, into the little hallway, where there are two velvet chairs and a rack of postcards with silly jokes on them. As you wonder who would sit down in front of the restrooms, the door leading back to the restaurant swings open.
You can feel him before you even see him, the sound of his steps against the tiled floor giving him away almost instantly. Waiting for the blow that you know is coming, you inhale deeply before turning your head towards him. Joel comes to a halt about two steps away from you. As if he were trying to create a safe distance, a risk management measure to reject any unwanted behaviour. He opens his mouth but you're faster and way more riled up.
"What the fuck are you doing here, Miller?" Your voice comes out less like a growl and more like a hiss.
"Minding my own business," he says, "as should you."
"And were you going to do that before or after you crash my date?"
"I'm not crashing anything," he states matter of factly.
"You do realise that a couple of hours ago you were giving me shit about coming here and now I find out from Sebastian of all people you're on a date?"
Joel's jaw hardens. "You're here with the mayor?"
"Yes," you say. "He saw you outside."
"Of course you are," Joel scoffs, "you like assholes now, huh?"
"Fits right in with you, doesn't it?"
His nostrils flare for a second. "I told you not to go out with him."
"It's part of the auction deal, Miller."
"I did not sign off on that," he states.
"He arranged it with Lori last week," you say.
He curtly shakes his head. "No one runs anything by me anymore, Jesus Christ!"
"I'm just holding up my end of the bargain."
"And what does that entail?"
"It's a business dinner."
"That doesn't answer my question," Joel says.
The door to the restaurant opens and before you can step away from Joel, he has grabbed your arm and pulled you through a door off to the side into a dark room.
"What the-" You start.
Then Joel turns on the light, which is just a lightbulb dangling from the ceiling, illuminating the small room just enough to see that it's the supply closet. As if it had just occurred to you know, you begin to feel that the distance between you and Joel has disappeared entirely. Maybe a hand could fit between you two now. The faint light is almost entirely swallowed by the dark of his eyes, staring down at you. His breath is warm against your lips. You can sense the faint smell of wine. Being in such a close proximity to him, knowing what happened just a couple of hours ago, where is hand had been, it feels almost unreal. Dreamlike.
"What are you doing?" You ask.
"I need you to answer the damn question," Joel replies, sternly.
"He's just getting what he bought at the auction."
"Special treatment?" Joel furrows his brows.
"Dinner, Joel," you reply, "who do you think I am?"
"If it's just dinner, why are you wearing that fucking dress?" As if on their own accord, his eyes move down your body, grazing along the shape of your dress. Daringly clinging to its curves.
"Because I like it!" You hiss.
"Does he get to take it off? Is that part of the bargain too?" He asks, mockingly.
You scoff. "You're unbelievable you know that? How dare you ask me that question when you've managed to find someone else to spend the evening with in under two hours?"
Joel runs a hand over his face. "It's not what it looks like."
"Sure," you say, "when has that line ever worked? You're such a fucking hypocrite, Miller."
"I'm a hypocrite?" Joel's voice raises its volume ever so slightly. "You knew that you were going out with him for a week and you didn't tell me. You know I fucking hate that guy and how he treats people. He's the reason we need to have a fucking auction because he's pulled most of the funding. You sat on my couch knowing that. And now he gets to sit across from you and look at you in that dress undisturbed and I have to watch. So don't give me that feigned innocence."
"I thought Lori would-"
"You wore my clothes and slept in my bed, goddammit," Joel interrupts, his finger pointing to his own chest, pressing down on the dark fabric of his shirt. "You should have told me."
"Why does it matter? You would have told me not to go and I still would have ended up going."
"It matters to me," he says.
"I didn't try to purposefully keep it from you," you say earnestly. And to be real, you had just forgotten to tell him about it. Especially after what had happened yesterday, it didn't occur to you that it might have mattered anymore.
"Your knees were on my floor," he whispers.
You have grown silent, as he inhales shakily.
He steps away from you. "I should go."
"If it's so fucking important to you who I go out with, why don't you just do something on purpose instead of waiting for your dreams to do it for you?"
Joel's face hardens visibly even in the dim light. "You know I can't," he says.
"Sure you can," you say, "you just won't."
"We're done here." Joel turns toward the door and opens it without another word.
"Coward," you say under your breath as he leaves the closet and shuts the door forcefully behind him.
You lean your back against the wall and exhale heavily. "Fuck." You let your eyes close for a second, trying to gather the strength to leave a room for the third time today. After a couple of seconds, as you step forward to reach for the handle, you hear steps outside. Not wanting to explain to someone why you're hiding in the supply closet, you patiently wait for the footsteps to fade out. But they don't.
Intuition makes you move away from the door right before it is pushed open as forcefully as it just had been shut a minute ago. Joel's body takes up the whole doorway for two seconds, before he moves inside, closing the door behind him. You're looking at him confused. His body is tense, the palm of his hands curled into fists by his legs and his face pulled into that stoney exterior you have grown to recognise. Joel's eyes take their time wandering down your figure and back up again. It is almost a lifetime later, as he relives you both and closes the distance between your worlds.
You hadn't known that in the highest moment of life, it could also feel so close to death. Your life flashing before your eyes in those pivotal moments. Or rebirth. Like something kicking and screaming and clawing its way into the light, cutting through the surface. Sharply. Indifferent of anything but its will to live, demanding to be recognised, to be heard. That is what it feels like when Joel's lips find yours. An almost animalistic, intrinsic intuition that there is only going to be a before and after now and that nothing in your life will ever be the same.







