Begin Again ~ John Logan x Fem!Reader - (Part Two)
Synopsis: After a painful breakup leaves you struggling to trust anyone again, an unexpected friendship with Briar hockey star John Logan becomes the brightest part of your week. But when a misunderstanding convinces you he's never felt the same way, you'll have to decide whether risking your heart one more time is worth the chance at something real.
Part One: read here.
My other Logan fics here: read here.
A/N: The finale - hope you enjoyed this one! :)
Taglist: @cosmosnkaz @parker-barnes-af @thecraziestcrayon @asterizee @nihoshi17 @ch3ska0 @wilmonyibo7 @hrollingcookie @solstice-333 @steadybelieverbanana
PART TWO
The following Wednesday arrived carrying one of those strange early spring afternoons where it was just starting to warm up.
The morning had been cold enough to justify a jacket, but by lunchtime, students were scattered across the quad in short sleeves, convinced that winter was finally over.
As you crossed campus toward the coffee shop, the weather now was accompanied by a small breeze that lifted strands of hair across your face every few steps.
A few months ago, Wednesdays had been ordinary. They were just another forgettable day that was buried beneath classes, assignments, and the exhausting process of trying to put yourself back together after someone had broken your trust.
Now, somehow, Wednesdays belonged to Logan. Or, at least, they felt that way.
You found yourself looking forward to them long before they arrived. They had become important.
As the coffee shop came into view, you automatically glanced toward the windows, searching for a familiar dark head of hair. You didn’t see him.
The disappointment arrived so quickly that it almost annoyed you. He was probably running late, or practice ran over.
Your thoughts stopped. A few feet away from the entrance on the opposite side, Logan stood near the outdoor tables. He wasn’t alone.
At first, you didn’t think much of it. People talked to him constantly. He was one of the most recognizable people on campus, thanks to being a star hockey player. It wasn’t unusual to see someone stop him between classes.
Then the girl turned slightly. It was the same girl from the coffee shop, the one who had stopped by your table a couple of weeks ago. The one who had greeted Logan with the kind of easy familiarity that had bothered you far more than you’d been willing to admit.
For a moment, you remained exactly where you were. You were far enough away that neither of them noticed you, but close enough to see the conversation unfolding. The girl laughed at something Logan said, like she’d heard him make a hundred jokes before.
Logan smiled back at her. The sight shouldn’t have affected you, he smiled at everyone. You told yourself to keep walking, that you were being ridiculous. Then, the girl stepped forward and Logan wrapped his arms around her. It was the kind of high exchanged between people who knew each other well. It was nothing that should have shattered the fragile confidence you’d spent months rebuilding.
Yet somehow, standing there on the sidewalk watching something that was probably completely innocent, you felt the ground shift beneath your feet. Suddenly every fear you’d been keeping at bay surged forward all at once.
It was the fear about yourself and that you’d done it again; you’d mistaken kindness for affection. That you’d taken a collection of small moments and transformed them into something bigger than they were. The coffee order he’d remember. The texts after games. The way his face seemed to brighten when he saw you.
You’d let yourself believe that those things meant something. Not because Logan had promised they did, but because you’d wanted them to. Maybe that had been the mistake. Maybe you had spent so much time enjoying the way he made you feel that you’d forgotten to ask whether he felt anything at all.
The hug ended, and the girl said something that made Logan laugh again. A second later, he reached for the coffee shop door. Panic swept through you so quickly that thinking became impossible. If he looked up now, he’d see you. He’d smile, maybe wave and ask why you were standing there.
You suddenly didn’t trust yourself to act normal. You didn’t trust yourself not to reveal every stupid feeling you’d spent weeks to hide.
Before he could turn in your direction, you pivoted and started walking. Fast. Not running, but just walking quickly enough that the coffee shop disappeared behind the next building before you could change your mind.
The entire trip back to your dorm had felt unreal. It was like your body was on autopilot while your thoughts spiraled several steps behind.
The first text arrived twenty minutes later.
Logan: where are you?
You were sitting on the edge of your bed when your phone lit up, still wearing your coat. Your bag was abandoned somewhere near your desk where you’d dropped it the second you walked through the door.
For a moment, you only stared at the message. It made your chest ache, because you could picture him too clearly. You could imagine him sitting at your usual table, coffee cooling beside his laptop, glancing at the door every few minutes with that slight furrow between his eyebrows he got whenever he was trying to figure something out. He’d probably waited at first, and then checked the time.
You hated that you knew him well enough to imagine all of that. You hated that the thought of disappointing him mattered.
What were you supposed to say?
Sorry, I saw you hug a girl and realized that I’m in love with you so I panicked and fled?
Nope. Absolutely not. A second message arrived quickly.
Logan: Did something happen?
It wasn’t annoyed, or casual. He was concerned. You pressed your palms against your eyes and took a breath that didn’t do much to steady you. The mature thing would be to answer. The reasonable thing would be to tell him that you were fine, that something had come up, and that you’d see him soon. Anything would have been better than silence.
But all reason had gone out of the window the moment you saw his arms around someone else. So, you did nothing.
By the next morning, he texted twice again. Nothing dramatic, or that made him seem angry.
Logan: Hey, just checking in
Logan: are you okay?
You read both, standing in the middle of your dorm with your toothbrush still in your hand, and the guilt that washed over you was heavy.
Logan didn’t deserve this, that was the worst part. He hadn’t done anything wrong. He hadn’t promised you he was interested, he didn’t ask for you to wait for him. He hadn’t even known you were outside of the coffee shop, watching one ordinary moment crack open every single insecurity you’d been trying so hard to bury.
This wasn’t his fault; it was yours. Your feelings. Your assumptions. Your stupid, fragile hope.
Still, you couldn’t make yourself respond. For the rest of the week, you became an expert in avoidance.
You stopped going to the coffee shop, because the idea of walking past your table and finding it empty made your chest feel tight. You took longer routes between classes, keeping your head down whenever you passed by the athletic center. You stopped checking the hockey scores. You turned your phone over whenever it buzzed because part of you wanted it to be Logan, and the other part of you was terrified it would be.
By Saturday afternoon, the routine you’d built with him had been replaced by a routine of avoiding him. You were in the library when your phone vibrated against the table.
Logan: okay, now I’m officially worried
Logan: if I did something, please just tell me what it is
You stared at the words for so long that they started to blur together. That was finally what made the shame settle in. He was somewhere thinking he’d done something to upset you, and you were letting him believe it because admitting the truth felt far too humiliating.
You had just unlocked your phone, though you had no idea what you had planned to type, when a shadow fell across the table. Every muscle in your body went still. You didn’t need to look up, somehow, you knew exactly who it was.
Logan stood on the other side of the table, his hockey bag slung over one shoulder and his hair slightly damp, like he’d come straight from practice. He looked tired, but more than that, he looked relieved in a way that made your chest ache before he even said a word.
“There you are,” he said quietly.
Your fingers tightened around your phone.
“Hi.”
It was a terrible thing to say.
Logan stared at you for a moment, as if he were waiting for you to offer literally anything else. When you didn’t, he pulled out the chair across from you and sat down.
He had the quiet determination of someone who had decided he wasn’t leaving until he understood what had gone wrong.
“What the hell is going on?” he asked.
For a moment, all you could do was stare at him. Your entire body felt locked in place. This conversation had existed in your imagination for days, but every version you’d imagined ended with you escaping it.
His gaze never left your face. The concern on it made everything worse. He looked worried.
“You haven’t answered a single text,” he said. His voice remained calm, but there was frustration underneath now.
“You stopped showing up. Then I saw you leave one of your classes yesterday the second you spotted me,” he said. He leaned back slightly in his chair, studying you.
Heat flooded your face.
“You’ve been avoiding me.” His words weren’t really a question.
You looked down at the table.
“Maybe.”
A disbelieving laugh escaped him, “Maybe?”
You winced. Okay, that hadn’t sounded great. When you looked up at him again, he was still watching you with that same stubborn patience that had somehow become one of your favorite things about him.
“I don’t understand,” he said quietly.
He genuinely didn’t know, which meant if you told him the truth, you’d have to admit just how deeply you’d misread everything.
“Nothing happened.”
The second the words left your mouth, you knew they were useless. Logan knew it too. His eyebrows lifted.
“Seriously?”
You looked away, “Okay, something happened.”
“That’s progress.”
Despite everything, the corner of your mouth almost twitched. Almost. Logan noticed anyway.
“Just tell me.”
You wished it were that easy. If this conversation were only about the girl, maybe it would have been. But, it wasn’t. The girl had simply exposed a problem that had already existed; the problem was sitting across from him. It was somewhere between coffee shop Wednesdays and late-night texts about his roommates, that you’d fallen in love with him.
Every word felt dangerous. You took a slow breath, and finally spoke.
“I saw you,” you said.
Confusion flickered across his face. “You saw me?” “Last Wednesday. Outside of the coffee shop.”
The confusion across his face remained for exactly two seconds. Then, understanding began to dawn. Not complete understanding, but just enough that he was following the timeline.
“I was talking to someone.”
You nodded. A humorless smile tugged briefly at your mouth.
“Yeah.”
Silence settled between you. Then, somehow, Logan looked even more confused.
“You mean Emily?”
Logan sat forward slightly, “Wait.”
His eyes narrowed, and a second later, something clicked. You saw the exact moment his brain connected all of the pieces.
“You thought Emily was my girlfriend?”
The horror that immediately flooded your body was so intense you considered climbing under the table.
“Please don’t say it like that,” you said.
“Oh my God.”
You covered your face with both hands. He stared at you, and then let out a short, stunned laugh.
“This is exactly why I didn’t want to have this conversation.”
The laugh disappeared instantly, and suddenly Logan wasn’t looking amused anymore. He was looking at you carefully, like he was realizing there was more than a misunderstanding.
And unfortunately, there was. A lot more.
“Hey,” his voice softened.
You lowered your hands slightly from your face.
“She isn’t my girlfriend.”
You nodded, “I figured that out.”
“No, I don’t think you did.”
The gentleness in his voice made your throat tighten. He wasn’t correcting a misunderstanding anymore, he was trying to understand why it had hurt. That was dangerous.
He leaned forward, forearms resting against the table.
“Emily’s my cousin.”
You closed your eyes. Of course she was. For several seconds, neither of you spoke. Logan sighed.
When he finally spoke again, his voice was quieter than before.
“That isn’t the whole reason, though,” he said.
Your heart immediately dropped, because somehow, you knew that he already knew.
“People don’t disappear for a week because of a misunderstanding.”
The words landed gently.
“You were hurt,” he stated.
“Logan—”
“You were.”
His gaze held yours.
All of a sudden, the exhaustion of the last few months came rushing back. All of the heartbreak, and fear, and the constant feeling that trusting someone again was like standing on the edge of a cliff.
You looked down at your hands.
When you finally spoke, your voice came out much smaller than you intended.
“I felt stupid,” you said.
The confession hung between you as Logan listened.
“I saw you with her and,” you laughed softly, though there was no humor in it, “I don’t know. I just realized how much I’d let myself believe.”
Silence.
“Believe what?” he asked.
You closed your eyes briefly. This is was thing you’d avoided saying, but there was no way out except for telling the truth.
“I thought maybe all of this meant something,” you whispered.
Judging by the look on Logan’s face, the words landed exactly where you were afraid they would.
Logan didn’t say anything, he just looked at you for a moment. The silence stretched long enough that embarrassment began creeping up your neck again. You immediately regretted saying it.
You dropped your gaze to the table.
“Forget it,” you said.
His response came immediately, “No.”
Your eyes lifted. He was still watching you with an intensity that made your stomach twist.
“No, we’re definitely not doing that.”
“Doing what?” you asked.
“That thing where you say something important and then immediately try to take it back. You’re not getting out of this one,” he said.
“I don’t know what you want me to say,” you said.
“The truth would be a good start.”
You stared out of the library window before looking back at him.
“The truth is that I liked spending time with you.”
“Okay,” he said.
“The truth is that Wednesdays became my favorite day of the week.”
Something unreadable flickered across his face. You pressed on before you could lose your nerve.
“The truth is that every time you text me, it makes my day better. I started going to hockey games. I started saving stories to tell you. I started…” you swallowed, “I started caring.”
The last two words barely made it out. Logan slowly leaned back in his chair, looking completely stunned. This wasn’t the reaction you’d expected.
“Wow.”
You immediately reached for your bag.
“Okay, this was a mistake,” you said, tears stinging the corner of your eyes.
“What?”
You stood so quickly that your chair nearly tipped backwards.
“This was a terrible idea,” you reiterated.
Before you could gather your things, Logan reached across the table and caught your wrist. Not hard, but just enough to make you pause.
“Would you stop trying to run away for five seconds?” he asked, the frustration in his voice startling you.
You slowly sank back into your chair. Logan dragged a hand through his hair and looked toward the ceiling.
For a moment, he actually laughed.
“You have got to be kidding me,” he said.
Your stomach twisted.
“That’s not usually the response people hope for.”
His eyes snapped to yours, “No, that’s not—”
He stopped, exhaled, and started again.
“What exactly did you think was happening here?” he asked.
You blinked, “What?”
“Seriously. What did you think all of this was?”
He leaned forward again. You stared at him.
“Friendship?” you said.
Logan just looked at you, and then laughed again, “Friendship.”
The way he repeated the word made heat immediately rush to your face.
“You thought I spent months finding excuses to see you every week because I wanted friendship?”
Your pulse began hammering.
“Logan…”
“I’m genuinely asking, " His eyes never left yours, “I want to know.”
You opened your mouth and closed it again.
Logan let out another breath. Then, quieter this time, he said, “You think I memorized your coffee order because I wanted to be friendly?”
You could literally hear your own heartbeat.
“You think I texted you after every away game because I wanted to be friendly?”
Your chest tightened.
“You think I spent half of the season looking for you in the stands at my games because I wanted to be friendly?”
The words hit one after another, each one landing directly in the center of your chest. Logan’s expression had softened completely now, and in its place was something infinitely more dangerous: affection.
“You really, really, thought I was doing all of this because I wanted to be friends?”
“I didn’t know what to think.”
Logan held your gaze for a few seconds, and then a smile appeared.
“I was trying to take you on a date.”
“What?” you asked.
“I’ve been trying to figure out how to take you on a date for two months.”
You stared at him. There’s no way you heard him correctly.
“You… you like me?”
His expression turned almost incredulous.
“Of course I like you.”
His words were immediate and so certain. For months, you’d prepared yourself for rejection and disappointment. You had never once prepared yourself for this. For Logan to look at you like the answer should have been obvious all along.
Somewhere in the back of your mind, a voice kept insisting that you’d misunderstood. That in another moment, he would laugh and explain himself. This outcome had never been one of the possibilities that you’d allowed yourself to consider.
Logan’s expression softened.
“You don’t believe me,” he said.
You immediately shook your head, “No, that’s not—”
But you stopped, because lying felt pointless. You looked down at your hands.
“I want to. So badly,” you said.
When Logan finally spoke, his voice was softer than you’ve ever heard it.
“Then what’s stopping you?”
You knew the answer immediately, and you knew you had to tell him.
“I trusted someone before. I trusted him completely.”
You hated how vulnerable the words felt.
“You know what the worst part was? It wasn’t even finding out. It was realizing I’d missed it. I kept thinking back to every conversation, every excuse, every weird feeling I had ignored.”
Your chest felt tight.
You continued, “Afterward, it felt so obvious. Then, I started wondering what else I was wrong about.”
The silence that followed felt heavy. It wasn’t the cheating or the breakup that was the real wound. It was the doubt, the constant uncertainty, and the feeling that your own judgement couldn’t be trusted anymore.
When you looked back at Logan, his expression had changed. There was no pity in his eyes, or discomfort. Just understanding.
“You want to know what I thought when I saw you with her?” you asked.
His eyebrows furrowed slightly.
“I didn’t think you were lying to me or doing anything wrong. I just thought I’d done it again. I thought I’d convinced myself something was there when it wasn’t.”
The admission finally settled into the open. Logan reached his hand across the table, gently enough to rest his hand over yours. The contact was warm.
“You know what I think?” he asked.
You shook your head.
“I think you’ve spent months waiting for something bad to happen. I think you’ve been trying really hard to not get hurt again.”
You blinked rapidly as his thumb brushed lightly against your knuckles. You looked away, because if you looked directly at him right now, you’d probably cry.
“Hey,” he said. His voice was gentle.
You looked at him.
“I’m not asking you to trust me immediately. I’m not asking you to forget what happened, and I’m definitely not asking you to pretend it didn’t hurt.”
Logan’s fingers tightened around yours.
“But I’d like a chance.”
The words settled over you. For the first time since your breakup, the idea of trusting someone felt scary, but it didn’t feel impossible.
“So,” he said.
“So?”
“Can I finally take you on a date?”
A laugh escaped you before you could stop it. The sound echoed softly between the library shelves.
Saying yes didn’t feel so frightening. It felt right.
The walk out of the library felt strangely unreal. The afternoon sun hung low over campus as the two of you stepped outside, casting everything in shades of gold and amber.
You were too aware of the person walking beside you, and the fact that Logan’s shoulder occasionally brushed yours.
He liked you.
The realization still felt impossible.
By the time you reached the edge of the quad, neither of you seemed particularly interested in heading anywhere specific. You slowed down near a cluster of trees. The conversation between you had faded naturally, leaving something quieter behind.
Logan turned towards you, staring. Then, the corner of his mouth lifted slightly.
“There was something else I wanted to do today.”
“Oh?”
His smile widened, “Yeah.”
Your breath caught, and the look in his eyes made it impossible to misunderstand where this was heading.
Standing in the fading afternoon sunlight, all you felt was a nervous excitement that seemed to stretch from your chest all the way to your fingertips.
Logan took a small step closer to you. His gaze flicked briefly to your mouth before returning to your eyes.
When he reached up and brushed a loose strand of hair behind your ear, you didn’t pull away, you leaned into it.
The smile that appeared on his face was almost impossibly tender.
Then, he kissed you. It wasn’t rushed. It felt like relief, like coming home after a very long time. His hand remained lightly against your cheek as your eyes drifted closed.
The kiss was soft, careful, and patient. As though he was giving you every opportunity to change your mind. You didn’t.
A grin slowly spread across his face, and you kissed him again.
--
Three weeks later, Wednesday still belonged to the two of you.
Some things hadn’t changed. The coffee shop was still crowded, your table was still tucked beside the window. Logan still showed up carrying far too much caffeine.
The difference was that now, when you looked up from your laptop, he leaned down and kissed the top of your head before taking his seat.
Across the table, he reached for your hand without even thinking about it. Like, it was the most natural thing in the world. Maybe it was.
For the first time in a very long time, you weren’t thinking about what had happened before. You weren’t replaying old hurts. You weren’t waiting for something to go wrong.
You were simply here, with him, happy.
Maybe starting over wasn’t about forgetting the past.
Maybe it was finding someone who made you believe the future could be better. As Logan smiled at you from across the table that afternoon, it was impossible not to think that maybe, just maybe, that was exactly what had happened.
On a Wednesday, in a café, I watched it begin again.
ok this is cute










