If Annie, Amber, and Jenny were the Heathers/the Plastics, who would they be?
YESSAHAHH THANKS SO MUCH FOR ASKING ABOUT THEM๐ธ๐ธ๐ธ
Mean Girls
Regarding Jenny, I don't think she would truly be one of the Plastics. I portray her as more of a kind, hard-working girl who hangs out with the wrong crowd๐โโ๏ธ So naturally, I'd put her in the place of Cady Heron. Cady Heron was actually my inspiration when I was coming up with Jenny's background!!๐
Headcanon dump: Jenny and her mom are the newest residents of Woodsburyโ they moved there just a week before the first episode of S1โผ๏ธ
For Amber, I initially thought she would fit Regina's place; but as time passed, Karen just started to make a little more sense... I aint forgetting the time she asked Chloe, "who are you bringing to the father-daughter dance?" โ ๏ธ TAKE A WILD GUESS. Anyway, my version of Amber has her at the top of Garden Grove Middle School's social hierarchy, though as high school rolls in, I think Annie would grow even more imposing / controlling than her.
That being said, Annie would be Regina George๐ฏ๐ฏ Blonde hair, pink wardrobe, rich, impatient, sassy, and MEAN! I like to think she grows out of being Amber's right-hand woman during middle school and takes the #1 spot in high school because she realized just how much power she has!
And of course, we can't forget about Gretchen. And I think Brittany would suit her. Brittany has been shown to be really mindful of her reputation and fitting in with the more popular kids, so I believe she would be Annie's confidant / right-hand to keep a good status (not that she's purely using Annie for popularity!) Also, I personally think Brittany would be almost as fragile as Gretchen when it comes to emotions๐คทโโ๏ธ
OTHER CHARACTERS:
โข Janis = Mildred, โข Damian = Cheesy
โข Aaron = Jake
Heathers
Heathers is a trickier musical to cast with ALVINNN characters but I'll try my best!! but i don't think I can exactly cast Amber, Annie, or Jenny all into those three roles๐
Jenny's best fit would be Heather McNamara-- the most redeemable Heather. But if I were to choose who Heather Mac's best fit would be, I'd say Vanessa! My take on Vanessa is that she's one of the nicest people you could ever meet (minus a few instances of being unaware of her own meanness). I'd also say she's more of a follower than an imposing figure just like how Heather Mac is
HELP I ACTUALLY CANT DECIDE WHICH HEATHER AMBER AND ANNIE WOULD BE
Okay my brain is fried. Amber is Duke and Annie is Chandler.
Also Veronica would be Mildred










