ahh nooo this game is too scary. you gotta hold me bro

At the Tale End, Purrfect Apawcalypse, Grimm's Hollow, Imaginary Friends, Mistrick, Fantasy Maiden's Odd Hideout, Crowscare, Symbiosis, Sofia?, and Home's Embrace, are what I'd consider good introductory games to build up horror tolerance. Assuming you meant something relatively light on death traps, chase scenes, gore, etc? (Examples of "heavy" horror games would be: Witch's House, Cat in the Box, Mad Father, Mermaid Swamp, The Crooked Man, Blank Dream, Pocket Mirror)

I love horror games, but I'm really bad at playing them myself - I usually just watch other people play because of that. But I wanna try to get braver.

I was raving for Cooking Companions with the demo alone, but surprisingly didn't get around to watching the full release... until now.