idk how I feel about devil in silver. there's no opportunity for restrospective bc it's set in the current day and bc it's such a sensitive issue (police brutality & psychiatric abuse), the showrunners clearly didn't want to leave any room for the misconception that the abuse is imagined and seemed to extend that to the demon itself, so it doesn't manage to punch the same way the first two seasons did. like if youre doing a reality bender from the perspective of extremely drugged psychiatric patients in an openly abusive system, you kind of need Stuff in there that we as the audience Is Not Sure Is Real. and that does not really happen at all because they are terrified of the audience missing the point
it's shorter than the other two seasons and it starts with the main character straight up wrongfully institutionalized in an act of blatant corruption and police misconduct whose stay is repeatedly extended for "noncompliance" (being too drugged & unable to take afternoon medication bc literally unconscious) to a shared understanding between him and his family that he really does need to be in a 'good' psychiatric facility. maybe because he absorbed a demon essence in the first abusive unit, but that doesn't really make sense bc the demon wants to feed on the misery of abused psychiatric patients so like. probably dont take it in any psychiatric facilities. maybe to soften the sociopolitical commentary and tell the audience that some people really do get help in these places? but the better character for that would have been the teenage girl who nearly killed her brother and was just let go, not the guy who has literally no reason to be there at all
also making a white man the face of police brutality and psychiatric abuse was A Choice, especially bc the entire hospital staff was POC. it was very clear that most individual hospital staff are not responsible for The System and are Just Doing Their Best but failed to engage with the reality that many choose those positions specifically because of the unrestricted power over extremely vulnerable people & abuse is rampant. it would have been a lot stronger of a show if they never clearly showed whether the demon thing was real or if it was a personification of the cruelty of the system, you know, how extremely drugged people in a stanford prison experiment might process things
they REALLY did not show people Having Symptoms at all except for zoning out due to being too drugged, which is again psychiatric abuse. some people in mental health facilities actually do have serious mental health conditions that seriously impact their daily life. so like. where the fuck were they? a main character was subjected to a lobotomy in that hospital AND was heavily drugged and like. she was fine??? could hold conversations, just seemed like she's got her head in the clouds. a bit spacey. it created a weird vibe where simultaneously youre asking whether any of them need to be in there and if the drugs are causing ALL observed symptoms AND that being drugged and lobotomized isn't all that bad aside from the stanford prison experiment issue. like you just get spacey instead of your reality starts bending around you. like all people in psychiatric facilities are obviously normal people including those with severe and persistent symptoms, but even if all of them were wrongfully imprisoned and have no real symptoms at all, being gaslit on its own causes reality warp. being heavily drugged on its own should have induced more reality warp than we saw. and again! cannot stress enough that one character was subjected to a LOBOTOMY. which is brain damage! i should have seen some Symptoms from that aside from crying blood tears. where is the reality warp? why do these characters confidently Know What's Real, why aren't they constantly reality checking against each other's senses?
























