pretty little liars

"It Happened ‘That Night,’" season three, episode 1 

"A Dangerous Game," season three, episode 24 

"A Is for Answers," season four, episode 24 

"Taking This One to the Grave," season five, episode 12 

The writers like to throw a lot of suspicion around, but I think there are only a few clues we should actually pay attention to, and they all relate to Mrs. D:

**Mrs. DiLaurentis saw everything and buried her own daughter and covered up her murder. To me this means, either Jason did it, and is Big A. OR Alison (or Jason) has a twin.

No one would cover up their child’s murder for anyone else but their other child.

Mrs. D wouldn’t do that for Bethany, even if she liked her, come on. And she especially wouldn’t do that for someone she didn’t even know very well, like, Lucas, Mona, Cece, Melissa, Hanna, Aria, or anyone else but her own child really.

PROOF THAT THE ‘A’ ENDING IN 4x18 WAS EZRA’S LAIR!

So I decided to go back and dissect as much of the lair/basement that we seen ‘A’ in at the end of 4x18… and to do so, I went and compared all the items we seen in it, to all the items we seen in Ezra’s lair in 4x12.

SEE FOR YOURSELF WHAT I FOUND.

1.) The yearbook from when the NAT Club was still in high school is seen in both 4x12 (Ezra’s Lair), and in the ‘A’ ending in 4x18.

2.) THE SAME EXACT MAP is seen in both Ezra’s lair and with A in 4x18. You can tell it’s the same because it’s a map that was printed out on two separate sheets of paper, and then taped together.

3.) THE SAME photo of Spencer is hanging in both.

4.) A PINK NOTEPAD was seen in Ezra’s lair in 4x12, and was now sitting in front of A in 4x18.

5.) THE SAME PHOTO OF WILDEN is hanging in both lairs as well.

6.) There is a tall GLASS MUG WITH RUBBER BANDS seen in Ezra’s lair in both 4x11 when Cece was there, and when the girls were there in 4x12. Now this SAME MUG is with A in 4x18.

7.) The same EXACT pair of SCISSORS were seen in Ezra’s lair when Cece was there in 4x11, and now with A in 4x18.

8.) There is a little ROUND SILVER TIN that was seen in Ezra’s lair in 4x11 and 4x12, and it is now also seen in 4x18 during the ‘A’ Ending.

9.) THE SAME EXACT PHOTOS OF ARIA were in Ezra’s lair. One of the front of her face, a side shot, and one of her lips. AND they are all in COLOR… last time we seen these photos, Jason had them, but they were all in B&W. NOW we are seeing the exact same specific photos in COLOR in both Ezra’s Lair, and with ‘A’ in 4x18.

ALSO, Something I noticed in Ezra’s lair from re-watching 4x12, is that on the board that is tracking Ali, there is a photo that says “body found” next to it. And the photo is of when the body bag fell out of the icebox on the Halloween train. I just thought it was interesting that we see that exact photo, when the only person that we know of who took that photo was LUCAS. He had that fancy camera with him all night, and he immediately snapped a shot of the body bag when it fell out. And now Ezra has the picture in his Lair in Ravenswood… does that mean Lucas IS helping Ezra?? Just a speculation.

BOTTOM LINE: The stuff we seen in A’s lair/basement-type setting at the end of 4x18, DEFINITELY belongs to Ezra. Which means it is most likely a part of Ezra’s lair that we didn’t see when Ezra went in his basement. I mentioned in my 4x18 review that we shouldn’t rule it out as being Ezra’s just because it didn’t look the same as what we saw in the episode, Because there was a side of the Lair that the screen never circled around to. Which means this other desk could still be in that lair.

IF IT’S NOT LOCATED IN HIS BASEMENT, then it HAS to be someone he is working with, in order for them to have all of his belongings that were once in his lair.

I seriously think that this is all the proof that we need that Ezra is somehow involved with the A team :)

In Season 3, Episode 18:

In Shadow Play when they find Ali it’s lead to believe that Ezra had the gun and Toby knocked him out or something to save the girls.

Guys. Guys.

Ezra gets shot in the finale. If this episode is a parallel - the HOODED FIGURE IS FUCKING TOBY. HE IS STILL ON THE A TEAM.

Ali wAs sleeping at the KAhn’s!!!!!

Ali was sleeping at the Kahn’s during the same time that Maya was. We spotted her bag while answering this anon’s question. I love this find and think it goes perfect with our Did Ali Kill Ian Theory? It shows that there was some sort of connection with Ali and Noel even during that time (3.10).

Also, this would explain the whole “Maya Knew” thing. Maya knew about Ali being alive, not that Nate was in town like we were told.

Don’t forget this clue that posted:

Did Spencer chase down Sara Harvey?

I’ve gathered everything I’ve heard (that is true and confirmed) about season 5:

- Caleb come’s back in 5x05 (also known as the 100th episode)

- Caleb’s friends from Ravenswood might appear in an episode of PLL for some final closure.

We’ve been trying to figure out what exactly happened to Ian Thomas as well as, why Noel Kahn was in the finale.

The Bell Tower:

1. She hit her head and never woke up …

During the struggle between Spencer and Ian at the Bell Tower, Ian recites a possible suicide note for Spencer as he proceeds to unsuccessfully push her from the tower. He also mention this:

And the letter, the one I wrote on your computer won’t answer all of the questions but, it’ll answer enough.

At this moment we learn that Ian had Spencer’s suicide planned out.

2. What are you doing here …

As Spencer was dangling from the tower, a black hoodie walks up and Ian instantly recognizes this person. His shocking response was none other than “What are you doing here?” The widening of his eyes showed that he was shocked/surprised to see this person. In the 4B finale this hooded person was revealed as being Alison DiLaurentis.

The girl thought to be dead during this particular scene but, Ian’s reaction wasn’t that of a person seeing a ghost but more of a person he hadn’t seen in a while (if that makes sense). His reaction wasn’t shocking enough for a person who was seeing someone who was presumed dead, which made us wonder if he knew Ali wasn’t dead.

As hooded Ali knocked Ian off the tower, she quickly walks away to get out of sight.

3. You did what you had to do …

As the liars try to comfort Spencer, Ian is left dangling in the ropes; a rope around his neck and one underneath his arm. You have to wonder how he managed to untangle himself when he could have easily been hung to death from the ropes. This is impossible to do for a person hanging at the feet he was, also we reviewed the screen cap of his body hanging and noticed that the ropes were carefully knotted in certain spots and there was a main rope leading out and away from where he was hanging. We believe this is how he was pulled down and we question Ali’s story.

Ali said that she was waiting in the back and that she saw him, “he was still alive.” If Ian wasn’t dead and was just unconscious, then who pulled him down? Besides the Liars, Ali confirmed she was there at the scene, Mona claimed in 4.01 that “I didn’t push Ian from the Bell Tower. I wish I knew who did,” and Noel Kahn was in the crowd. Therefore, we figured that Ali and Noel Kahn could have worked together during this time to pull Ian down from the ropes and put him in a car out back.

We’re suspecting Ali and Noel because he had to have served some sort of purpose to what happened at the Bell Tower especially since he was seen standing in the crowd that night. In the finale he was the one who was helping her so it’s possible he knew about her being alive for some time. Also, Ali had a few reasons to kill Ian; a broken heart from Hilton Head, the risk of him telling others that she’s alive.

4. He’s been dead over a week …

Ian was dead longer than a week, this was mentioned by Melissa. If Ian was dead longer than a week than we assume that after his body was taken from the Bell Tower Ali and Noel decided to make it look like a suicide. We also suspect Ali because she wore the black hoodie that night at the Bell Tower and Ian could have very well been dead after falling into the ropes, but he was shot in the head to make it seem like a suicide.

The person who murdered him was seen in 2.04 putting Ian’s phone into Spencer’s bag. Remember this is the same person who was texting Melissa and asking for drugs. We still believe this to be Ali because who would want to see Melissa hurt more than Ali.

Melissa was threatening Ali during the summer of her disappearance and she followed Ali and Ian to Hilton Head.

Melissa told Ian that “if he saw Ali again someone would get hurt.” That sounded like fighting words to me, so “game on b-tch!”

Ian said he was just “killing time until something better came along” - she was young and this was probably her first crush so to hear those words was very upsetting.

5. I killed Alison …

The suicide note. We decided to review Ian’s suicide note:

I killed Alison. I lost my temper because she knew too much. But there’s only so much you can bury. It won’t be that easy, but I know how to get rid of the pain. I can’t run from the law. Com and find me.

After reading this letter we matched it up with some things from what we saw in the season finale and this is what helped us with this theory that Ali could have possibly killed Ian (please click the link above for the photos). Because she didn’t deny or say if she did or didn’t, no one bothered to ask.

A list of things to think about as to why Ali is the number one suspect:

Ali wore the black hoodie

Ali’s stories doesn’t match up with Mona’s, they share some of the same events but are slightly different. Who do you believe?

Ali told Hanna “the four of them combined remember more about that night than they think they do.” Meaning the girls memory from that night is still gone and have yet to surface. Therefore, could Ali’s story be the truth are a lie?