LEAGUE EXPANSION/RELOCATION SERIES - NHL
Now to take a stab at a league that has definitely over-expanded - the National Hockey League. As it stands, with the new expansion team in Vegas, the NHL has a total of 31 teams. Obviously, that leaves room for another team, but any more than 32, and the NHL risks becoming too top-heavy.
One issue I am attempting to address with this piece is the issue of over-expansion into the American South. Teams like Arizona and Florida are quickly going the way of the Atlanta Flames and Atlanta Thrashers.
This setup would add a 32nd team to balance the conferences, and would move several teams north to more loyal fanbases.
As it stands, here are our current divisions:
Atlantic: Boston, Ottawa, Montreal, Tampa Bay, Florida, Detroit, Buffalo, Toronto
Metropolitan: Washington, Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, Carolina, New Jersey, Colombus, New York (I), New York (R)
Central: Chicago, Nashville, Minnesota, St. Louis, Colorado, Winnipeg
Pacific: Anaheim, Arizona, Las Vegas, Los Angeles, San Jose, Vancouver, Edmonton, Calgary
As it stands, we see teams that simply do not belong. Hockey in Miami and Phoenix? Really? To address these issues, I have picked three teams to relocate, and am analyzing several relocation possibilities. I also have added one expansion team in order to even up the divisions.
Top relocation candidates:
-Florida Panthers - yes, they may have been good last year, but hockey has no place in Miami, and it shows with the half-full arenas that the Panthers constantly have to contend with. Considering the following Tampa Bay has, it seems that Florida only has room for one hockey team.
-Arizona Coyotes - here is another southern team that simply does not belong. Ownership issues, fanbase issues, this team flat needs to move.
-Nashville Predators - here is a team that has struggled to fill arenas at times. Nashville is a bit of an island, too isolated from any major hockey markets. A move north would help.
-Carolina Hurricanes - yes, they won a cup a few years ago, but like their Florida counterparts, the Canes are having trouble filling arenas, largely due to being well away from the traditional US hockey fanbases.
Other possible candidates -
-Anaheim Ducks - unlikely, because they’ve been successful, and Gretzky’s tenure with the Kings made the NHL a fixture in L.A. sports.
-New York Islanders - unlikely given the loyal following in the New York area. Still a possibility due to having to compete with the Rangers.
Now, we have our relocation candidates. We also need an expansion team to make it 32 teams. From what I’ve read, and what I’ve dug up, these seem to be the best candidates for destinations -
-Quebec City, Quebec - the Nordiques left for Colorado in the mid 90s, and Quebec hockey fans have since been left with the prospect of following the hated Candiens. Quebec City is overdue for a team, and should be the #1 relocation prospect.
-Milwaukee, Wisconsin - Wisconsin is one of the core hockey states in the US, and amateur and semi-pro teams are found all over the state. Milwaukee hosts a metro area of roughly 1.7 million, easily big enough to support an NHL team, and Wisconsin hockey fans would welcome a team with open arms.
-Seattle, Washington - Seattle boasts one of the best sports fanbases in the country, yet the largest metropolis in the Pacific Northwest only hosts two teams, the Seahawks and the perpetually awful Mariners. Seattle was home to the first American team to win the Stanley Cup, the Seattle Metropolitans.
-Hartford, Connecticut - “Connecticut?” younger fans may ask. What we may forget is that the Hartford Whalers were a fixture in the NHL until their move to North Carolina. Maybe a move back is something to consider?
-Anchorage, Alaska - This may seem like a stretch, but hear me out. Alaska is home to at least two NCAA Division One hockey clubs, so the fanbase is definitely there. Anchorage is home to roughly 400,000 people, so it has the size.
-Hamilton, Ontario - too close to Toronto, but big enough where the possibility cannot be ruled out.
-Kansas City, Missouri - another Seattle-like candidate, but lacks the history when compared to some other candidates.
-Toronto, Ontario - Toronto is big enough to potentially hold a second team, but if Toronto brings in an NFL team, that makes a second hockey team unlikely.
-Saskatoon, Saskatchewan - Big enough, yes, but given the demand elsewhere, I don’t see a relocation here soon.
-Atlanta, Georgia - considering the NHL tried here twice and failed twice, I don’t think Atlanta is a candidate anytime soon.
-Houston, Texas - definitely is big enough, same size as Chicago roughly, but the market for hockey simply is not here.
Now, I see an expansion team being added to bring the league to an even 32, and that will make the playoff process more fair, and also balance out the divisions. Here are our moves -
Expansion team - Anchorage Grizzlies
Arizona Coyotes relocate to Seattle, change name to Rangers
Florida Panthers relocate to Quebec City, change name to Nordiques
Carolina Hurricanes relocate to Hartford, change name to Whalers
Nashville Predators relocate to Milwaukee, change name to Admirals
Obviously, this would mean the NHL would need to realign their divisions. What I think would make the most sense would be an arrangement like so -
ATLANTIC DIVISION: Quebec City, Montreal, Boston, Hartford, New York, New Jersey, New York (I)
METROPOLITIAN DIVISION: Ottawa, Toronto, Columbus, Pittsburgh, Buffalo, Philadelphia, Tampa Bay, Detroit
CENTRAL DIVISION: Chicago, St. Louis, Minnesota, Milwaukee, Colorado, Dallas, Winnipeg, Las Vegas
PACIFIC DIVISION: Anchorage, Los Angeles, Seattle, Vancouver, Calgary, Edmonton, Anaheim, San Jose
Unfortunately, I could not find a way to move Detroit into the central division. Considering that Detroit has rivalries with every major team in Wisconsin and Illinois, and in Minnesota, the NHL is missing a great opportunity there.
I pretty much pulled names out of the air, so if anyone has any better ideas, hit me with it!
My goal was to bring hockey to places where it belongs, and get rid of some of these “what in the heck are they doing there?!” teams.