Olden Towne

the good:

12- my favorite character of the pack. I love his shades and his guitar and his vibe of being both very cool and very uncool at the exact same time.

10- definitely had the best companions and the best run of the show, but he's not 12. He's great, funny, and sexy, but he's not 12.

15- he had some of the best episodes of the show and some of the worst, back to back to back. I like that we got a doctor who goes to gay clubs and Nigerian barber shops. He was very fun, very human, and sometimes somewhat fatherly. A million directions were set up for his character but a strong one was never committed to, which is a shame. Davies and studio meddling share roughly equal blame for that.

9- the most rascally a doctor has ever been. Loving the leather jacket and the trauma. I do wish we'd had more time to get to know him though, but we didn't. Again: Davies and studio meddling share roughly equal blame for that.

the boring:

13- Chibnall forgot to give any of his characters personality, except for Graham. She was just a "socially awkward nerd" stock character. Jodie Whittaker deserved better, and frankly so did Jo Martin.

the bad:

11- I hate that Moffat wrote him as a sex pest and then made him the center of the universe.

One-off regens/honorable mentions:

Fugitive doctor- I hope we get a season with Jo Martin. I love that outfit, and I loved her in the role. She was written like more of a doctor than 13.

14- this is just 10 if he was old