Maybe you don’t know why it hit you that hard. But you know what you were looking at.
Max looked away. Bit her tongue against the dozens of excuses that threatened to fall out. She wanted to brush it off. Sweep it under the rug and pretend nothing had happened. Somehow force things to go back to normal, back to how they’d been just a few minutes ago. She, unfortunately, knew that wasn’t something she could do.
Damon wasn’t likely to let a reaction that strong go that easily. He wasn’t going to take “it’s nothing,” nod along, and forget about it like she wanted him to. Max didn’t want to talk about it, but she also knew it would be far better if he heard it from her, rather than him going digging and coming to an even worse conclusion on his own.
“It’s not dented,” she grumbled. It could be. She’d hit it pretty damn hard, but she didn’t bother looking up to confirm his claim. Instead, she put all her attention to picking at the skin beside her thumbnail, chewing anxiously on her lip. Considered how she wanted to go about explaining, what exactly she wanted to tell him. Her silence was a thoughtful one.
Taking a breath, she wrapped her arms a bit tighter around her knees and picked a random cabinet to look at. It was easier than meeting his gaze. “He’s just…some guy. Chase.” She started slowly, picking her words carefully. The last thing she wanted was for Damon to look at her the same way everyone else had, by the end of this. “We went to school together. Back in California.”
Her expression tightened. “We moved there the summer before I started high school. So I was the weird new freshman, and he was the senior everyone already knew because they’d all grown up with him. Your stereotypical attractive, popular jock that everyone liked.” She took a breath. “Including me.”
She shook her head, remembering just how ridiculously infatuated she’d been. How there’d practically been hearts coming out of her eyes any time he passed by her in the hallway. How she’d swooned when he smiled in her direction. God, she wished she could go back in time and tell her younger self to stay the fuck away from him.
“I had this massive crush on him, and I didn’t think he even knew my name.” Maybe that’d been part of the reason why she’d liked him. He’d been safe. Unattainable. A guy she’d known she never had a chance with, so there was no risk of getting hurt.
Oh, how wrong she’d been.
“But then he found me in the hallway one day and asked me to go with him to a party someone was having, and I was just…over the moon.” She let out a quiet, bitter laugh. “God, I was so fucking excited. I was just…a dumb kid.”
Old anger and hurt and mortification came rushing back, all at once, and Max swiped at her eyes with a huff. “I shouldn’t have gone. I shouldn’t have drank. But he just…he’d hand me more, and I didn’t want to say no, you know? I just…wanted him to like me. I wanted him to like me so fucking badly. So, when he brought me upstairs, I…we—”
She cut herself off when it suddenly started to get difficult to breathe again. Her expression twisted as her chest tightened. After a few quick, short breaths, she squeezed her eyes shut and swung her fist back into the wall beside her, cursing. “Shit.” She felt her fist go through the drywall—that one was definitely more than a dent—but pulled it out and covered her face with both hands, taking a second to breathe through it. “…Sorry. I’ll pay for that,” she said quietly.
“Fuck, this is so stupid. I was so stupid. And then, Monday morning rolled around and he told basically everyone that I was this huge slut, and of course they all believed him, because why wouldn’t they? Everything was already so fucking hard at home, and he made school hell, and…he’s part of the reason I moved. I just…I couldn’t…it was one stupid mistake and I had to move across the goddamn country to escape it and…it’s been years. I don’t know why I freaked out like that. That’s not…I shouldn’t be freaking out.”