Someone reblogged this months ago going "But Rowling filled the books with nazi ideology!" and listed antisemitic tropes in the books, because they missed the actual point of my post. I wrote up a long response in my drafts.
Checked that person's blog and they have a post calling Israel "an extremely antisemitic nation" and another using the term "zionist pig" so they are clearly a fucking bigot who does not give an actual shit about real Jewish people. I'm blocking them.
I think my response does say worthwhile things, though, so I'm going ahead and putting it here:
As a Jewish person who grew up reading fantasy and sci-fi, the sheer amount of antisemitism embedded in media that goyische people gloss over is obscene.
It's like fish in water. It's so prevalent that most of them don't even notice it's there (much like colorism is). If I assume all of them are aware of it it and accept it, I will become a paranoid wreck, I really will.
If someone points it out to them, breaks down the tropes/symbols for them, and they still brush it off, that's a different kettle of fish. Then I know they're not safe for me to be around. But if they're just clueless?
Want to enjoy a children's film? Chitty Chitty Bang Bang's child catcher is several antisemitic tropes rolled into one. There's a whole mess around Mother Gothel's character design going from Lady Tremaine-esque to a caricature. The one Jewish-coded character in the How to Train Your Dragon television series betrays the heroes.
Some vintage romance novels? Oh no, the protagonists are in trouble with a Jewish money lender written like a mobster.
DC comics hired an open antisemite, and only fired her because she ran her mouth about another antisemite, not because of the times she celebrated violence against Jews or her sexual harassment of a Jewish journalist.
Oh, we have positive representation like Ms. Frizzle? Sorry kids she gets goy-washed in the reboot.
This ensemble cast has a Jewish character who doesn't turn evil? Oh they're going to celebrate Christmas or the in-universe equivalent with all the other characters.
Then there's Dragon Age's...everything.
Should I assume everyone who enjoys Disney, HtTYD, Dragon Age, Danny Phantom, DC comics, etc, wants me dead?
If I assume the goyische audience clocks all of the antisemitism without one of us holding their hand, and that they accept and support the inescapable deluge of antisemitism in media, I will go insane.
I'm already stressed by the antisemitic violence in my country, in the world, and how people keep excusing it. I'm already closeted about my ethnicity at work.
I'm three for three on my workplaces being vandalized with nazi symbols. A different workplace didn't get vandalized but the intersection outside it was constantly plastered with antisemitic stickers. I've been within yards of a guy pulling down the collar of shirt to show off his swastika tattoo to his buddy while I was walking home. I'm not even going to get into the shit I experienced in school.
I need to stay alert to legitimate threats to my physical safety.
Not exhaust myself panicking over someone buying some stupid Harry Potter Keebler Elf Cookies.
What would have been my reply tags: #you did NOT read the room on this post #I KNOW Rowling's work is full of antisemitic crap and she leans into nazi territory #I have written about that exact issue before
#this post is about engaging realistically with the wider world and remembering that strangers on the bus #and casual acquaintances in my life don't already know the things that I do or realize they are ignorant
#it's about not promoting scrupulosity disorders
#yeah I'd like people to be more aware and stop spreading so much bigotry but I also want to not exhaust myself #I know there's shit like the Jaws effect there already present prejudices can be exacerbated by media