morelikeianhardon

Are you confused after 6x20? You’re not alone. I think I have solved the entire show. Everything.

In this master theory post, I explain:

- who is Mary Drake? - was CeCe lying in 6x10? To what extent? - did CeCe know she is adopted or did she think that was her immediate real family? - who killed Jessica? - why was Jessica killed? - who killed Charlotte? - why was Charlotte killed? - who is Bethany Young? - what is Rollins up to? - who is Uber A?

This took forever and a day to prepare. I came across so many plot holes when writing this that contradict me, but I worked a way around them ALL. I think this is a very consistent and possibly true theory. 

WARNING: it is VERY, VERY long. But it’s ALL relevant; answer after answer after answer.

Not going to waste anymore of your time. Please, ENJOY!

I AM CALLING IT NOW MARY DRAKE IS SPENCER (POSSIBLY MELISSA) BIOLOGICAL MOTHER

the signs are there: Both spencer and Melissa look like Mary Spencer’s parents knew Mary and Jessica Peter and Veronica never mentioned Mary Mary can ‘never turn down caffeine’ Mary is incredibly smart and enjoys traveling/learning about the world It explains why Jessica was so mean/didn’t like spencer/blamed spencer for a lot because she knew she was Mary’s sister - so she thought she was crazy and had the same traits as her mother (Mary)

Our clues given (that are relevant, there are many more i’m sure)

So we can cross off for episodes: 

 Aria Montgomery

Spencer Hastings

Hanna Marin

Emily Fields

Alex Santiago

Jonny Raymond

Clark Wilkins (unless he’s in the finale but probably not)

Then, adding parents to the mix, we can cross off:

Ella Montgomery

Byron Montgomery

Ashley Marin

Tom Marin

Pam Fields

Wayne Fields

Veronica Hastings

Peter Hastings

Kenneth Dilaurentis

Jessica Dilaurentis (dead but whatevs)

Anne Sullivan (i know it’s odd to add but remember that A threatened her son and hey nobody can be 

AND ADDING THE OTHERS….

Aria Montgomery

Spencer Hastings

Hanna Marin

Emily Fields

Alex Santiago

Jonny Raymond

Clark Wilkins (unless he’s in the finale but probably not)

So then, assuming that Charles will be a MALE that we know, it leaves:

Toby Cavanaugh

Jason DiLaurentis

Mike Montgomery

Lucas Gottesman

Garrett Reynolds (dead so probs no)

Noel Kahn

Darren Wilden (dead so probs no)

Wren Kingston

Ian Thomas (dead so probs no)

Gabriel Holbrook

Andrew Campbell

Ted Wilson

Travis Hobbs

Jake

Sean Ackard

Lyndon James (dead so probs no)

Holden Strauss

Lorenzo

Ezra Fitz

Caleb Rivers

Now I’m going to take out the dead people and those who really have no reason to be Charles (with reasons included)

Jason Dilaurentis (he has been in the same room as Charles as seen when Toby got high two episodes ago)

Toby Cavanaugh (same as above)

Lorenzo (same as above)

Garrett (dead)

Wilden (up)

Ian (up)

Lyndon James (up)

Ezra (we saw him while Charles was holding the girls captive)

Caleb (same as above)

Andrew (same as above)

UNLESS  ANY OF THESE PEOPLE HAVE TWINS OR SOME CRAZY SHIT LIKE THAT THAN THESE SHOULD BE VALID

So that leaves:

Mike 

Lucas

Noel

Wren

Holbrook

Ted

Travis

Jake

Sean

Holden

Now, it totally could be a girl, i’m not ruling that out, but i’m saying it’s more likely that Charles is a boy. So this is my list of most possible people, definitely add anything if you want!!!!!

remember when Hanna was looking through the rosewood high yearbook and cece was in it because it was ‘confirmed’ that she went to rosewood high meaning there was no way she was in Radley if she was enrolled in a high school.

remember in the flashback with Alison in Toby’s bedroom when they were TEENS and Toby’s mother walks in and is very much alive, but somehow in the finale Toby’s mom is pushed off the roof when Charles and Bethany were KIDS meaning Toby wasn’t even born yet.