I want to root for Steve. I really really do.Ā
But the accords were not written three days after Lagos happened; weāre shown that people are anxious about the Avengerās lack of accountability as far back as the first film! In Sokovia, weāre shown graffiti of Cap with the wordĀ āfacistā over his head. I think what people have to understand is that, fine, absolutely, Steve does not trust large governmental bodies, and he has every reason not to, BUT, itās not really about him.
Seriously. There were 117 countries that signed the accords.Ā āThe agendas of the people on the oversight committeeā⦠the UN. Steve Rogers is afraid of being curtailed by the UN, and the what, corruption of those 117 countries? I just. Thatās not a decision he gets to make? Fine, valid criticism, EVERYONE is a little skeptical of bodies like the EU, UN, Nato, whatever. But when you are being told ā not just by politicians ā but by ordinary civilians who view you as a facist, and small countries that see you as imperialistic, you donāt get to be the person that plants themselves like a tree and tells everyone else to move. Itās a really bizarre characterisation move to make Steve the person who refuses to listen to the public; the person who ignores the voices of the majority, and fights against other peopleās freedoms. And I do say that, because for many of the civilians of the MCU, it is about freedom from fear.Ā
I donāt know, maybe itās an American thing, but imagine youāre a small country in Europe, under-represented on the world stage and constantly beholden to other countries power struggles, and something like the Avengers comes into your country, rips your city up from the ground, and smashes it back down again. ??? that happened? This isnāt hypothetical? Lagos happened because Wanda was not ready to be on active duty and there was no board of any authority to dictate whether that was true or not. Or to make sure she was up to scratch. Or that, as a young, untrained civilian, it is even ethical to have her in that position in the first place???Ā
And look, ultimately it comes down to this: does Steve have reason to be concerned over the agendas of the oversight committee (otherwise known as the frickin UN)? Yeah, probably. Does that mean he was right? No. He needed to compromise. Not because Tony wanted him to, or the team would fall apart or whatever, but genuinely because 117 countries were living in fear. 117 countries who were not the USA were wondering if they would be next, if the next time the Avengers decide to visit to take care of a threat their civilians would be the ones killed. Unfortunately, what CW gave us wasnāt a Steve who believed inĀ āindividual autonomy and choiceā for all, it gave us a Steve who was more interested in the individual autonomy of his team. As Captain America, a man who supposedly represents a country which fought to free itself from imperialist tyranny, itās hard to square up why Steve feels his opinion on the safety of his friend(s) is somehow, without fail, the right one?
(Well we know why, itās because he was poorly written and the Russos weighted civil war WAAAAY too much in Tonyās favour, to the extent that itās too easy to poke holes in Steveās reasoning and he comes across looking, at best, incredibly naive. sigh. my poor son, he deserves better)Ā