I'm genuinely in awe with how you came up with all of this. The world building and characterization is just amazing. When I first saw this fic recommended on tiktok I was like who on earth would write a voldemortxsiruis fic I'm soo glad I gave it a try tbh.
I remember a chapter you wrote where Harry said he'd be okay marrying Draco and I thought it could be a thing but have lost hope since they started hogwarts. My drarry heart broke.
Also can you touch more on bellatrix's character? She's an absolute badass but no matter how hard I try I can never seen to like her and trust me I've tried. She's described as morally grey like most of the characters yet I only see her to be awful and self-serving. Nothing really to consider her morally grey and not just cruel. I've read soo many comments to try to get it cause I hate the feeling of not understanding the nuance of a character. Maybe I'm still holding the grudge of what she did to Marlene and her family.
I also feel like Siruis was too hard on Harry. The situation just reminds me of how single minded the black family can be. They fail to see the perspective of others and how their actions affect anyone who isn't them. They expected Harry to go to school filled with the children of people they murdered or tortured and not think of them as monsters? That is very single minded.
Please feel free to correct me if I'm wrong and have totally missed the point you were trying to make cause I do let my views get in the way of actually enjoying a good book. Tbh I find most of the characters insufferable yet I can't seem to not want to read about them. This is honestly the most enchanting fic I've read. Thank you for writing it, truly it has shaped my brain in soo many ways after reading fics where Walburga and Orion are just monsters for no reason this has allowed me to view the black family in such a different light.
Bella is not described as morally grey. Or at least that was not my intention. I did my best to make her a complex character, but there's nothing grey about her morality: she is a bigot, she is an extremist, she follows a very rigid code, she is cruel, violent, and has no issue with genocide. I...do not see how that would be morally grey, really. Yes, she's loving and helpful with her family, but that's the complexity of a human being- you can be evil, morally bankrupt and still adore your little sister, and die for your cousin. One has little to do with the other.
"like most of the characters"- again, my intention was never for most of the characters to be morally grey. Voldemort's side, the Black's side of the story, loads of them are pretty much horrible people.
I often say I strive to write human characters, and that means complex characters, as in they can be evil but that doesn't take away from their humanity. However, that does not at all mean they are morally grey. Voldemort, I hope, is written as a very complex man, but no one would ever call him 'grey'.
Same for the good guys. Dumbledore in It runs is very much a good guy, with incredible moral compass. But he's still human, so he has flaws. He still makes some bad decisions. That doesn't make him a bad man, or a 'grey' man. It makes him a good man with a lot of responsibility on his shoulders, in the middle of a terrible war.
James and Lily were good guys, but they also had some flaws.
Same for the bad guys- they're very much bad, but they still have qualities, like bravery or a twisted set of honour, or ...idk, loving their children and pets.
You don't have to force yourself to like Bella; Sirius likes her, and you can see how his love colours his POV, but she's a very hard person to stomach, if you aren't on her side. It's normal that you hold a grudge against her for, you know, the murder of Marlene and her lil' niece. Of course, in that case, there should also be a grudge against Voldemort, who ordered the death of her entire family. But I noticed Bella always gets more flak than Voldemort, across fandom.
You're right, lots of the characters are insufferable, because they are horrible people. However, because they are fictional, that doesn't mean they aren't fun to read/write about. It's actually why I like to write them.
There's something fascinating about writing an evil character like Voldemort, or Bella, but still writing them as human; because they are humans. It would be amazing if morally bankrupt people wouldn't be humans, wouldn't it? But they are. They love, and suffer, and laugh, and joke around, too. They find ways to explain away their evilness and cruelty in a way that makes sense to them. At least Voldemort knows he's bad, but most purebloods around him don't think of themselves as bad- a lot of them actually believe that what they are doing is good for their families or their country. They view themselves either as righteous or as 'morally grey'. But they aren't. They're bad people, that have zero regard for those that are not exactly like them.
It's also fascinating how the qualities they do have, like honour, bravery, love- how these become twisted with the wrong mindset. Rodolphus, Arcturus, Sirius, Bella- they all have honour, they all are brave, they all love *so* fiercely. But we see how those qualities make them worse people, instead of better. Rodolphus and Bella would murder nations out of love for their lord. Arcturus would sentence babies to death so he can save a family member. Sirius would do literally anything for Voldemort or the Blacks.
And, hopefully, as you read from Sirius' POV, you can see how he explains it away to himself, how he reaches the bottom of the barrel, moral wise, how he loses himself from a good young man, to the Head of House Black, to Voldemort's beloved. I do hope most people that read it can indeed relate to the very human aspects of him, and indulge in this story, but I never meant for these very fun and charismatic people to be morally grey or morally...anything really.
They're just fun, really. In a fascinating, sometimes horrible sort of way.
Sirius is a good man, if you ask his family, his other pureblood friends. He's a hero, holding up their birthright, protecting their lineage.
Now, best not to think how the rest of magical UK views Sirius, though we hear a little, here and there. He, too, is a bad man.
"They expected Harry to go to school filled with the children of people they murdered or tortured and not think of them as monsters? That is very single minded."- these are the Blacks. They expect the same out of all their children. They expect loyalty to the family.
Since we were speaking of morals, Harry is morally in the right, of course. Not only that, but he's also a child. Alas, the Blacks believe Harry is wrong, because he 'betrayed' them. He answered their love and protection with disloyalty. Obviously, that's a very harmful way of thinking, but like I said, there's nothing healthy about the way the Black family raises their children, or what they expect of them.
"after reading fics where Walburga and Orion are just monsters for no reason this has allowed me to view the black family in such a different light.". Thank you! I am glad you like the nuance I tried with the Blacks.
Mind you, in my fic, Orion and Walburga still inflict terrible damage on their sons; sure, not in a cartoon character way, throwing Crucio around at their kids and gleefully laughing, but the abuse is still very much present. Only in more human ways, in more insidious ways.
"Everything they do to you is permanent damage" Voldemort tells Sirius at some point, when Sirius shrugs off the way his mother treats him. And, Voldemort is right.
However, that doesn't mean Orion and Walbruga didn't love their sons; they loved their sons more than anything in the world. Anything except legacy, that is. They adored Sirius and Regulus, but their loyalty is always first to the Black part of the name, and only after that to the individual that is called Black.
And Sirius and Regulus in turn love their parents.
And yet, with all this love, all this loyalty, abuse still happened. Permanent trauma still happened. Vicious circles are still in place, and Sirius is repeating them with Orion Jr.
It's the tragedy and beauty of their family. The Black family is so interesting to write about, but obviously, there's nothing 'grey' about them. They perpetuate a cycle of abuse that not only harms the world at large, but harms every single individual inside their family. All in the name of legacy and power. All in the name of protecting the family.
Still love them, though 😂
Hope you can continue to enjoy 'It runs' for what it is. It is not the type of story where you can look for morals inside it, though. Just a deep dive into how harmful royal-type families are, and how much love two bad people can hold for each other.