I want you to imagine college writing like making a cake; you have already gathered your ingredients with mise en place and now youâre mixing your ingredients together.Â
By this, I am referencing the creation part of writing. You donât write just to write, rather, you write to join a conversationâto create a name for yourself in a writing setting.Â
This can only allude to finding a âvoiceâ or writing with authority.Â
The main facet that differentiates high school level writing from college level writing is the presence of an authoritative voice; in other words, a student will have to learn how to create a ânameâ for themselves in the writing process.
To help visualize this, letâs look at Professors Ann M. Penrose and Cheryl Geislerâs Reading and Writing Without Authority; in this example, they compare students who utilize an authoritative voice versus those who do not utilize an authoritative voice.
 âTexts are authored and negotiableâÂ
âAuthors present knowledge in the form of claimsâÂ
âKnowledge claims can conflictâ
âKnowledge claims can be testedâ
 âTexts are definitiveâÂ
âInformation-transfer modelâÂ
Students want to write like Roger, but they may relate more to Janet if they are a new writer. College-level writers (such as Roger) write to join a conversationâthey write as if they were an expert on a topic. They explain their viewpoint in confidence, but allow people to reject their viewpoint if they have a disagreement. A conversation is created among scholars.Â
For writers that are not yet at Roger level, they may have a more direct approach to writing. Writers may choose one viewpoint and stick to that. Such a viewpoint is staticâit does not constantly evolve as the conversation evolves.Â
To put it in a more casual sense, imagine you are in a group of friends. They are all trying to decide on where to eatâthe group recommends Olive Garden.Â
Friend 1: âOlive Garden has a wide selection of Italian foodâthereâs something for everyone.â
Having a voice with authority means that your response would look a little something like:
You: âOlive Garden sounds good, but Little Caesars would fit our budget more and we could eat wherever we want.âÂ
Notice how you are able to join the conversation, acknowledge the other speaker, but also include your own viewpoint on the matter. You were able to analyze the pros and cons of eating at each restaurant, which then meant you could think about which choice best fit the situation.Â
You: âIf you think Olive Garden sounds good thenâŚthatâs fine with me.âÂ
In this scenario, you are less likely to establish yourself as someone with an authoritative voice. This is mainly because you are yielding your viewpoint entirely. You can still choose Olive Garden, but seeking an âexact truthâ is not adding to a conversation. Your friends want true input rather than just a spat-out agreement; authority means you have the âwhyâ supporting the âwhatâ
Writing with authority means that you should not be âafraidâ of more experienced writersâprove your position by knowing that you are on the same debate level as them.Â