If you want to read the full series, itâs pinned on my Tumblr in my masterlist. After an entire year, itâs finally here. I hope you guys like it!
marked - from the broken vows series - chapter eighteen
You arrived at the bar a few minutes later than you meant to.
Ellison was already there.
You spotted her almost immediately, leaning against the bar like she belonged there, like every room knew to make space for her. Cream pants, a white shirt, a leather jacket thrown over it all.
For a second, she reminded you of Alexia a few years ago.
That same kind of certainty.
That same easy confidence, like the world had never once given her a reason to doubt herself. Like everything she believed in was solid beneath her feet.
It was strange, almost cruel, how much could change, how drastically someone could become someone else.
You pushed the thought away and walked over to her.
âHi,â you said. âSorry if Iâm late.â
Ellison turned to you, her face brightening. âOh, donât worry, you werenât. I just got here.â
You smiled, relieved in a way you didnât want to examine too closely.
Ellison tilted her head. âSo, how are the post-party nerves?â
You let out a breath, dramatic but sincere. âHonestly? Happy that itâs over. And seriously considering never doing it again.â
Ellison smiled. âThatâs probably what everyone says right before they do it again.â
You laughed, and then she did too, and you liked it immediately. The sound of it. The way it loosened something in her face. The way it made her seem warmer, less impossible to reach.
âNext year,â she said, âwhen youâre sending out invitations and pretending this was your last one, Iâll remind you of this conversation.â
âPlease,â you said. âIâm begging you. Be cruel if you have to.â
âOh, I will,â she said lightly. âIâll do whatâs best for you.â
The conversation stayed soft after that, easy and light, and somewhere in the middle of it you started really looking at her.
Not just at the clothes, or the confidence, or the way she held her drink.
The small expressions she made when she listened. The way her eyes stayed on you like she wasnât half anywhere else. The way she seemed so sure of herself, and somehow still curious.
And despite yourself, you wanted to know more. Maybe that was why, when she said something else you were a beat too slow to answer.
It was embarrassing, the force of it. The simplicity. She was beautiful, yes, but that wasnât even the worst part. The worst part was how easy she was to be around. How quickly your body had decided that she could be trusted.
You took a sip of your drink, mostly to give your hands something to do.
And then, sharply and without permission, you remembered the first time you and Alexia had gone out for drinks. The same low light. The same charged feeling of sitting across from someone and being absurdly aware of every small movement: fingers around a glass, the tilt of a smile, the quiet thrill of being chosen for the evening.
The memory caught hard enough that you looked away.
âYou disappeared,â Ellison said.
You looked back at her. âSorry?â
Her mouth twitched. âFor a second. You got that look people get when theyâre either remembering something tragic or trying very hard not to kiss someone.â
A laugh escaped you, startled and a little breathless, mostly because the alternative was choking on the truth.
âThose are wildly different situations.â
Her tone stayed light, but her eyes didnât leave your face.
You could feel yourself wanting her attention with an intensity that made you feel younger than you were, and not in any flattering sense. Younger as in raw. Younger as in unfinished. Younger as in capable of making stupid, needy decisions and calling them instinct.
You wanted her to keep looking at you.
That was the dangerous part.
Not even wanting to sleep with her, though you did. That part was blunt, physical, almost simple.
The dangerous part was wanting to be wanted by her. Wanting her attention to land on you and make you feel less like a woman in the middle of a divorce and more like someone still fully alive inside her own body.
Ellison tipped her head. âYouâre doing it again.â
âThinking instead of talking.â
You smiled into your drink. âOccupational hazard.â
You could have lied. Probably should have.
Instead, you said, âIâm out of practice.â
Something in Ellisonâs expression softened, just slightly. âHaving a drink?â
âSure,â you said. âLetâs call it that.â
Ellison smiled, but didnât answer right away. For a second she just looked at you, like she was considering whether to let that sit or say something that would make it worse.
Then, from somewhere behind you, a laugh cut through the noise of the bar: bright, familiar, impossible to mistake.
You turned before you meant to.
She was across the bar with her girlfriend, one hand wrapped loosely around a glass, the other moving as she talked.
For one brief, cowardly second, you thought maybe she wouldnât see you.
Recognition crossed her face in pieces. First surprise. Then warmth. Then, quick enough to be almost invisible, her eyes moved to Ellison. Took her in. Came back to you.
Nothing in her expression changed, exactly.
Claudia had always been too perceptive to need to show her hand. She just seemed, suddenly, to understand more than you wanted understood.
She said something to her girlfriend and started toward you.
âHey, you,â Claudia said, leaning in to hug you, quick and easy and familiar enough to make something in your chest tighten. âIâm sorry I couldnât make it to Noraâs birthday. It was Linaâs momâs birthday too, and we couldnât miss it.â
âNo, itâs okay,â you said. âReally. Nora loved the present, though.â
âIâm sure she did.â
Claudia smiled, then looked at Ellison with effortless openness. âHi, Iâm Claudia.â
âNice to meet you,â Claudia said, and she meant it, which somehow made it worse.
Claudiaâs gaze moved between you once, briefly, with the calm of someone noticing more than she let on. Then she looked at Ellison again.
âI donât think I know you,â Claudia said to Ellison. âAre you two old friends?â
âNot really,â you said.
Ellison smiled, easy. âI coach Nora.â
Claudiaâs eyebrows lifted, just slightly. âOh.â
It was a small reaction, almost nothing, but you felt it anyway.
âSheâs been training with her for a few months now,â you added, hearing the extra explanation in your own voice and hating it a little.
Claudia nodded. âRight. Of course.â
Her girlfriend appeared at her shoulder then, smiling, and Claudia made the introductions with her usual easy warmth. For a few minutes the conversation stayed harmless. Noraâs birthday. Linaâs mother. The party. Some joke about children having better social lives than the adults responsible for them.
You smiled when you were meant to. You even meant some of it.
But something underneath had shifted.
Maybe it was only that Claudia belonged to a part of your life Ellison didnât know. Or maybe it was the opposite, that Ellison had entered your life through Nora, through this newer, smaller, more fragile version of it, and Claudia had understood that immediately.
Either way, you felt suddenly too legible.
When the conversation began to thin, Claudia touched your arm lightly. âIâm glad I ran into you,â she said.
And you meant that, which was annoying.
Her eyes held yours for half a second longer than necessary, warm, knowing, careful not to say anything she didnât need to. Then she smiled at Ellison again.
âIt was really nice meeting you.â
âYou too,â Ellison said.
Claudia and her girlfriend drifted back into their seats, and for a moment you watched them go without really seeing them.
Beside you, Ellison was quiet.
Then, after a beat, âThat was subtle.â
You laughed despite yourself, looking down at your drink. âWas it?â
There was no judgment in her expression. Just a kind of dry steadiness that made it hard to decide whether you wanted to laugh again or kiss her.
âShe knows Alexia,â you said at last.
Ellison nodded once, like sheâd already guessed as much.
You turned the glass slowly between your hands. âAnd she knows enough to know what this might look like.â
Ellisonâs mouth twitched. âWhat does it look like?â
At the calm confidence of her face. At the fact that she was making you answer your own question.
âThat,â you said, âis not very nice.â
âNo,â she said lightly. âBut it is a real question.â
You looked down at your drink and turned the glass once between your hands, suddenly too aware of them, of yourself, of the noise of the bar pressing back in around you. Music low under everything. Glasses knocking together. Someone laughing too loudly near the door.
When you looked up, Ellison was already watching you.
Not impatient. Not offended. Just quiet in that deliberate way people got when they were choosing not to crowd you.
For a while neither of you said anything.
The bar kept moving around you, careless and loud, but it felt far away now, as if the room had shifted slightly out of reach. You could feel your pulse in strange places. Your throat. Your wrists. The space just under your skin.
Claudia was gone. That should have helped.
Instead, the feeling sheâd left behind stayed lodged in you, sharp and humiliating, like being seen too clearly and all at once. Not by her, exactly. By yourself. By the version of yourself standing here with a drink in her hand and Ellison in front of her and too much of the past suddenly crowding in at once.
You looked back at your glass because it was easier than looking at Ellison.
When you finally spoke, your voice came out quieter than you meant it to.
âI think maybe I should go.â
Ellison held your gaze for a second, then nodded.
That was all. No argument, no attempt to make it lighter than it was. She just reached for her pocket, set some cash on the bar before you could protest, and slid off her stool.
You followed her out into the night almost without thinking.
Outside, the air felt cooler than it should have. Cleaner. The noise from the bar dulled the second the door shut behind you, leaving only the street, the traffic further off, the sound of someone laughing at the corner.
Then Ellison looked at you and said, quietly, âI get it.â
You frowned a little. âDo you?â
A small smile touched her mouth, but it faded quickly.
âI get enough of it,â she said. âYou donât have to explain.â
The gentleness of that made something in your chest tighten.
Ellison tucked her hands into her jacket pockets. âI know where you are in your life,â she said. âIâm not trying to push you into anything.â
You looked at her, really looked at her, standing there under the streetlight with her face gone softer than it had been inside.
âIf you want a friend,â she said, âI can be that.â
The words landed more heavily than they should have.
Maybe because they were kind. Maybe because they werenât. Maybe because there was something unbearable in hearing her make herself smaller for your sake, even gently.
At the patience in her face. At the restraint. At the fact that she was letting you leave without asking for anything, letting you retreat with your dignity intact, as if that was all this had been, as if the last hour had not shifted something live and reckless awake in you.
And maybe that was what did it.
Maybe it was the kindness. Maybe it was the way she said friend like she would mean that too. Maybe it was just that you were suddenly terrified of letting the night close over without touching her.
Before you could think better of it, you stepped toward her and kissed her.
Not carefully. Not with the hesitation youâd carried all evening. Just the sharp, undeniable fact of wanting, finally given somewhere to go.
Ellison made a startled sound against your mouth, brief and soft, and then kissed you back.
Her hand came up to your jaw, warm and steady, and for one impossible second everything in you went quiet. No Claudia. No Alexia. No divorce, no fear, no past crowding in to tell you what this meant.
Just her mouth on yours, the cool night air, the feeling of having crossed something you wouldnât be able to uncross.
When you pulled back, it was only far enough to breathe.
Ellison was still looking at you, her hand still lightly against your face, her expression unreadable in a way that made your pulse jump all over again.
âWell,â she said softly.
You laughed once, breathless and a little wrecked. âYeah.â
A small smile touched her mouth.
Ellisonâs hand stayed lightly at your jaw for one more second, then fell away.
She looked at you for a moment, like she was recalibrating.
Then she said, quietly, âMy place is close. We can call you an Uber from there.â
You knew what she was doing. Giving you an out inside the invitation. Making it easy to say yes without asking for too much all at once.
You held her gaze for a beat, long enough to feel your pulse kick again.
Something in her expression shifted at that. Not surprise, exactly, but a small, contained warmth, like sheâd expected you to refuse and was trying not to show she was pleased.
âOkay,â she said back.
And then, because apparently neither of you trusted the moment to survive too much examination, you just drifted into step beside each other and started down the street.
When stepped into Ellisonâs apartment, the contrast hit you immediately. It was sleek, modern, and impeccably neat. Clean lines, soft lighting, and that quiet sense of order that felt expensive.
âWell, this is nice,â you said, glancing around.
Ellison raised an eyebrow, a small smirk tugging at her lips. âDid you think I lived in a dump?â
âI didnât think anything, actually,â you replied honestly.
She leaned against the kitchen island, watching you. âI know you donât know me⊠but I was a good player.â
âI mean, Iâve never really known much beyond Alexia and Europe, if Iâm being honest.â
âItâs fair,â she said with a soft laugh. âYou shouldnât know.â
She tilted her head slightly. âWell⊠do you want something to drink while you order the Uber?â
You narrowed your eyes, studying her. The air between you had shifted.
âDo you want me to call an Uber?â
Ellison held your gaze, her voice low and steady. âI donât. But if thatâs what you want to do, then thatâs it. I didnât bring you here with expectations.â
The alcohol had loosened something bold inside you. You took a slow step closer, eyes locked on hers.
âNo expectations then?â
The phrase hung between you like a challenge.
Ellison didnât move, just watched you with that intense, unwavering stare. You kicked off your heels, feeling the cool floor beneath your feet. Then, without breaking eye contact, you began unbuttoning your blouse one button at a time, deliberate and unhurried.
She stayed perfectly still, her eyes never leaving yours, even as your shirt parted.
You moved closer, close enough to feel the warmth radiating from her body. Your fingers dropped to your pants, unbuttoning them slowly.
Only then did Ellisonâs gaze finally drift downward, tracing over your exposed skin. Her eyes burned with unmistakable hunger, dark and heated.
Ellison exhaled sharply, like sheâd been holding her breath. She finally pushed off the kitchen island and closed the distance between you. Her hand rose slowly, almost reverently, and brushed her fingertips along your collarbone, then down the center of your chest.
âYouâre really doing this,â she murmured, voice husky. Her thumb grazed the edge of your bra, sending a shiver through you.
âI thought you said you didnât bring me here for that.â you teased, though your voice had grown breathy.
A low, dangerous smile curved her lips. âI didnât. But Iâm not about to stop you either.â
She leaned in, her mouth hovering just inches from yours. You could smell her perfume, something warm and subtly sweet, you could feel the heat of her body.
When you didnât pull away, she closed the gap, kissing you deeply. Your hands found her waist, pulling her closer. Ellisonâs fingers slid into your hair, gripping just tight enough to make you gasp against her mouth. She walked you backward until your back met the cool edge of the kitchen counter, trapping you between her body and the marble.
She broke the kiss only to trail her lips along your jaw and down your neck, sucking lightly at your pulse point. One of her hands moved lower, skimming over your ribs, your waist, then boldly cupping your ass and pressing you harder against her.
âTell me to stop,â she whispered against your skin, âand I will.â
You answered by arching into her touch, fingers tugging at the hem of her shirt.
Ellison let out a soft, satisfied sound
Her hands were everywhere, kissing, touching, exploring. Confident and sure, like sheâd imagined this moment more than once.
The tension snapped the second you told her not to stop.
Ellison grabbed your waist and lifted you onto the kitchen counter like you weighed nothing. Your legs parted instinctively as she stepped between them, mouth claiming yours in a deep, greedy kiss. There was nothing polite about it, tongues sliding, teeth nipping, breath mixing hot and fast.
You yanked her shirt up and over her head. She did the same to your bra, tossing it behind her. Skin met skin. Her hands were everywhere, squeezing your breasts, sliding down your stomach, gripping your thighs hard enough to leave marks.
She broke the kiss only to drop lower. Her mouth latched onto your neck, sucking hard, then moved to your breasts. She took one nipple between her lips, biting just enough to make you gasp, while her hand pinched the other. You arched into her, fingers tangled in her hair.
Ellison pulled back, eyes dark and wild. She pushed your thighs wider apart, staring at your soaked pussy like she wanted to devour it. Without a word, her tongue dragged slowly up your slit, tasting all of you, before she dove in.
She ate you like she was starving: mouth wide, tongue fucking into you, then sucking hard on your clit. Two fingers pushed deep inside, curling instantly against that spot that made your vision blur.
âFuck yes,â you moaned, head falling back against the marble with a thud.
She groaned against your pussy, the vibration making your thighs shake. Her free hand gripped your ass, pulling you harder against her face as she devoured you. The sounds were obscene, wet, filthy, relentless. You could hear how soaked you were with every thrust of her fingers and every swipe of her tongue.
Your hand tightened in her hair, hips grinding against her mouth. Ellison looked up at you, eyes locked on yours while she sucked your clit and fucked you harder with her fingers. The eye contact was almost too much.
You were close already, the pressure building fast and brutal.
âIâm gonnaâfuckâEllison,â you moaned, the words breaking apart.
She didnât slow down. If anything, she got more aggressive, sucking harder, fingers pumping faster, growling against your pussy like she needed you to come just as badly as you did.
The orgasm ripped through you violently. You cried out, thighs clamping around her head, body shaking as pleasure flooded every nerve. Ellison kept licking you through it, drawing out every last pulse until you were a trembling, gasping mess on her counter.
When she finally stood up, her chin was wet with you. She kissed you fiercely, letting you taste how much youâd come for her. You reached for her pants immediately, desperate to return the favor, but she caught your wrist with a dark smile.
âNot yet,â she rasped, voice wrecked. âIâm not done with you.â
She pulled you off the counter, spun you around, and bent you over it. Your breasts pressed against the cool marble as she kicked your legs apart. From behind, she reached around and slid her fingers back inside you, fucking you deep while her other hand rubbed your sensitive clit.
You moaned loudly, pushing back against her hand, completely lost in the feeling.
Her hand slowed as her eyes caught the tattoos you had forgotten about, the ones that had become so much a part of you that they barely registered anymore. A small, âAâ was inked on the lower left side of your back, and just above the curve of your ass on the right side sat a â11â. Both of them somewhat hidden, but impossible to miss in this position.
Ellisonâs fingers stilled inside you for a second.
You suddenly became hyper aware of them. The marks youâd gotten for Alexia years ago. Still there. Still on your body. The realization hit you like cold water. You felt exposed, vulnerable in a way that went far beyond being naked and bent over her counter.
Ellison traced the â11â with her thumb, then brushed over the âAâ on the other side. She didnât say anything, but you could feel her gaze burning into your skin. She leaned down and kissed the â11â softly, then the âAâ, her lips lingering as if she was processing what they meant.
Even as she started moving her fingers again. Slower.
The pleasure was still there, but it was now tangled with guilt, shame, and memories of your Alexia. Her mouth was on your neck, sucking and biting softly while her thumb circled your clit with devastating precision.
You were trembling, so close again, when your phone started ringing from inside your purse.
You reached for it with a trembling hand.
Ellison felt you tense instantly. Her mouth slowed against your shoulder, her fingers still buried deep inside you as her other hand settled carefully at your waist.
The screen lit up with a flood of angry texts.
The phone kept ringing, vibrating angrily in your palm. You stared at the name, the heat that had been consuming you moments ago now clashing violently with a cold rush of tension.
You set the phone down without answering. The ringing finally stopped, but the damage was done. Frustration swirled in your chest.
Then something else took over.
You turned around sharply, grabbed Ellisonâs face with both hands, and kissed her hard, desperately. She made a surprised sound against your mouth before melting into it, kissing you back. You pushed her backward, guiding her out of the kitchen and down the short hallway toward what you thought it was her bedroom.
The moment you reached the bed, you pushed her down onto it. Ellison looked up at you as you climbed on top of her, straddling her hips. You kissed her deeply again, grinding down against her as your hands roamed over her body.
For a few blissful moments, it worked. The heat returned. You kissed down her neck, her chest, tasting her skin while your hand slipped between her thighs. Ellison moaned softly, arching up into your touch, her hands gripping your ass.
As you hovered over her, looking down at her flushed face and parted lips, Alexiaâs face flashed in your mind. Alexiaâs voice. The way she used to look at you before everything fell apart. The betrayal. The call. The anger.
You froze on top of Ellison, breath shaky.
Suddenly the heat in your body felt wrong. The anger you felt toward Alexia twisted painfully in your chest until your eyes started to burn.
Ellison noticed immediately. Her hands moved up to your waist, gentle and grounding.
âHey⊠hey, look at me,â she said softly.
You tried to blink the tears back, but one slipped down anyway, landing on Ellisonâs chest. Your throat tightened.
âI canâtâŠâ you whispered, voice breaking. âIâm sorry, I canât.â
You climbed off Ellison quickly, legs unsteady. She sat up, confusion written across her face as you hurried out of the bedroom and back toward the kitchen, still completely naked.
âI canât, Iâm sorry, I canât,â you kept repeating under your breath, the words tumbling out as you gathered your scattered clothes from the floor. Your hands were shaking as you picked up your blouse, your pants, your underwear.
Ellison followed you out, pulling a loose robe around herself, looking shocked and concerned.
âHey, wait, whatâs going on?â she asked, voice gentle but clearly thrown off. âWhat happened?â
You didnât look at her. You just kept dressing, fumbling with the buttons on your blouse.
âWho was it?â she asked. âOn the phone?â
You shook your head, eyes glassy. âI canât⊠Iâm sorry, I canât. I donât know.â
You grabbed your phone and opened the Uber app with trembling fingers, requesting a ride. Ellison stood a few feet away, watching you, still trying to understand the sudden shift.
You zipped up your pants and slipped your heels back on, repeating softly, âIâm sorry⊠I really canât right now.â
Ellison took a slow step closer but didnât crowd you. âOkay⊠talk to me. What just happened?â
You finally looked at her, eyes wet. âCan we talk about it another day?â Your voice was small and exhausted. âPlease?â
Ellison studied you for a long moment, then gave a slow nod, even though she was clearly unsettled.
âYeah⊠okay,â she said quietly. âWhenever youâre ready.â
The Uber notification pinged on your phone. You grabbed your purse, hesitating for half a second at the door.
âThank you,â you whispered. âFor tonight. Iâm really sorry.â
And with that, you slipped out, leaving Ellison standing in the middle of her apartment, still shocked and half-dressed, watching the door close behind you.