Top 10 Treehouse of Horror Segments (Seasons 4-10)
It is very difficult to narrow down The Simpson’s Treehouse of Horror episodes, let alone segments. The first ten seasons were phenomenal in their own way, yet there are some segments I felt made a stronger case for great storytelling of these characters.
10. Hell Toupee (Season 10)
Homer gets a wicked hair transplant from deceased criminal Snake. His hair then grows roots into his brain and turns him into an evil version of Homer. Some great laughs and just all around steady storytelling of Homer not knowing what is going on with his new doo. Also, the scene at the end of the toupee getting shot as it tries to walk away on it’s sideburns, is comedic gold.
9. Nightmare on Evergreen Terrace (Season 7)
Somehow the Simpsons managed to make an image of Willy getting burned alive become funny. Willy is told to wait his turn for help as he’s burning to death. It’s such an oddball thing to happen, and is perfect for some halloween scares. Willy invading the children’s dreams and killing them off is a terrible way to showcase this much loveable character, but it definitely captures how little the Springfield community care about their local caregiver.
At the outset of this episode, where we see the Simpsons family is at Professor Frink’s yard sale, Homer’s ponders over paying 50 cents for a once in a lifetime breakthrough of scientific creation (he pays 35 cents in the end and gets a pair of mood pants). This reveals how much Homer represents the idea of being an everyman, one that does not care about “science” and likes to haggle, maybe out of some misplaced principal. The rest of the episode is amazingly funny, with Homer trying to steal sugar from BartFly’s bag of sugar, or the two headed cat dog, “Twice the pet, none the mess!” and when the two rear-end versions of the animals come out, Bart says that can be Lisa’s. It goes to show all the motivations in an episode like this can be well intentioned, but horribly misplaced.Â
7. The Homega Man (Season 9)
The Last Man on Earth tale is remarkably better told with the Simpson’s family. It kinda puts the classic films to shame, as it seeks out humour in the most horrible situation. Homer’s realization that he does not need to wait in line, nor wait in traffic thrills him, so much so he realizes what a wonderful world it can be with no one else to boss him around. But as soon as he starts remembering his family with “little Bart... little Lisa.... little Maggie.... little Marge....” and they appear as spectres floating above his head, all swinging baseball bats as they float by, Marge included, who misses the ball, it shows how much Homer (simplistically) cares about his family. Oh yeah, and the mutants are awesome, they add so much to the issues of dealing with nuclear warfare.Â
6. King Homer (Season 4)
Another Hollywood classic made better by The Simpsons. King Homer’s lackadaisical demeanour and his over-aggressiveness pair perfectly with a giant ape. There’s some great animation going on in this episode, from Mr Burns prancing around after being winded by a smoke bomb, or Marge’s flailing from Homer’s huge grip. Also the reveal of Homer only being two flights above ground when climbing what I think is the Empire State Building, is comedic genius. And lastly, let’s not forget the mention of Candy Apple Island, which is home to apes, but they’re not as big.
5. Nightmare Cafeteria (Season 6)
Good golly, this episode is gross, but weirdly, in a way that makes it all okay. When children start piling up in detention, it’s obvious to the teachers you would only eat the students to clear up room, and also improve the school cafeteria’s failing dietary budget. There are so many moments in this episode where you just shake your head in confusion, like Marge’s advice for the kids:Â
“Listen, kids - you're eight and ten years old now; I can't be fighting all your battles for you.” - Marge
“But, Mom!” - Bart
“Nobuts! You march right back to that school, look them straight in the eye and say 'Don't eat me'.” - Marge
This goes swimmingly well for the kids in the end. The ending which is unfortunately out shined by a wonderful musical number about a fog that turns your skin inside out.
4. Time and Punishment (Season 6)
This time travelling segment is probably the most creative of all the segments, as the writers get to explore alternate universes for Homer’s chaotic time travelling adventure. As well, it provides proof that a Halloween episode of The Simpsons paints Homer as the misunderstood genius of invention with his time travelling toaster. Even the stupid premise of why the toaster needed to be fixed makes sense in some way: Homer’s hand constantly getting comically stuck in the toaster. It’s genius how we just accept this fact. I must admit, it is a little disconcerting to see Ned Flanders have a lobotomy centre set up for his minions, but it gives Ned Flanders a much different heightened christian-values iron grip over everyone. Notable quotes include “Stupid bug, you go squish now!” and Grandpa Simpson’s wedding day advice to Homer.Â
3. The Devil and Homer Simpson (Season 5)
The forbidden doughnut has gotten more questions than answers from me and others: it seems no one can understand why Homer keeps the last morsel of a doughnut around. Yet it is the perfect catalyst for a wonderfully subversive tale where we see Flanders play the devil, judging Homer on his crimes that keep him in hell. There are amazing scenes in this episode, including Homer being stuffed with doughnuts for eternity (what kind of punishment is that?) or the jury of historical baddies that are responsible for his sentencing. It is amazing to consider that Homer’s vices keep him from realizing the weight of choices in reality.
2. Dial Z For Zombies (Season 4)
Bart’s spells of department stores and talk show hosts raises the dead, and with them a barrel full of laughs. When Homer shotgun blasts Zombie Flanders we truly see how Homer feels about his neighbour, as he is unaware he’s even a zombie. We also learn that bodies are somehow beneath Springfield Elementary, as a scene of Willy finishing off a flower bed, has it suddenly destroyed by zombies popping out of the ground. We are treated to Ned Flanders’ perfectly timed blood-curdling scream after he lets in a group of zombies into his house, when he realized Old Sue isn’t really dead. The comedic pace of this episode races along with everyone in the town slowly becoming zombies, something rarely seen in most Simpson episodes. It’s definitely a lesson in how to tell a detailed story but at a fast pace, while keeping the fun in tact.Â
The most amusing of deaths, I think, is Krusty the Clown’s unfortunate on screen demise, and he then after tells the audience of children to send their parents’ brains, or write “parents brains” on a 3x5″ card and send it to the station. The absurdity of it all is wonderfully sinister and Homer’s lack of intelligence takes a walloping when not even Zombies will devour his ol’ gray matter. Let’s not forget about the literary nod at “Is this the end of Zombie Shakespeare?”
1. The Shinning (Season 6)
The Shinning has to be the Simpson’s perfect parody of a film. If the original Shining’s regular nobody Jack Torrence can go insane, it’s fair to say such isolation would have almost an instant effect on Homer. Everything in this episode is parodied on point, from the opening shot of the family station wagon winding its way down the mountain side, to the blood in the elevator and the wonderfully animated "No TV and no Beer Make Homer Go Crazy” scene. The only questions I had in this episode were “Why does Mr Burns own a hotel in the mountains?” then I realized how silly that was to ask.
Not only did this episode introduce me to The Shining, but it explains a good deal of what makes The Shining so scary, that having someone you love lose all sense, especially a loveable dope like Homer, is horrifying. The typewritten message of “Feelin’ Fine” tries to reflect a calm and collected Homer, but upon a flash of lightning lights up the walls, we truly understand what surrounds the person who’s gone insane. They are written words that engulf Homer and Marge, not just for comedic effect, but for revealing true horror in insanity. Kubrick’s original “All Work and No Play Make Jack a Dull Boy” is a good analogy for Jack’s dissolving psyche, but I am particular to The Simpsons’ take on it, because it reads really well.
The Shinning presents parody but with real issues in a way that Kubrick would have never considered, and I think that sometimes it is more powerful when you really know the characters, like in a TV series. Seeing Homer go insane is not only frightening for the characters on screen, but I think as a viewer, it affects me more to see someone (albeit fictional) I care about become insane.
Well, that’s all of them, there are plenty that are still good ones in my books, but I think the episodes that really connected with the characters’ personalities jived the best for my tastes.