My Father, Our Feelings, Ourselves
For much of my life, my father was a sort of enigma to me. He was there but he wasnât always âthere.â I was emotional, loud, boisterous; he was reserved, quiet, contained. I was such a sensitive girl -- I felt everything so intensely, took everything so personally -- that his exhaustion after a hard dayâs work or business trip to Japan affected me more than I cared to admit.Â
My mother was the parent in whom I confided. We would go for secret ice cream trips to Dairy Queen. I came to her when I wanted to start taking birth control. She talked me through the various ups and downs of my romantic life, in college and beyond. I could always tell my mother the truth.
Simply put, my teen years were a nightmare for the household. What I realize now was chronic depression manifested in emotional volatility, and Iâm sure my parents felt simultaneously helpless and frustrated. My mother was always the one to try to break through, to ask me if I needed to talk to someone, to comfort me when hot tears of shame and sadness once again sent me racing up the stairs to my bedroom from the dinner table. I sometimes felt like my father didnât care.
But looking back (something my nostalgic heart cannot help but do), I now see so clearly how untrue that is. My father cared; he still cares. He cares deeply. What I thought was my father failing to understand me was probably his inability to know how to communicate with me. His logical mind and my volatile heart struggled to overcome a sort of linguistic barrier, which makes the moments when we did connect even more powerful to me.
The moments I remember most vividly of my relationship with me father are all emotional turning points for me, for us. Here are a few of those moments.
In the early summer of 2002, the summer before I entered my junior year of high school, I was dreamily waxing poetic about last yearâs summer, which I had spent at the North Carolina School of the Arts summer session. I wanted to go back, to relive that magical experience, to know that it was still there for me whenever I needed to touch it and feel it. I begged my parents to let me visit the few friends I had who returned this summer. My father agreed.
We drove the nine hours to Winston-Salem as my heart raced with excitement and anticipation. He dropped me off on the campus and returned to our hotel, giving me the evening to galavant and reminisce. But though the setting was the same, everything was different. New people, new relationships, new energy. Rather than blending back into my idyllic summer memories, I spent the next hour crying on a curb. I learned an important lesson that day: you canât ever go home again.
I did something I rarely do: in a fit of tears, I called my father. I begged him to pick me up. He did. We drove back to the hotel as I deflected every attempt he made to understand what had happened, what went wrong. I told him I wanted to go home. The next day, less than 24 hours after we arrived, we did just that.
The car ride was quiet -- I remember listening to The Beach Boys (a shared love of my father and me). I felt mortified, like a complete fool. Mostly, I felt devastated and confused -- I was growing up and moving on, an act that was distinctly painful. I figured the car ride would be Hell -- what would I say to him? How could I face him when he knew how foolish I had been? But I donât remember anything like that. I remember my father being with me, quietly. He didnât pry or push; he was just there. Itâs as if he could sense how ashamed and crushed I was, and there was no real need to talk about it -- I just needed someone to quietly love me. In that moment of utter heartbreak, of learning the obvious yet painful truth that the past remains the past, my father was there with and for me.Â
On a frigid January weekend in 2008, my family came up to Evanston, Illinois to see my latest show, one of my last as a student at Northwestern University. I was cast as Nettie Fowler in Northwesternâs production of Carousel, which meant that I got to sing two of the biggest musical numbers in the show -- June is Bustinâ Out All Over and the iconic Youâll Never Walk Alone. I connected so deeply to Youâll Never Walk Alone; it wasnât a song that I sung, but rather a song that sung me. For that brief two minutes of each show, I knew I could just be. I wasnât competing, struggling, or even trying. I just let that song flow out of me, into the auditorium, through ears and hearts and souls. It was me, honest and open.
After the first performance my family came to see, I changed out of my costume, tidied up my dressing room, and headed to the lobby for what was more or less the performersâ âPraise me!â moment. We all loved it; it felt like greeting an adoring public, no matter how silly or terrible the show, and it fed our delusions of grandeur for half an hour. I spotted my family and instantly knew something was different this time: they were all in tears (except for my little brother; itâs okay, Nicholas!). My mother, my grandmother, my grandfather, my cousin -- their faces were wet with tears of joy and amazement. I then looked at my father and felt a thrust of emotion in my gut and throat -- he was crying, too.Â
Iâve only seen my father cry a select few times in my life, and all have been etched into my miserable excuse for a memory. I canât help but cry whenever I see him cry; itâs as if our emotions are linked and I feel what he feels, as he feels it.
As I watched his eyes swell with tears of pride and wonder, I felt my face grow hot. I hugged him and as he held me, he told me how incredibly proud he was of me, how hearing me sing that song was one of the greatest moments of his life. I muttered a meager âThank you, Dad,â as my emotional core was rocked. He saw me as me, he understood me. He was proud of me.
Iâm not a professional performer anymore, not that I ever really was. I love to sing, more than anything else in the world, but the business of musical theatre was too harsh. When I sing, itâs a reflection of me -- itâs not an act. My voice is a part of who I am. I couldnât help but take it personally when I didnât get a role or when someone told me that I wasnât right for something. The rejection was always personal because my performance was always personal.
I wondered for a while whether or not my father was disappointed that I couldnât hang with it, that I gave up, that I moved on to something else. The pride he expressed after hearing me sing Youâll Never Walk Alone was so poignant, so deep, that I wondered if I had betrayed him in some way by abandoning it.
But this Christmas, as my mother, father, aunt, uncle, brother, and boyfriend all celebrated together in what will always be one of my favorite holiday memories, I learned yet again that my hunch wasnât true. After we all had several glasses of wine, I noticed that my father got that look on his face again. I watched him as his eyes swelled with tears, his throat became a lump of encapsulated emotion, and he leaned in across the table towards me. He looked me in the eyes and said, very quietly, âIâm proud of who youâve become.â He smiled, nodded his head, and that was that.
Today is my fatherâs 62nd birthday. In some ways, heâs still an adolescent -- put on a doo wop song or a Pink Floyd record and watch as the layers of his nostalgic heart, just like my own, peel back before you. Heâs reserved a lot of time (unless watching a Northwestern football game, in which case look out!), but the moments of joy with him are unlike anything else. When heâs happy, you feel happy -- his joy is infectious. Not many people can do that.
In some ways, my father is still an enigma to me, but Iâve come to realize over time how alike we are, beneath the surface layer personality types and our differing linguistic styles of logical vs. emotional. My father feels, and he feels deeply, just like I do. Heâs just better at keeping it to himself than I am.
Except in those moments, the ones I hold so dear, when he quietly lets his feelings seep out and you feel the universe shift. I treasure those moments.
Happy birthday, Dad. Here's to more of those rare but exceptional moments.