Theres this specific thing Qilfrey mentions when he shows Coco the atelier that is such a good encapsulation of what this story is about that. He shows where everything is and then deliberately specifies that the bedroom doors can be locked.
Because these girls deserve to have privacy and space to feel completely safe for themselves. Its such a small detail but qilfrey pointing out "this is space is yours and only yours" is so important as a guardian. (It also is an amazing way to show what qilfrey is actually like early on and his geniune care for his apprentices)
And thats the best part of the manga & anime, this consistent theme of respecting children and their autonomy (as well as what it means to be a mentor figure). Yes their twelve and a little ridiculous, but he always allows them to evolve by themselves. He let's them make mistakes and guides them while always letting them retain their own autonomy, personality and beliefs.
Shirahama gives these girls the dignity they deserve in a world where everything kids but especially young girls do gets infantalized, ridiculed and demeaned. Their problems are real and given depth.
They question the knights moralis and work to fix it (or find loop holes...) because they have qilfrey and olruggio who back them up and encourage them to have these big ideas and to go against the grain, because even if their twelve, they are people to be heard and respected. Their ideas are not automatically stupid and niave just because their kids.
More often then not, kids get patronised non stop so for qilfrey to geniunely hear them out, no matter what happens or to take their emotional outbursts or stupid decisions seriously and not consider them "tantrums" but rather an outburst of emotions that anyone would have being put under that much stress is just so so lovely. Its just one part of the story but the manga does so much with it.
Love what you’ve written here, and I’d like to tack on a bit more about Qifrey.
Because the thing is, he isn’t perfect. He’s amazing, one of the best, if not the best teacher in Witch Hat, but even he has had his shortcomings when it comes to being supportive for kids.
And yes, I’m talking about (manga spoilers incoming)…
This is tack-ception but you reminded me of something aswell
(Manga spoilers warning)
I wanted to add that even when its about the girls, qifrey sometimes has to be reminded that his priorities should be his apprentices, not chasing a potential lead to brimhats. He tries his best and improves as time goes on but he isnt perfect.
He visibly weighs out his options in his altercation with Iguin when coco gets injured and really wants to just drop everything to go after Iguin. This actually makes the dynamic more interesting because he isn't this selfless mentor trope, but he will keep trying to be the best and that's much more valuable then if it was inherently easy for him.
















