Stray review: What We Did On Our Holiday
Didnât make it in before The Dissolve shut down, so here it is. (Also: Itâs my draft, so none of the polish Scott, Tasha, and/or Genevieve usually bring to it is there.)
What We Did On Our Holiday
Directors: Andy Hamilton, Guy Jenkin (PG-13, 95 min.)
Writers: Andy Hamilton, Guy Jenkin
Cast: David Tennant, Rosamund Pike, Billy Connolly, Celia Imrie, Ben Miller, Emilia Jones, Amelia Bullmore
Company: Lionsgate
Rating: 3 stars
by Keith Phipps
Heading into a vacation with her family Lottie (Emilia Jones) has just one request: âI need a list. Of the lies youâre going to tell.â Sheâs the oldest of her three siblings, so sheâs got a better sense of whatâs going on between her father Doug (David Tennant) and mother Abi (Rosamund Pike) now that theyâre not sleeping in the same house, much less the same bed. She also understands that they value keeping up appearances, especially as they head up to the Scottish Highlands for what will most likely be the final birthday celebration for Dougâs father Gordie (Billy Connolly), whose cancer has taken a turn for the worse. If they canât show him one last good time, complete with a show of togetherness, then can they even call themselves a family?
That questionâwhat makes a family a family?âis at the heart of the mild-but-engaging What We Did On Our Holiday, even if some contrived storytelling occasionally gets in its way. Co-written and co-directed by Andy Hamilton and Guy JenkinâBritish TV veterans best known for their series Outnumberedâthe film broadly telegraphs whatâs to come, laying out details in the early scenes for no real reason than to make them pay off later, particularly young Mickeyâs keen interest in vikings. When the family arrives at the home of Dougâs wealthy brother Gavin (Ben Miler), the film both indulges in familiar gags about his technology-filled âintelligent houseâ and sets up some future humiliation by revealing an A/V system capable of playing whatever one personâs watching on every room. Viewers could probably write their own final act after the first 20 minutes.
Yet while the film walks a familiar path, it takes some welcome digressions along the way. Connolly finds he melancholy beneath what could have been a standard twinkly-eyed grandpa role and the kids are a delight, particularly when the film leaves them to their own devices in semi-improvised stretches, one of which involves a flight into theoretical biology concerning what would happen if an ostrichâs egg was somehow inserted into its bottom. Itâs refreshing, too, in the way it sets up Doug and Abi (both well played by the leads) as doomed from the start. The film isnât about pushing them back together so much as figuring out how to minimize the damage of their break-up. And though the film keeps the tone light, is its willingness to acknowledge darkness that sets it apart. Midway through, a dramatic event best not revealed here changes the direction of the film, but rather than just rushing into the filmâs next chapter, What We Did On Our Holiday gives Lottie a moving series of scenes in which she wanders around the house looking for adults to help her and stumbles on one scene after another of her parents and near-relations squabbling. Searching for someone behaving like a real grown-up, she finds no one. Itâs a moment of recognition: Maybe, in the sourest stretches of adulthood, everyoneâs decided what lies they need to tell to get by, even if they know those lies canât last forever.











