Request: Could you do one where Peter and the reader are together some new lost boys try and touch the reader but Peter finds out and gets pissed and stuff goes down and Peter must remind her what real love is like or something..... Smut pretty please :X :)
When most people think of Neverland, they probably picture Disney’s portrayal, with boys no older than nine or ten running around in animal-inspired costumes and causing an adorable amount of chaos. Or at least, that’s what you would have imagined before meeting the real Peter Pan.
And although it’s a sweet animation with a storyline that you love as much as the next girl, it simply isn’t the truth,
Neverland really does preserve your youth for as long as you walk its soil- the creator got that part right- but it’s inhabitants are long passed the age of being innocent children and are frozen as teenagers, forever stuck in that curious, hormonal stage of life where suddenly you feel attracted to pretty much anyone around you. Being the only girl on the island they have regular contact with, sometimes the boys have to stop and reminds themselves exactly who you belong to, and what that certain person would do to them if he ever discovered they laid so much as a finger on you.
However, it would take a while for the newest members of the family to realize what Peter was truly capable of. They perceived him as a friend- someone who had saved them from their dull lives at home and never could they dream that there was a demon behind his smile. The stories of what he would do to any boys that dare disobey him seemed too gruesome to be true, and so they would ignore his threats and warnings to keep a distance from you.
Intrigued by your soft curves and bright eyes, often they would step out of line and your boyfriend would have no choice but to force them back again, which was never pretty. At times, it shocked even you how dark Peter could be- and he was always at his darkest when his possessive side took over.
“Hello, (Y/N),” You were following the pathway back to camp after spending an hour with Tinkerbell when you were stopped by a small cluster of the Lost boys. They were all relatively new to the island- none of them could have been here for any longer than a week but from what you had gathered they were having no trouble fitting in. They had seemed friendly enough at first too, but something about the way they towered over you made you feel uneasy.
“Hi,” you answered slowly, your eyes flitting between each of their faces. “What’s up?”
“We just wanted to ask you something,” continued the tallest of the four. He had dirty blonde hair and a cheeky grin- you had seen him around the camp fire on a number of occasions but his name had slipped your mind.
They shuffled forwards, and instinctively, you took a step back. “And what would that be?” Your hand automatically twitched towards your hip, where you usually kept your dagger on a sheath beneath your dress (Peter had insisted you carried some sort of weapon in order to protect yourself) before you realized with an inward groan that you must have left it in your hut after washing the same morning.
“Why is it that only Pan is allowed to have you?” He demanded.
“Excuse me?” You answered incredulously, shock overriding your features. They should count themselves lucky that the boy in question didn’t seem to be in earshot, because otherwise he would have ripped out each of their hearts and crushed them one by one. “I’m not a possession to be owned, or a prize to be won. We love eachother.”
They exchanged amused glances, as if they knew something you didn’t. “You don’t really believe that do you? You must have guessed by now that he’s just using you to…ah, satiate his needs.” A grubby hand reached out to tug at a lock of your (h/c) hair, before dropping until it met your waist. With a sharp glare, you clawed it off, although his words were having more of an effect on you than you would like. You tried your best not to listen to them- but as always there was a small voice in the back of your mind that edged you to pay attention. It was the very same whisper that sometimes made you question what exactly Peter’s intentions were. You loved him with every fiber of your being. You loved each of his flaws and would continue to do so no matter what he did. He could slit your throat with your own blade and still you would forgive him. It was so rare to be that passionate about something that when you found out that he felt the same it had almost been impossible to comprehend.
It wasn’t like he didn’t tell you often enough how he felt, because he did. Perhaps not in the traditional way of “I love you’s” (Pan is no fairytale prince and he won’t pretend to be, not even for you) but rarely a day would go by without him reminding you how wanted you were, and although at the time you would believe all his words and gestures, whenever you were alone again the flicker of doubt in your mind would return.
The truth was, there were moments where you simply didn’t feel good enough- and sometimes you would feel as if you were playing a waiting game, making the most of your relationship until he realized what you had known all along and send you back to where you came. The fact that the boys seemed to believe the same thing didn’t make you feel any better.
“It’s not fair that only he can have a taste,” the boy smirked, backing you into the trunk of a tree. You could feel the bark scraping your skin through the fabric of your outfit as he pressed himself so close to you, you could feel his heartbeat. (and the slight bulge in his trousers)
Disgusted, you kicked out and snarled against his grasp but his hold was tight, and when you opened your mouth to call for Peter you met instead the palm of his hand. “We just want a turn, (Y/N). Isn’t that what mothers do? Take care of people?” He mocked, most likely referring to the youngest of the Lost Boys, who had begun to recognize you as “mother” of the camp. His calloused fingertips slowly trailed up your bare leg, kneading each newly discovered patch of skin. His breath was hot on your neck- his eyes wide with anticipation as he practically foamed at the mouth. “We hear you two a lot, you know. We hear what you do… How responsive you are. I wonder, can I make you moan like that?”
You felt sick to the stomach- it was so wrong to have anyone other than Peter touch you. It was like trying to shove a key into a lock that didn’t fit; you belonged with him, not anyone else.
“I bet I can.” You glared furiously back at their smug faces- refusing to give him the satisfaction of a single sound. You knew they would get what they deserved eventually.
There was no use in struggling- even if you could find the strength to break free you were outnumbered and couldn’t fight past all of them, let alone outrun them. You’d have the advantage of the forest on your side- you knew each pathway like the back of your hand, but what they lacked in knowledge they made up with in speed, and there was no way they’d let you get away so easily. His fingers popped at your blouse, revealing the black underwear underneath. “I can’t wait to see the rest of you,” he groaned breathlessly, and you felt his sloppy lips at the cream of your neck, making its way along your collarbone and down your now- bare shoulder.
“I’m afraid you’re going to be disappointed,” A sudden cold seemed to fall over the clearing, a breeze rippling through the air and lifting a few strands of your hair with it. Peter had emerged from the greenery of the forest- his fists clenched so tightly that the skin of his knuckles turned white with the strain- and as if it was the most natural thing in the world, he shot one of them into the back of your captor and pulled out his heart, crushing it to dust in a movement so swift you could only catch a blur.
Immediately, the remaining boys scattered in a different directions, desperate to preserve their lives for longer than their friend had. But if Peter noticed, he didn’t say: his attention was focused on you. “How dare they,” he growls, aiming a harsh kick at the corpse by his feet with his right boot. With a glance downwards, you saw the ghost of the boys last smirk was still etched onto his face. Any normal person would be horrified that another living being had been murdered before their eyes, but all you could think was that you didn’t even know his name. “I warned them- now I have to kill them.” He’s practically shaking with rage- and when his eyes snap up to meet yours you can almost feel that anger as if it were static- crackling in the air between you. ‘He’s right,’ you think, unglueing yourself from the tree trunk and fixing your clothes. How dare they kid themselves they had a claim to your body- that you were their right. They had to pay, and you were happy to help Peter make them.
“Are you okay, darling?” Peter’s handsome expression is strained. Clearly, he is struggling compose himself- but when his hand cups gently at your cheek his features soften almost instantly. “If I had any idea that they would-”
“You love me, don’t you Peter?” you ask suddenly, staring up at him with hard eyes. You know that perhaps its stupid, but the Lost Boys taunts had wormed under your skin, reminding you how replaceable you felt, and you needed a reminder of what it was like to have his arms around you. For some reason, that feeling had the power to fix any problem you faced, and you knew this would be no different.
“Of course I do, (Y/N).” he looks surprised that you asked. “From the moment I saw you, I knew I had to have you.” He ducked his head to kiss you and the whole world fell away. It was slow and soft, comforting in ways that words would never be. His hand rested below your ear, his thumb caressing your cheek as your breaths mingled. Running your fingers down his spine, you pressed yourself closer to him until there was no space left between you. You had been here many times- if was the type of kiss that begun gentle, but had the makings to develop into much more.
Drunk with want, Peter’s only desire was to touch you- to move his hands beneath your summer layers and show you once and for all just how much you meant to him. With a small moan of need, he yanked at your legs until they circled his waist, smoothing his hands over your soft skin. “So perfect,” he mumbled between pecks, his lips brushing yours in a manner that’s no longer innocent, but fiery and passionate- drawing small noises from your throat as he moves to nip at your collarbone with his teeth. “You have no idea how long I waited for you, (Y/N).”
“Show me,” you demand, arching your head back and letting out a soft whine as his mouth reaches that special spot of skin that drives you insane. You desperately grind yourself against him, eager for relief from your aching chore and luckily, he takes the hint and within a flash you are shattering into his tent, clawing at his clothes with your fingers. Sex with Peter nearly always consists of painful hours of teasing- he’ll pump his fingers into your dripping heat or swirl his tongue around your clit until you’re on the verge of an orgasm- and then he’ll stop, waiting until the moment has passed before starting all over again. By the end of it you are nearly sobbing with want- begging him to slip inside you and make you cum.
But tonight is not one of those nights. His focus is not on lust- it’s on loving you. He wants you to feel every inch of him, for you to never doubt again just how much he cares for you.
Peter lays you down on his bed, his head ducked into the crook of your neck while one hand dips into the fabric of your underwear. The tips of his fingers brush against your clit as he gently slides down your panties, and that feeling of pleasure combined with the sensation of his mouth sucking purplish marks onto your neck is enough to make your eyes roll into the back of your head. “Oh,” you moan softly, automatically bucking your hips upwards into his as you slide his shirt from his shoulders.
“So wet for me,” he purrs into your ear, drawing the lobe slowly through his teeth. A shudder ripples through your body and he takes the opportunity to yank at his trousers, pulling at them until they lie in a pool at his feet. “My good little Lost Girl, always ready for me.” His words are husky, his hot breath on your skin. Peter could make even the most innocent love poem sound dirty, but you can’t deny that you love it about him. His darkness had always tempted your purity.
“Please,” you half yelp, half whisper. With fumbling hands, you tug at the waistband of his boxers, drawing him closer until he hovers above you, your noses brushing. It’s not often you do this here, in his tent- he had always preferred your bed to his. Only the material of his underwear separate you and with a small smirk of anticipation you push them down, running your hand along his thick length as it springs to his stomach. He bucks into your grasp as you guide him to your entrance, the head of his cock teasing your folds. You can feel your wetness practically dripping to your thighs as he finally pushes inside with one sharp thrust, the entire bed moving with the force of your movements.
“I love you, I love you, I love you,” Peter chants into your neck, moving slowly to ensure that you can feel each inch of delicious inch as he buries himself inside you and then draws to the hilt again- before thrusting at an angle that makes you squeal. Complete pleasure is overriding your senses- in that moment, all you can think of his how good he’s making you feel and how you never want it to stop.
The bed begins to creak as it rocks in time with your bodies- shaking beneath you almost as if it’s no match for your rhythm. Although if it collapsed at any moment, you were sure neither of you would care.
“I know, darling,” he mumbles after you let out a particularly loud moan, his thumb moving to trace circles on your clit. “I know how badly you want it.”
“Oh God, Peter-” you gasp as he hits your G-spot, triggering an entire new wave of pleasure that only heightens with each thrust. “Feels so good. I need to- oh,”
He picks up the pace, pulling out once more and slamming in again so hard that your orgasm hits you immediately- a short scream passing your lips that he quickly silences with his thumb. Peter watches you through hooded eyes as your tongue swirls around his fingers, your head flying back to hit the creased blankets as you cum. The sheer expression on your face and the feel of your walls contracting around him is enough for Peter to reach his own climax and he spills inside you, panting heavily as he manages to pull out and collapse onto his back by your side.
The two of you lie there for several moments, trying to catch your breaths as you come down from your high. “I love you,” he reminds you again, wrapping an arm around your waist and pulling you to him. You lie on your side, one leg draped over his and you can’t help but smile.
“I know,” you reply sleepily, nuzzling into his awaiting arms. This time, you mean it.