I finally found someone that I could ask the following question without confusing them or making myself sound stupid:
Do you find that the Jedha testing of the Death Star is like the bell ringing of an IPO, in the sense that the Death Star and the company both “went public” at that moment?
*Sending hugs and best wishes your way*
This inspired a mental image of both Grand Moff Tarkin and Director Krennic one one of those podiums (there is a sign behind them that reads “DS-1”, with the Tarkin Initiative symbol), fake smiles plastered on their faces and trying to act nice so they can inspire confidence in prospective shareholders. The sort of faces that are telling: “No hidden faults, no petty rivalries among the management, everything is fine. Safe to invest! Give us your credits!”
If the attack on Jedha is the ringing bell, does that mean that the whole thing Tarkin did on Scarif was some sort of hostile takeover? 🤔
*Sending hugs and best wishes as well!*
Exactly! I have a head canon that Krennic intentionally placed that fault within the Death Star as a poison pill because he knew there would be a hostile takeover anyway. And by his design, Tarkin would disappear with the Death Star.
Krennic really could use a lawyer’s help at least to remind him the danger of specific performance as a remedy and help him sort of his compensation plan!
Oh, that’s a very cool headcanon! Would that imply that everything we see in Rogue One between him and Galen Erso is a big act of pretend? Krennic and Erso have been working together all along so both of them are responsible of the fault? Or Krennic knew about Erso’s handiwork way before the events of the film, and allowed it to happen, thinking it might benefit him in case of hostile takeover? In both cases then, when the pilot attracts too much attention and Tarkin is aware of the rumor, the director has to keep up appearances the way he did?
As a wise man once said “nothing says sorry like money” and I would add “and a nice villa on Naboo to compensate those unquantifiable moral damages” xD
Thanks so much for liking my headcanon! Yes, that would imply that everything we see in Rogue One between him and Galen Erso is a big act of pretend. Additionally, I believe the thermal exhaust port was highly likely designed by Krennic and Erso together.
Here is why: I live with a house mate - a physics PhD student studying in the School of Applied & Engineering Physics. (For the record, I am a 3L, not a full-fledged lawyer yet but will be one soon! Sorry for any confusion.) From what I learned from him and other people studying physics, I get the following impression: physcists are responsible for finding out the theories (through experiments, etc) for building a machine, while engineers use those theories to build a machine and make sure the machine carries out its purpose. Even people like my housemate, whose specialization in physics borders so close to engineering, don’t actually do an engineer’s work. Thus, it would be impossible for Erso to 1) find the theory of the superlaser, 2) supervise the construction of the superlaser, and 3) take care of the inner design of the battle station itself at the same time. I am very frustrated by the extent to which the writers simplified the design and construction of the DS-1.
If they designed the fault together, that would imply Krennic either changed his mind at some point, or his loyalty didn’t belong to the Empire at the very beginning. That would make his character much more interesting. Also, under this headcanon, Krennic would need to come clean with Erso at some point. That would be a fascinating moment in their arcs.
I thought that it would be impossible for Krennic to ignore the question of what’s gonna happen to him and his team after they delivered the DS-1. Given Krennic’s talent of predicting and manipulating people’s actions (as we have seen in Catalyst), it wouldn’t be hard for him to realize that he and his team would likely be removed from the picture and slienced.
In my home country during the ancient times, the architect who built the cemetery of a King would be sealed inside the cemetery and die there because the King feared that people would find his body in the cemetery (dead people can’t talk) and do bad things about it. Krennic’s situation is compared to that of the architect mentioned earlier. He just knew too much.
So what we see in Rogue One was simply a replay of how Krennic used Captain Has Obitt and his team to pin Tarkin at the battlefield and prevent him from messing with his work (see Catalyst). The only way to fool Tarkin and escape alive is to make Tarkin believe that he was on Scarif because Tarkin would definitely target Scarif and fire the DS-1. The pilot, the interaction with Tarkin and Vader…were all calculated to serve the ultimate goal of faking his death - it was too easy for Krennic. He might also be able to save Erso along the way.
I read this right after waking up this morning and I thought “alright, I’m going to wait and reply with worthy words” but… There are no words that I can add to this. I love this headcanon. I really do. This take does Krennic the justice he deserves! Sometimes, I must confess, I get a bit frustrated with some of the takes on this character. He is terribly flawed, that’s true, but he is also brilliant (I’d even go further and say that for an architect that basically created that Imperial sort of brutalist architectural aesthetic he must have something else - sensibility, of a sort, even). This makes my own hc of how he survives - because he is alive, period - pale in comparison btw. Ah, but I am ranting! XD
This. Is. Good. Very good. Yes! I’m so hyped! :D
Catalyst. I got a copy last month but not the time to read it (and I’ve been meaning to for quite a while). Hopefully these holidays I’ll do it! I think I ate a spoiler along the post too but that’s alright!
About killing off the architects and people that know too much, it is established that the Empire does that (thinking about Tarkin’s Maw Installation in the old canon lore, and how Natasi Daala made sure that whoever knew too much never made it through on their way out the Maw). Orson Krennic, as an ISB Director, has probably handled similar situations, so it makes total sense that he knew what was coming next for him and his team.
I wish you the best of luck with your studies! Thank you for sharing this!!
Thank you so much for liking my headcanon! I have never had such an enthusiastic response before, and it makes the best holidays gift for me XD
Sorry for the spoiler! I hope you find some time to read Catalyst because it is great and provides a lot of background on Krennic, Erso, and Tarkin. Krennic and Tarkin make the best board-room drama. There were a lot of problems with Catalyst too, which opened up a lot questions about Krennic and Erso. But at the same time, possibilities and potentials. After you read Catalyst, I am sure one of the questions you have would be: well, what exactly did Krennic study in the Futures Program, what exactly did he build? The writer wasn’t being precise with his words. I will say no more on Catalyst now. I’d love to discuss it with you when you finish reading it but no pressure because I couldn’t imagine how busy you are!
I completely relate to your frustration with some of the takes on Krennic’s character. People all have their problems, but Krennic’s flaws are artificial - in the sense that it’s not organic, that it won’t really happen in a real person’s mind and actions. The negligence and illusions that Krennic had towards the end of his project, which we saw in the movie, are entirely off the chart. I believe that criminal law has to set a new category for that type of negligence. Krennic’s flaws are designed to make sure the Rebellion will win. And I totally agree with you that an artist who created the Imperial brutalist architectural aesthetic is hypersensitive and thinks about “deep” questions like what my next job would be, do I even get the next job?
The problem with Krennic’s character, I guess, is that he was created by multiple writers, and some of their ideas/designs conflict with those of the others. Krennic is like a combination of a CEO (the type that got sued by shareholders for breaching their fiduciary duties - I won’t say he is the type that messed up financial statements because Krennic got things done), an engineer, and an artist. The combination makes him so wonderful and lovable but gives us fans endless frustration because we want him to be alive!
In my headcanon, Krennic survived, and he lived on one of those planets close to Thrawn’s homeworld. Krennic built palaces for politicians on that planet. He also left many lovely houses and buildings in general, all with his signature designs. His work used designs far surpassing the-state-of-art architecture on that planet. Decades later, when the New Republic sent diplomats and exploration teams to that planet, they noticed Krennic’s work which seemingly didn’t belong to this place. And it was until the New Republic officials had experts investigate the Imperial-era art history that they realized the Father of the Death Star survived Scarif. I thought this would be a fantastic way for Krennic to make his statement to the universe that he survived, and he outsmarted them all.
Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts with me. I wish you happy holidays and all the best with life and work!




















