Oh well, one more uninspired anthology
"and the women around them wait, tempt, suffer, obey, betray, or disappear."
Oh, so they have character, but you don't like it
"Through a bold feminist lens, this book revisits the ancient goddesses, mortal women, witches, queens, prophets, mothers, and monsters who shaped the mythic imagination—and asks what they were before patriarchal storytellers made them smaller."
I don't trust this book will do anything good with these characters
"Gaia becomes passive “Mother Earth.” Hera becomes the jealous wife. Cassandra becomes the madwoman no one believes. Medusa becomes the monster whose story begins only after male violence. Hecate becomes the frightening crone at the edge of the road."
The audacity to call Gaia "passive"
"How Hera’s ancient independence was reframed as jealousy and marital disobedience"
Hera wasn't called disobedient for her anger against Zeus' infidelity, in fact he doesn't even stop her from attacking those women
"Why Hecate's threshold power became associated with fear, witchcraft, and the crone"
But she is the deity of witchcraft...
Edit: this book now has a audio sample, and not to my surprise it talks about the pre-hommeric society being full of powerful women who were later controled by the patriarchy
I'm worried about the chapter around Hecate
The best I can describe this is hatred and envy. At no point you feel that the writer Elara likes reading anything about mythology, it's as if she reads searching for an excuse to complain about the patriarchy
"These epics defined what it meant to be a hero, what it meant to be a leader, and, crucially, what it meant to be a woman."
This last one is totally false
"Homer's lens filters out her humanity to highlight the men's fragile egos."
... while I agree that Briseis should have gotten more lines, it's insane that you missed the point of Achilles and Agamemnon being stupid for causing such drama over her
"But the notice the nature of her cunning. It is defensive. It is entirely confined to the domestic space. And it is ultimately focused on preserving her husband's estate until his return."
See why I called this a work of hatred? Penelope used her agency to avoid re-marriage but according to this author this is bad because every single female character should behave like "Strong Independent Woman who doesn't need a man"™️
She disregards Athena, Nausicaa, Calypso and ignores the fact that Circe also helped Odysseus
"But Aeschylus was writing for a city that could not tolerate a woman who wielded masculine power."
And of course you totally ignored that Clytemnestra was a terrible mother to Orestes because that would weaken your complaint
For the surprise of NO ONE, this petty writer is lazy when doing "research". She called Medusa a priestess of Athena 🤦♂️
"We accept that Zeus is the rightful king, that Penelope's silence is a virtue, that Clytemnestra is a monster, and that Medusa's punishment is the natural consequence of her beauty."
... don't know how to explain everything that is wrong with this 😐
"If he sang a song suggesting that the earth belonged to an ancient, terrifying female deity who demanded the subservience of mortal men, or a song glorifying a woman who outsmarted her husband and seized his throne, the bard would not simply be booed. He would be cast out in the dark."
They had no problem with Procne getting revenge against her husband after he attacked her sister Philomela
"In Ephesus, they worshipped a multi-breasted Artemis who was less a virginal huntress and more a primal, unstoppable force of biological creation."
But Artemis is portrayed as both
"They forced the sovereign female deities into the newly constructed, patriarchal family tree of Olympus. The ancient goddesses were assigned new roles: they became the wives, the daughters, the sisters, or the r*pe victims of the male Olympians gods."
That's now they were treated. That's how you see them
@sarafangirlart this book is a hate crime against Hera while pretending to be feminist
"—not virginity in the modern, patriarchal sense of sexual purity, but virginity in the ancient sense of being complete unto herself, belonging to no man. She was sovereign. She was whole."
This paragraph is ridiculous. The ancient greek society considered women objects, but the ancient ancient greek society was super feminist and progressive 😑
"When Hera opposed Zeus in the myths, she was no longer a sovereign deity fighting to maintain her ancient jurisdiction. She was just a nagging wife who wouldn't learn her place.
"When she lashed out at the women Zeus assaulted, it was no longer a fractured memory of older goddesses fiercely protecting their sacred precints from male intrusion; it was reduced to the irrational jealousy of a woman blaming the other woman."
"They ensured that every time a young greek girl heard the name of the most powerful female deity in the cosmos, she also heard a warning: Even the Queen of Heaven cannot win a fight against her husband. Even the Queen of Heaven is made miserable by her resistance. Submit, or be mocked."
I hate this. And you know Elara would find problem with the wood wife myth from Pausanias
"It extended it's reach to the mortal women of myth, carefully pruning away any traces of divinity or dangerous agency. And no woman was pruned more aggressively than Helen of Troy."
Pretends to care about Helen while ignoring she wasn't from Troy. Typical
Of course Sparta would treat Helen as a goddess, that's her hometown
"The bards took the sovereign goddess of Sparta and stripped her of her divinity. They reduced her to a human woman, defined entirely by her physical beauty and her proximity to men."
"The message encoded in the curated oral tradition was unmistakable: when a woman stops outside the boundaries of patriarchal household, when she breaks the bonds the male ownership, cities burn and thousands of men die."
"But read it through the architect's lens. It is the desperate attempt of an older, local religious tradition to push back against the Panhellenic character assassination of their goddess. It is the spartan cult crying out: Our goddess did not betray her husband. Our goddess is not a pawn in your epic games."
I still don't care about your opinion
"Women had their own robust, parallel oral traditions. They sang songs while woving at the loom. [...] In these spaces, far from the male gaze, women undoubtedly told different versions where the goddess won. They told versions where the mortal's woman rage was justified."
Of course she uses the "there's a secret version of the myth told by women that just so happen to fit with my modern mentality!" argument 🙄
So I was right. Elara wrote this 300 pages torture because she was angry at her college professor