hellooo! can I request something with dexter? maybe him having his first normal relationship? normal by his standards. someone accepting all his flaws and everything that comes with dating him.
Basically! Someone who he can be himself completely
Pairing: Dexter Morgan x Reader
Summary: Dexter Morgan’s First Normal Relationship—And He’s Over the Moon About It
Author's note: Hii hope you enjoy! Dexter is so cute!
Dexter Morgan never thought he’d have a relationship like this.
Correction—he never thought he could have a relationship like this.
Not with everything that he was. Not with the Dark Passenger lurking in his every thought, whispering in his ear, dictating the things he had to do.
And suddenly, everything changed.
The first time Dexter realized he didn’t have to hide from you, it nearly short-circuited his brain.
He was so used to pretending—to fabricating a version of himself that fit into the world. He’d done it with Rita. With Lila. With Lumen. Even Hannah. There was always something he had to keep buried, locked behind a carefully crafted facade.
But with you, there was no mask. Because you knew. You knew everything. And you stayed. More than that, you accepted him.
The first time he told you about his Dark Passenger, you had listened—not with horror, not with disgust, but with quiet, thoughtful interest.
“I always knew there was something different about you,” you had said, studying him like a puzzle you were excited to solve. “I just didn’t know it was this.”
And then, the question that changed everything:
“Do you ever feel like… this makes you who you are? Like you wouldn’t be you without it?”
Dexter had stared at you, his usual sharp mind unable to form a response.
Because, for the first time in his life, someone had understood him.
Not feared him. Not tried to fix him.
Now, months later, Dexter is happier than he’s ever been.
He didn’t even think happiness was something he wanted—but apparently, it is. Because every time he looks at you, every time you roll over in bed and mumble his name in that sleepy, content voice, every time you lean up on your toes and press a kiss to his jaw just because you felt like it—his chest does this tight, foreign thing.
He likes it. He loves it. And the best part? You love him. The real him.
Not the mask. Not the carefully curated version of himself he used to present to the world. Just him.
It still catches him off guard sometimes. Like now.
You’re sitting on the couch, watching a movie, your legs draped over his lap as you absently run your fingers along the veins in his forearm.
He’s not even watching the movie anymore. He’s just watching you.
You notice, of course—you always notice.
“What?” you ask, amused, tilting your head.
Dexter shakes his head, his lips twitching into something dangerously close to a full-on smile.
“You really like touching me,” he observes, glancing down at the way your fingers trace along his wrist, ghosting over the tendons with no hesitation, no wariness.
You hum, turning your attention back to the screen. “You’re my boyfriend,” you say simply, like that explains everything.
Because the word boyfriend still sends a strange, electric thrill through him.
It’s the most normal thing in the world.
And yet, for him, it’s everything.
His fingers twitch where they rest on your thigh, a silent reminder that he’s still adjusting to this whole affection thing. But he doesn’t pull away.
He never pulls away from you.
Because you are the one thing in his life he never wants to hide from.
Later that night, as you’re getting ready for bed, Dexter watches you from the doorway, arms crossed, a rare softness in his gaze.
“You’re staring again,” you tease, glancing at him through the mirror as you tie your hair up.
Dexter doesn’t even try to deny it.
You shake your head, amused, walking up to him and poking his chest. “What’s going on in that big, scary brain of yours?”
His lips twitch. “Nothing scary.”
A pause. Then, he exhales, tilting his head slightly.
“I think I’m just… really happy.”
You blink, as if caught off guard by the admission. “Yeah?”
Your face softens, and then you’re wrapping your arms around his neck, pulling him into a kiss that he leans into without hesitation.
Because he doesn’t have to pretend anymore.
And that’s better than any kill high he’s ever had.
stormborns
snowghoul
origamiaround
2087
titsay
romaincrisis
baratheonpilled
kianamaiart
pixelskylines
