There are millions of ways people can perceive things. When someone reads a book, they may see the main idea differently from everyone else. In the novel, The Good Cripple, the author, Rodrigo Rey Rosa, leaves it up the reader to figure out what his main argument is. He leaves his readers with an open ending, so that the reader can use their imagination to figure out what he is trying to say in the novel. Rosa's novel expresses many ideas, but his main point was that Juan Luis Luna, the main character, was in fact “the good cripple”, as the title suggests. He was a good man and Rosa leaves clues about it throughout the novel. Juan Luis Luna is a good man because he did not seek revenge from his kidnappers, he does not follow in his father's footsteps, and he decides not to have children so that they do not have to endure the hardships he went through. First of all, Rosa's main argument is that Juan Luis Luna was a good man because he did not seek revenge from the people who kidnapped him. Of course he was angry and had thoughts of killing them but he never has the courage to do so. Rosa states “It wasn't worth dirtying his hands with the blood of a man like that” (93). Luna was smart enough to let all of his temptations go and realize that killing Bunny would not do any good. After Luna spoke to Bunny and left without doing anything, Bunny says “If I were him, I wouldn't have thought twice about shooting me or hitting me in the back of the neck...but he chickened out” (Rosa 3). Bunny believes that Luna is a coward, but after seeing that Bunny had a wife and a family to take care of, he decided to be the better person and walk away. This shows that Luna is indeed a good person, because any other person would have tried and seeked revenge. Instead, Luna just wanted the truth about what had happened to him and was not interested in stooping down to their level. Therefore, he is the good cripple, as the title suggests. He is crippled physically and still manages to maintain the goodness in him. Some people may argue that Luna is not a good man, that he is just a coward, but he is not. Luna went through a near death experience. He had his foot cut off by men who were his childhood friends. He could have easily had it in him to kill Bunny as soon as he saw him, but he says so himself that it is not worth it. He is smart enough to know that it will not solve anything. If he were a coward, he would not have gone to meet with Bunny, knowing he was one of the kidnappers. Cowards take the easy way out. Luna would have been a coward is he had killed Bunny because that would be the easier thing to do in his situation so that it would not bother him any more that the people who tortured him are still alive. Luna does not want to be an evil man, he does not want to be like his father who was cold. He made a good decision because he is, in fact, a good person on the inside. Second of all, Luna is a good man because he decides not to follow in his fathers footsteps. Throughout the novel, we get clues that the father, Don Carlos, is a part of some kind of illegal business. We get this idea from when the author states, “he took a checkbook for an account in a foreign bank. He read the balance: two and a half million dollars” (Rosa, 44). This reveals that Don Carlos had a lot of money in foreign banks. The reason he has foreign banks is because the way he gets his money is illegal. Don Carlos is angry at Luna because he does not want to be in the business with him. Luna chooses to be a better person. He does not want to follow in the footsteps of his father because he knows that he is better than that. One of the kidnappers tells Luna “You're going to write him a nice letter...You're going to tell him that you've repented of the way you live and that when you get out of here you're going to lick whatever he wants you to lick” (Rosa, 25). This proves that Luna did not live the life that his father wanted him to. He had to lie just to get his fathers attention. Even with all the corruption around hi, he never gave in to the demands of his father. He was such a good man that he even risked his relationship with his father to live his own life without joining the business of his father. This shows that he is not as corrupt as everyone else at that moment. He maintained his goodness even when pressured by his own father. Some may argue that he did give in to the pressures. He wrote a letter to the father saying that when he got out he would follow in his footsteps. In that case he did give in to the corruption. But, in his defense, he had his life in his father's hands. If he did not lie to his father and tell him that, he could have been killed. He had to do whatever he could to stay alive. He wanted his father’s attention and believed that was the only way to do so. Many people in that situation would do the same. Sure he can be called names for it, but that does not make him a bad person. He is a good man trying to get out of a bad situation that his father put him there in the first place. The one man that put him in is the only man that can take him out. He has to lie in order to save his life. Lying does not necessarily mean that someone is a bad person, it just means they are trying to get out of a bad situation. Although he does give in to the corruption at one point, there was not much else he could do to save his own life. In addition, Juan Luis Luna is also a good man because he decides not to have children. He decides this because he does not want his children to live in an evil world. He did not want them to go through what he did. He wants to end the evil in his blood as much as he can. He is not evil, but his father is and he knows that he has it inside of him. He chose a different route than his father but who knows if his children would. He does not want to take that chance. Rey Rosa states “On a shelf...a photograph...caught his eye...Bunny's son, undoubtedly...At that moment Juan Luis was strangely certain that he wanted no descendants” (112). Juan Luis decides that after meeting and talking to Bunny about the kidnapping. After seeing the picture of Bunny's son he left and decided not to kill him. He did not want the son to go through the pain of losing his father. It is obvious that Luna becomes an even better person at that point because it shows that he actually cares. The goodness comes out of him. We also know that he does not want to have children because Rey Rosa also states “he pulled out to spill his semen on her smooth belly with its fine tracing of hair; it was a risky day and he did not want to have children—he was sure of that” (116). He is a good person for not wanting to have children because he did not do it for selfish reasons. He did it so that his children would not have to endure the hardships he did. He wanted to end the corruption in his family. He thought that would be the best way to do it. Some people may argue that him deciding not to have children is a bad thing. He does not let the children decide the path they want to take. He does not even give them the chance to live and choose for themselves. They did not have to be corrupt like the father was. They could have chosen a better life. Nevertheless, it does not change the fact that they would be living in a corrupt society. The fact that they would have been related to Don Carlos could have affected their lives in a negative way. It definitely affects Juan Luis in a negative way. The father had millions of dollars and the kidnappers knew that and that's why they decided to kidnap him. He did not do anything wrong, it was only because he was the son of Don Carlos. If Juan Luis had decided to have children, they could have gone through the same thing just for being related to him. Juan Luis did not want to have children just so that they could be corrupted by society. He makes a wise decision in deciding not to have children. He is a good person who thought about the kinds of lives they would live if he did have children. He thought ahead and made a good decision. Furthermore, Juan Luis is a good person. The title of the novel has to do with him. He is the good cripple, literally. He is crippled because he has to walk with a cane and he is a good person throughout the novel. He never seeks revenge from his kidnappers. Instead, all he wanted t=was answers to him questions and then he left him alone. Juan Luis did not give in the the pressures of his father. He did not want to be like him. He did not want to live the life that his father did and because of that his father cut him off. Despite all that Juan Luis stayed true to himself and did not get into a business that he knew was illegal. He decides not to have children just so that they would not have to live the life that he did. Even though he was not in business with his father, the bad decisions of his father affected him the moment he was kidnapped. He was only kidnapped because his father had money. He did nothing wrong. He did not want his children to have to go through the same. He ended his family tree and the Luna's would no longer exist after he and his father died. It is his way of ending the corruption in his family. Juan Luis Luna was a good man and he stayed true to himself throughout the hardships he faced. It was extremely difficult for him, but he makes the right decisions.