TW: dissociation, death mention, suicide ideation
‘…Katie went missing two years after your death.’ Nothing else James had said, or hadn’t said, could process then. Those words echoed in Lark’s skull accompanied by that high tinnitus ringing reserved for the nightmares that plagued him every night. Somewhere off in the distance maybe James said he felt sick, but the nausea twisting Lark’s own stomach drowned that out. Time became excruciatingly slow and Lark could feel his soul and his body uncouple from one another. He was outside of himself now, some other thing that was only half there, looking down on the hollowed out shells of two brothers meeting again in some place between realities.
It could have been seconds or even hours that passed before Lark realized he should come to some understanding of the implications of Katie’s disappearance. Maybe she needed to get away to process her grief and decided to go off the grid entirely. That was a best case scenario that Lark found extremely unlikely. If the roles were reversed, he could imagine feeling a gaping emptiness knowing Katie was no longer in the world with him. That strong, psychic bond between twins severed, leaving an aching sensation that would never pass. Like a phantom limb. He could imagine failing to find any reasonable way to continue on after that. He felt a twinge of it now. Perhaps the only way she could bear the idea of the world without him was simply to follow. And maybe…
He looked, wide-eyed toward the jungle. “She could be here too.” He needed anyway to convince himself she wasn’t dead. He looked back at James, “Jay, Katie could be here too!” The sickening feeling resurfaced and, like a man possessed, he took off running toward the jungle he had so recently sworn off for the foreseeable future. He didn’t check to see if James was following him. He didn’t care. He just needed to make sure. Cutting through the trees, he moved with pointed purpose for the spot where he feared to find that familiar face which looked so much like his own.
Finally, the lagoon came into view, surrounded by trees mottled in the shapes of statuesque corpses. He didn’t want to look, for fear of finding something, but he knew he had to. For some half-closure, he had to know. His eyes searched the tomb trees frantically. Then his knees buckled and he collapsed to the ground.
A sigh of anxious relief, that lifted no real weight off his shoulders, rattled through him. “She isn’t here. Thank god. She isn’t here.” He heard the footsteps behind him, but didn’t look back to see who it was, only assumed and continued talking out across the lagoon. “But she could still be here. On this island, I mean. You are. And if she disappeared… She could be somewhere out there too. Right? Don’t you think?” What was the alternative to holding onto this weak hope? She was dead. And if she was dead, he was just as good as dead himself. He could live in solitude on an island knowing his literal other half was out there alive somewhere. But if she wasn’t, there would be no point. He so desperately wanted there to be a point. So he would believe this, no matter what. For no other reason than the fact that it was something to hold onto. “She has to be here.”
James saw it. The blankness in Lark’s eyes like he was looking at something far away. Despite his gaze being focused on the rocks and pebbles at their feet. This was the last thing he wanted. To have Lark in a state over something neither of them had any control over. Well. Lark had no control over Katie leaving. James on the other hand always wondered what he could have done different. Asked Katie to move in with him and Lillian for a while or have someone watch her-- as if either of those things would be the sort of stuff Katie would ever agree to or approve of. James knew that there was nothing he could have done to prevent Katie’s disappearance.
“Lark,” James said hoping to pull his brother out of the trance he’d placed himself in. “Lark, please, I...” I don’t know what to do when you’re like this, as if James had ever known how to placate Lark. How to deal with his sensitive heart. Finally Lark spoke and James breathed a sigh of relief thinking he had snapped out of it. To the point he didn’t hear his first phrase. Only when he raised his voice and used that old childhood nickname did James realize his brother was still in a sort of delusion. “Lark,” he said in a warning tone. His brother started sprinting for the jungle. “LARK” He shouted before chasing after him.
Damn his long legs, James thought before shouting again, “Lark!” How deep into the brush he followed James wasn’t sure. In some ways it didn’t matter. He’d lost his brother and his sister-- powerless to stop either. He wasn’t just going to stand there and lose his brother again. Finally he caught up with him, finding him collapsed on the ground. James for his part doubled over with his hands on his knees as he caught is breath, the musky air sticking in his throat.
She’s not here... No shit, James wanted to rebuttal but this wasn’t the time. Straightening his back he finally got a good look of where they were. A lagoon, an inviting shade of turquoise, glowed in front of them. It was so mesmerizing James didn’t notice what surrounded them. Trees, dozens of them, with detailed faces in pain like they were burning in hell. What James hated most was how detailed the faces were. None of them he recognized but he suspected if there were a face he knew embedded in the trees he would recognize it.
“What the fuck,” he said still a touch breathless. James shut his eyes tight, trying to forget the forrest of faces. He marched forward and got on his knees, placing both hands on Lark’s shoulders. “Lark. If she was here... I know misery loves company, but this place...” His eyes wandered away from his brother before James shut his eyes tight again, shaking his head. “I have you, Lark. I’m grateful for that. I know... I know Katie is better. I know you two had something between you I can never fully understand. But fuck I want Katie to be alive somewhere. To be living a happy life away from our God damn name. I won’t pretend to know what this place is but--” he gestured to the trees around them, “this isn’t where I would want Katie to be. Not now. Not for two long years alone. Not ever.”
James squeezed Larks’s shoulders. “And I can’t lose you again. Please, please don’t run...”