Something that’s crazy to me, watching supernatural for the first time with a fully developed frontal lobe (this is hyperbole: there is no scientific evidence that the frontal lobe ever fully develops, we are ever changing) is just HOW gay it is. The first time I watched it, I was like 12-15, and dealing with a lot of internalized homophobia (woo!). Destiel fanfic was actually the first queer content that I ever engaged with. I had this weird justification in my head where I loved them together in fanon, but I told myself I couldn’t see the chemistry between them in the actual show. I had this sort of image of Dean as this incredibly heterosexual, bad ass man who would never actually be interested in men, so when I saw bi jokes/canon evidence that he was bi, I was always like…yeah, whatever.
Okay. Wellp. So, I went into this rewatch with the mindset that I wouldn’t be biased (lol, bi), and, dude. He’s The Bisexual™️. Younger me was such a fool. I know that the coding likely comes from a place of the writers being like ‘lol, gay funny’, but it gets to a point.
I was watching with a friend when we got to the siren episode (of note: I don’t remember 90 percent of the plot lines of the show: it has been many moons since my first watch. I’m pushing thirty). As soon as the premise of the episode was set, I turned to my friend and I said ‘…calling it now: the siren is going to appear to Dean as a man’ and they laughed at me. And then…Jesus, dude. I understand that they were going for a ‘Sam is the most important person in Dean’s life, and shit is rocky, hence: new brother’ but…they WENT ON A DATE.
Also, also. Castiel and Dean’s dynamic in season four is clearly meant to parallel Ruby and Sam. Their relationship (super straight, definitely just dudes being bros) is the direct foil of Sam and Ruby’s definitely more than platonic…thing. Ruby corrupts Sam while Castiel guides Dean while Dean ‘corrupts’ (frees) Castiel.
‘My superiors are doubting me because of my feelings for you’ (indirect quote, I can’t be bothered to look up the exact line). ARE YOU KIDDING ME? Isn’t being doubted and shoved out by your family because of your feelings for someone the most DIRECT QUEER METAPHOR in history? Jesus h. Christ, bro.
Rewatched Free to Be You and Me last night, and realized upon watching it that it was 1.) likely my most rewatched episode as a teen, so that was a treat, 2.) so gay, dude. Wtf. (I was really watching the ‘Cas and Dean go on a date’ episode over and over again and telling myself I only liked it because Cas is funny)
Yet again, the episode parallels Sam’s romantic life with Dean and Cas pal-ing around. It directly cuts from Sam on a dinner date with Diner Girl to Cas and Dean at a candle-lit dinner in a brothel (lol).
‘I haven’t laughed like that…in years…” he says, gritty and platonic, eyes shining with tears of bromance.
Anyway. All of this to say: watching as an adult, it’s honestly crazier to me, from a writing standpoint, that it’s NOT meant to be romantic. I don’t understand how they were writing this shit and thinking that it was straight. Also…I’m in a pit of despair and can’t stop reading Destiel fanfic. Wasn’t expecting to be back here at 27. Teen me would be. Likely disappointed, actually.
















