Nabiha Syed
Assistant General Counsel
New York, NY
âSo there is a video in the 7th circuit, Illinois, about, uh, involving⌠footage of a cell. In this cell there is only supposed to be one person. But for whatever reasonâ prison overcrowdingâ they put three people in that cell. Two of them were brothers that were in there for violent assault, and they were left unsupervised⌠and they managed to EAT the other person. Rip him limb to limb, and eat his organs.
And somehow no one saw what was going on. It was prison! Imagine, you have no instruments, you have no nothing, you have no knives. How are you going to eat a person?
That doesnât happen in one second. That is a long process, and in this whole process no one realized that a. dude. is. being. eaten.
So the family of the dudeâ of the eaten party, is suing, saying âHey Department of Corrections, what the hell happened?â
And Prison Legal News is covering this to say âWe want to understand. Did a guard ever walk by?â Because the footage would show if a guard walked by, if they ignored it, if the guy called out for help. But the DOC wanted to do all of this in private. They wanted no coverage, no nothing. The public wouldnât know.
So we filed a suit to try to get them the footage.Â
We lost. We didnât win. The court said that the footage was so terrible that it couldnât be disclosed, and I understand that, but it was a good fight. And Prison Legal News got to make its case to the court, and be in the court reports of what was going on, get access to some of the documents, so they could get a description of the video if not the whole video. Um, but that was one where you sort of realize⌠the stakes of whatâs going on, and also the importance of media as watch-dog. Because the public should know.
It was such an interesting case, even though we lost, and that happens, you know? When you fight the good fight you lose sometimes.â
Interviewed and photographed by Sabrina Majeed.