This is probably a hot take, but I don’t think Shane grew up being bullied in school or he was completely friendless. Sure he didn’t have a bestfriend untill he met Hayden, but I don’t agree with this famous fanon that Shane was completely alone as a child and only had his parents as his friends (the one where he only played video games with his parents or that he no one attended his birthday parties).
Shane has been playing hockey since he was a child, and has always been good at it, no way he wasn’t popular among his peers and didn’t have other boys trying to befriend him.
But also this doesn’t mean Shane wasn’t lonely. There is a huge difference between being alone and being lonely.
Oh yeah definitely? I've always found the idea of bullied!Shane a bit odd.
It might be considered a hot take but I've always had the opinion Shane had a perfectly happy childhood with a normal amount of friends and no serious issues. Especially if we're not going to be hyper realistic about how bad juniors hockey can be (which is quite bad. but HR is a glossy romance world, so I'm okay softening this).
It's realistic that child/teen Shane got picked on a few times for his race. He would have been othered due to his sheer talent. He also probably had a sense of unease around his sexuality even though he wasn't self aware about being attracted to men until the night of the draft.
But overall....Shane is the golden boy. By 16 he's the most talented hockey prospect in Canada. He's captaining the Canadian national juniors team and leading them to victory. He probably had groupies in high school. We know he had a girlfriend and she was probably the prettiest girl in Kingston. Beyond that, he grew up in a stable and loving home with two parents who genuinely loved him and were not interested in stealing his future income or micromanaging his career. His life was and is objectively pretty good.
As for the loneliness...I actually don't think child Shane was all that lonely. Maybe some only child loneliness but I kind of think Shane liked being the center of his parents' world. And I think he liked being the standout junior talent.
My take is actually that Shane's loneliness doesn't set in until he accomplishes all his childhood dreams and moves to Montreal. My reasoning for this is that he seems somewhat surprised by it in HR:
I think Shane's life up until that point had been so dominated by the goal of making it to the NHL and getting drafted that he really didn't have time to be lonely. And Shane would have been in that shit with all the other kids, even though he was obviously a stand out talent, there's still this bonding experience of you're all striving for the same thing. And you can kind of pretend you're all on the same ship.
And then Shane goes 2OA, he's moving up to Montreal alone, he's probably going to be captain within a few years, suddenly his teammates have like---wives and kids and lives? Adult lives? And Shane's standing there fresh off his first gay experience with the guy who took 1OA from him fully aware no one on the planet but that guy would understand any of this.