alright, now that the heat of the moment has passed, let's take this apart point by point. complaints and spoilers below the cut.
rushed. the word for this season is rushed.
as with volumes one and two there were parts i did enjoy, but with such a bloated cast, players i would have considered vitally important took a backseat while fun side characters had more time to shine. this may have been solved with a ten episode season with the finale clocking in as the eleventh episode. why did they not think of that? genuinely, why? eleven???? missed opportunity imo.
where did vickie go? that poor girl.
what was that shockingly racist bid at making kali seem like the spy? why was she the ONLY one to "die"? i put "die" in quotes but every clue points to her last act being getting eleven out of the town. to say that "i'm so done" with characters of color being props for the white heroes and dying in the process does not cut it. that made me rage. fuck that. i'm not keeping that.
another issue that irks me is the bandaid feel of this finale. again with the strange time cuts that leave a great deal too much out. INCLUDING footage that was seen in previews and trailers that was MISSING. i do not love the bait and switch feel of that. this kind of "gotcha! not as sad and sadistic as you were expecting us to be" rug pull gives the same impression as the tragedy of game of thrones s8 with their "gotcha! we saw all your theories and wrote a final season that wasn't any of those theories just to hoodwink you!"
now, onto the quick-fix of queerness. i'm here, i'm queer, and while i am not personally victimized by this finale's ending for will, that doesn't mean others won't be. as good as it is to see him happy, what an uncomfortable message to young queer people finding themselves that they must leave their hometown to find true freedom. as if away from home, they can best be their true selves. huh??? i also have beef with the implication that declaring identity to the biggest accepting crowd you can manage is the best kind of validation in a pinch. what i DID like was showing will's friends devotedly showing their affection for him, no matter his font. the rest....i surrender to the people who are more emotionally connected to it.
max. i love max. much as i love her, i can't jive with that bandaid ending. she deserves happiness and a successful life telling roadblocks to fuck off, but my max blog will absolutely not be going by the "omg everything is fineeeee" after her laundry list of traumatic injuries. the finer points of my rewrites will actually be on my max blog, but her vision and her legs suddenly working 2 smth years after what we witnessed her survive in s4???? being disabled is not a CURSE. when will this get through to writers in in the industry?????
thank you dustin, for giving principle higgins that middle finger. we all did it with you. and what an excellent young man dustin showed himself to be this season despite his inner war. much deserved. dustin and lucas and max have my entire heart and i adore those three so very much. (dustin's mom hyping him up WAS MY FAVORITE)
the grown up kids. yeah, i get the vibe, sorta. nancy not finishing school was not in my cards though. i just.....i just don't think she'd waste the opportunity that higher education provides to absolutely kill a journalism degree even if she didn't want to be a bigwig news staffer. if anything, i could see her taking a gap year to do pro bono work alongside paying jobs to make sure she knows what she wants. steve, lol.....i do like what he's ended up doing. the love of hawkins is a little hammy but he's a good man to stick around and give kids a male figure to look up to who will accept them. the sex ed teacher thing is ALSO hammy, but then again idk, steve isn't gonna judge those fetuses for wanting to explore. he'll just teach them how to be responsible. jonathan, you go queen, make that anti-capitalist slasher film. robin, please go collect your girlfriend. i love you so much robin, it was so good to see you smile and feel comfortable and safe with your friends but lol please.
what we saw of vecna's past was obtuse enough to be entertaining but not detailed enough to be reasonable. i don't need every detail handed to me like i'm a baby learning to eat but it felt like they threw shit at the wall to give us a spark of "huh, so that's why he's like that." they did successfully toe the line of him having a sympathetic side but an inexcusable mindset that would render him unable to change. that i am glad for.
i did go full rave mode when joyce decapitated vecna, and holly was a warrior this season. she really won my heart.
a barb and chrissy flashback moment. neat! they deserved that at least, my precious redhead girls who deserved better.
personally, i am not not invested in either mileven or byler enough to have a favorite, but i will not lie: i expected a byler ending. i did. and i'm sad we didn't get it. even if it wasn't straight up "THEY'RE DATING NOW" but more along the lines of "mike has accepted that he may be closeted and will has fully accepted himself and is an inspiration to mike in his identity and oh would you look at that, maybe you and i should try this relationship thing." they don't even have to last but gdi come on now.
finn's acting excelled in this finale, though. man was ripping my heart out every time he was on screen.
honestly, good for jane. go, my love, explore the world. i just wish your survival was not built upon the ashes of a woman of color forced to be the sacrificial hero. kali lives, bye. i do wish the girls who both lived tyvm stayed in touch with the hawkins residents who loved them. that seems like the least they could do. it's still possible to let someone go without keeping them contained.
har har montauk easter egg
right after the finale finished, i loved the experience of watching it. now that my fog has cleared i feel much more sure of my critiques. the duffbros tried, and they failed in ways i thought were avoidable. their biggest success here was giving us media to swipe from them and play a game of better barbies that they did not have the balls to think up.
my greatest joy will be watching what we come up with from this point forward. i'll keep that close to my heart instead.