EVAN

CREEPYPASTA MANSION BUT FOR NOSLEEP

No no hear me out on this

The whatever place they live in would be the gas station (tales from the gas station) since they're already enough supernatural shit there you could have them live there in one of the underground stations

Jeff the killer would be replaced with David king from "i dared my best friend to ruin my life" they're both edgy as fuck serial killers and david has better monologues

Since lots of people tend to use liu as another killer you could have zander duo with David as killers and use the gas station to kill people

The eyeless jack of this team could be the creature from stolen tounges both are similar overall in my opinion

Laughing jack of this team would be ickbar (or however you spell his name the sock puppet that needs teeth to keep the main character alive) could lure people into the gas station

If we need an animal we have that one skinwalker dog from "my dog was lost for three days what came back wasn't my dog" i imagine it stumbled into the gas station and is davids dog (similar to how people turns to have jeff and smile dog being a duo)

For the video game creepypasta you could have uhh idk any nosleep game creepypastas i think i remember one with pokemon but not sure

The slenderman for this one would be the angel from "I'm questioning my atheism after a visit to Montana" i know this isn't the best comparison but i do like this one just kinda appears sometimes and everyone listens to it for some reason

Maybe for slender you could have like alice from left right game after she became god like maybe have both the angel and alice like a good vs evil thing who both control the killers

For ticci Toby you could have Kyle from borrasca now I know this sucks as a comparison but BUT he could be like forced to work with the killers to save kimber also he'd also kill people maybe he was driven insane (he still blasts music don't worry)

For zalgo you could have the demon from deepwoods like he steals souls and controls everyone and alice fights him daily or something

I still imagine jack working there just chilling because he doesn't give a fuck anymore

The mountain borrasca is up there somewhere and Kyle wants to desperately reach it

The stalker from penpal is somewhere there in the forest and David has almost killed his ass but his boyfriend (zander) stopped him

Idk what else i could use but if you want to suggest something then go ahead

these guys are cool