First You Say You Love Me, and Then You Say You Don't
I know who it is when my text alert sounds, I know its her, and I know I should ignore it because nothing good will come from this exchange. Nothing good ever happens after 2 am. I just wish she wasnât who she was, because if it was any other girl I would be strong enough to say no, Iâd be strong enough to ignore the phone. But this time, like all the other times before, I wont ignore it, Iâll answer it and Iâll go wherever she is and Iâll be whatever she needs me to be in this moment.
âI miss youâ it reads, I roll my eyes, she has said this before, and sheâll say it again and Iâll fall for it every time.
âDo you miss us?â So she hasnât been drinking, its legible, sheâs either up too late and thinking or, sheâs up too late and sheâs not thinking.
âIâm sorry âbout last time; you know I love you, answer meâ three in a row, sheâs getting persistent. Sometimes I like to see how many sheâll send before I respond, because this will be the only time tonight when I will hold any of the power in this relationship. Five more minutes and no new message, so Iâll need to respond soon or I might lose this moment.
âCourse I doâ its all I can muster; I wish someone would take her phone away; in the end sheâll be the death of me, and I wont survive her.
âI knew you did.â Did you see that? All of the power I had is now gone, sheâll have it all now. âHave you been thinking about me?â All the time, constantly, I wake up thinking about you and spend most of the night lying in my bed, and looking at the ceiling wishing you would make up your mind. I canât respond with that though, because she canât handle that much truth, she can only handle the childish back and forth.
âYes, Rae, Iâve been thinking about youâ too many words, Iâm saying too many words.
âCome overâ I shake my head no, I will not do this again, she is going to destroy me. I run my hands through my hair, I am showered and ready for bed, not ready for a 20-minute car ride to hers.
âYou think thatâs a good idea?â I ask tentatively, most of me wants her to say no, itâs a horrible idea, but I want you to anyway. But then thereâs that voice in my head saying, you know this is a terrible idea and that youâll be worse after this is over.
âItâs an excellent idea, see you in 20â and sheâs right, she will see me in 20 because Iâm the fool, and sheâs got me on a string. Deep down I know this should be the last time I come over. Sheâll say she misses me that she loves me and then in the morning, in the morning sheâll be different. I wont be though, Iâll still be the same stupid Finn making these same stupid decisions, maybe Iâll be a little different Iâll be a little more broken.
After spending 30 seconds pretending like I wasnât going to go, I found myself in my car driving straight to her. After sitting in the car, looking at the light on in her bedroom window I found myself heading up the walk and knocking on the door without hesitation. Iâll save the hesitation for another time, cause right now sheâs gonna open this door, pull me in by my jacket and kiss me as hard as she can and all Iâm going to taste for the rest of this night is whatever cheap wine sheâs got, her mouth, and her body.
âIâm so happy you cameâ she smiles and it breaks me even more.
âCourse I didâ by the time the door has shut behind us, and sheâs flipped the lock I know Iâm in trouble. This nightâs gonna be different, because sheâs made popcorn and sheâs readied a movie and spending quality time with her not just the tiny pieces of herself sheâs only ever given me, never all of her, Iâm not going to make it out of this night with the rest of my heart.
âI thought weâd watch some TV, yeah?â Iâd agree to anything, any amount of time she let me spend just being around her. I shake my head in agreement and we settle in on the sofa. Sheâs in my head, and I donât know if this is a new trick or if sheâs changed, and sheâs going to give me more of her.
Wait ten minutes Nelson, youâll find out.
âYouâre so far away from me,â she says tucking one hand under my arm drawing me in closer to her perfection. I let her consume my space and I am flooded with how she smells and my stomach wont stop doing somersaults waiting for what will come next. Sheâs gonna leave me such a mess.
If this wasnât my fault, if I hadnât broken her first, maybe it wouldnât be like this, and maybe one day sheâll trust me with more of her. Until then Iâm gonna take what she offers me.
Warm kisses trace my jawline, and I can feel her hands all over me, and I canât breathe, and Iâm so happy in this moment because I am in love with her, and she; she only gives me pieces of her love now.
âDid you miss me?â She asks again, and I canât answer her, so Iâll show her this time how much. She tells me she loves how I make her feel, and that no one knows her body like I do, and how to make her feel good. But I want to make her feel good all the time and she only wants me to make her feel good when she calls me at 2 am.
After sheâs gotten what it is she needed from me tonight weâll fall asleep in her bed, this she always gives me. Sheâll afford me the luxury of sleeping next to her, and waking up surrounded by that mess of dark hair on my shoulder. But after weâve had coffee and sheâs awake enough to realize that Iâm still here and she has to say those same words to me again, the air gets thicker, and I can feel it change when that happens.
âYou donât have to say it again this timeâ Iâll save her a few words this time.
âI knowâ she half smiles, and wraps herself up tighter in that ratty bathrobe âbut Iâm still sorry.â And itâll sting just as hard every time she says it, and Iâm going to keep coming back when she calls every time because I know one day sheâs going to wake up and not feel like she made a mistake with me.
âI do love youâ she huffs âand I know you want it all, but Iâm not ready for that.â
âI know,â itâs my turn to half smile with my reply âI love you too.â Itâll be all I can do to get out of this place without breaking down in front of her. âLet me just get dressed and Iâll get out of your hair.â Her pretty little head tilts and she looks at me like Iâve said the most offensive sentence sheâs ever heard.
âI didnât ask you to leave,â and Iâve never been told this in the morning. Sheâs always hurried me out; sheâs never ready to let me be there with her in a way that wasnât in the bedroom, not since I let her down. âIâm not asking you to leave, Iâm actually asking you to stay. I cant promise that Iâll be better this time, that I wont push you away again but I feel better about this now and Iâm always going to love you so I either need to forget about you or give you another chance because this back and fourth is exhausting for both of us and frankly Iâm shocked youâve put up with it for this long.â
âYouâd be surprised what Iâd put up with when it comes to youâ I smiled and kissed her lightly on the lips.
So maybe it wasnât perfect, but the air didnât feel thicker, it felt electric and full of hope; or maybe that was just me. Either way I wasnât going to risk it by asking questions.
not enough people have read this lovely little story
This was hiding in my drafts ⌠but itâs still a gem. One of those fics Iâm not strong enough to write but love to read. And just a smidge of delicious hope at the end.Â
Iâm scrolling, and I just saw the title of this. Iâm like âawesome I wrote something with a title like thisâ because I did not realize it was mine lol. Then I got to experience the joy of having someone reblog something of mine from so long ago, so you guys are peaches.Â











