TADC FINALE SPOILER!!!
Ngl, it might just be me, but while I absolutely love and relate to Jax, Goose absolutely fumbled writing a good trans character even with Jax being based off her own personal experiences, it was so subtle people assumed and theorized Jax was everything but trans, including being an actual real life murderer
Both me and a friend are irl closeted transfems and by the end of watching the full show, theorizing, and watching theory videos on it, we ended up having absolutely no clue that she was also trans, and we were both shocked after seeing all of the wikis update her gender and seeing Goose confirm that Jax is a transfem
She have a pretty horrendous relationship with Zooble, the only other queer/trans character
She seem to feel no gender dysphoria whatsoever, which while not a requirement and not everyone feels, that would've been something that would've made this less subtle
She seem to have problems that are far worse than being closeted, having self-worth issues so bad she killed her closest friend, on top of the trauma of having killed her closest friend. All of this wayyyy overshadows her being trans. When a character is severely struggling from mental health, thinking about if a character is trans is about the last thing you think about as a viewer, and is almost offensive. My full focus was on her issues of self-worth and self-importance by the ending, thinking "Her mental health problems come from being trans and she killed her friend Ribbit because she was afraid of Ribbit finding out" feels very phobic as of itself
One of the popular theories I saw was that Jax committed a hit and run having killed a little girl due to everything shown in Episode 7 back when people were piecing things together, yikes
Not to mention, for most of the show she is the biggest villain outside Caine, and unlike Caine, she never even gets the chance to apologise for anything or explain herself on-screen. I don't like that the evil character with objectively the worst mental health problems, who never apologizes, is trans. Phobes already use "transness is a mental illness" as a defense for their ideologies too often.
The only hint we ever got was her being flustered dressing up in a maid outfit, which can easily be brushed off as a man valuing his masculinity far too much, and "Isn't she lovely" being part of the end scene lyrics, which at the time I thought was referring to Jax's opinion on Pomni due to how she was fully risking her life just to save her.
The show has kind of written Jax as someone with self-esteem, self-worth problems, and a guy seemingly struggling with his masculinity, more than a struggling closeted transfem. While I don't like when closeted trans characters are written as obviously trans, I feel like her case was way too subtle and overwhelming for the average person watching and theorizing on the show, let alone for someone who just casually watches it.
It's even more annoying because I did genuinely go through a time back when I was in school where I was the closeted transfem class clown that boymoded everywhere, I'm still kinda like that all the way now that I'm 20, and yet I still didn't catch this at all until after Jax died, until the actual show's creator brought it up
I still absolutely love Jax as a character, but dear god, it feels like Goose had no idea what Jax' struggles were during the animation process and just slapped a closeted transfem sticker on her right at the end















