The Christmas List By Maren Moore
Spice Rating:🌶️🌶️🌶️(2.75/5)
Tropes: Small Town, Second-Chance, Cowboy Romance, Single Dad
Publisher: Indie?(I can't tell, from research)
*Thank you so much to Valentines PR and the author for sending me a copy of this book for free in exchange for a honest review, it really means a lot that you trust little old me!*
It's a joke that is often said that people ruin their TBR's for holiday books and novella's and all I have to say to that is The Christmas List by Maren Moore is packed full of holiday vibes with plenty of cute, cozy moments to go around.
Josie and Wyatt are the couple that got away. Wyatt decided his future was more important and left Strawberry Hollow to play football at college, while Josie stayed. Now 10 years later, Wyatt is back to help run the ranch, just with a daughter in tow, who happens to be in Josie's kindergarten class this year. As the queen of Christmas herself, Josie can't deny Lucy, Wyatt's daughter when she askes her if she could be part of their team for the Christmas List competition, she can't say no.
The vibes this book has are perfect if your looking for a cute, quick Christmas book. It's got all the small town hallmark vibes you could want. The Christmas list is a cute idea just in general. I think it was a great plot device as well. Like, come on, how wouldn't want to dress up all Christmassy and complete Christmas themed tasks? Sign me up! The small town vibes are also hitting perfectly and are really well written.
I really love the characters in this book. Lucy is the cutest daughter ever. Josie also had a lot of character growth which I liked. Wyatt is a good MMC, and is a good dad overall.
The romance is okay. I needed more tension and angst personally, but it was still decent. It's a novella so I understand. The Smut is decent as well, so if your looking for that to help feed your holiday vibes, this might be the book for you.
I only have two minor-ish things that I would change. First, I feel like the book didn't have enough intro to it. It was immediately jump into the plot. Which, it's also a novella, so I understand, but it was a little hard to understand what was fully going on, until I got a couple of chapter in, which normally doesn't happen in romance novels. *Editing Fairy here, I realize that this isn't the first book in the series, it's book 3, so there is more to Strawberry Hollow if you want it! probably a reason why there is less world-building. That being said, I still think a recap of the first two books or more story build up would have been nice * Second, the pacing was kind of all over the place personally for my taste. But then again, it's also a novella so I understand. You have 200ish pages and a lot of plot, romance and storytelling to do, and not a lot of time to do it.
If your looking for a cute Christmas read, pick this one up!! It's short, not to long of a commitment, and the vibes are really great.