I canāt tell if this is meant to be positive or negative but Iām going to interpret it in good faith because I have a lot of thoughts and feelings about country music.
As I said in my tags, I love country music. For argumentās sake, weāre casting country as a very broad genre, including bluegrass and rockabilly and blue yodeling. Weāll leave folk music in a gray areaāpeople can get touchy if you call folk country or western but you canāt deny that country has a lot of roots in folk music, from instruments to themes. Hell, one of my recommendations in those tags, Knoxville Girl, is adapted from a 19th century Irish ballad adapted from an English ballad adapted from an Elizabethan ballad. Some folks consider zydeco to be country but Iād argue itās closer to jazz, but itās directly related to Cajun fiddle music which I do consider country, so. A lot of it is pedantry, really.
I get really frustrated by people who hate country music solely for being country, thereās a lot that can be criticized both musically and politically, but ācountry sucksā isnāt any of that. Toasty has a very justified criticism hereāa lot of country breakup songs by men, for the last 20 years or so, have been specifically bro-country. You know, all the songs about drinking and hot girls and having a good time? Most of those are bro-country, and pretty much all of them are country pop, so they get a lot of radio time. Some of them draw from hokum, and a lot of those are fun, because of the time honored tradition of innuendo and committing to the bit.
(For example, Iām Gonna Miss Her is a fun breakup song because itās got some hokum styling. The girlfriend presents an ultimatumāher, or fishing. If he goes out to fish, sheāll be gone by noon. The next verse begins āwell Iām gonna miss her / when I get homeā with a nice beat of comedic timing that lets us know he chose fishing. Itās playful and itās not demeaning, and itās not bro-country.)
Iām pretty sure youāve heard a bro-country song before, no matter how into country music you may be. A lot of those hyper-patriotic country songs are bro-country, too. A non-exhaustive list of bro-country youāve probably heard or at least heard of:
* Courtesy of the Red White and Blue
Maddie & Tae have the song āGirl in a Country Songā which is a direct criticism of how bro-country talks (sings) about women. āLike all weāre good for / is looking good for you and your friends / on the weekend, nothing moreā and āget up in the truck / keep our mouths shut / and ride along,ā and maybe most damningly, ābeing a girl in a country song / how in the world did it go so wrong,ā and the bridge mentions Conway Twitty and George Strait, saying they never treated a girl like this. Country didnāt used to be like this, and not all modern country is like this, but itās invading country pop so it gets a lot of radio time.
Some bro-country songs are fun, I can and will admit. I recognize Honkytonk Badonkadonk is objectifying and kind of forward, but itās no more so than Queenās Fat Bottomed Girls. Shaboozeyās āBar Songā is very much bro-country in theme and lyrics but musically itās closer to R&B than country pop, so it may be debatable. Good Time by Niko Moon makes you wanna have a good time. Arguably, Talladega Ten is a bro-country, but itās also a song about a woman knowing sheās hot and feeling it. Just because itās bro-country doesnāt necessarily mean itās bad, but thereās a lot of bro country that ranges from moderately annoying to kind of sickening.
It didnāt used to like this. Even most of the pro-military country wasnāt so⦠patriotic, weāll say. Private Malone is ostensibly about a military man, but itās more about a young man who died young whose memory lives on in the guy who bought his car 30 years later. Itās a story about grief and memory, for all that the only named character is a guy who fought in Vietnam. And thatās not to say that there isnāt highly patriotic and kind of objectifying country music thatās older than the 1990s, there absolutely is, but it wasnāt what defined the genre for people who didnāt really listen to it the way it does now.
Thereās a certain kind of man that perceives performing to be feminine, so they overcompensate with aggression and shallowness. Itās emasculating to be emotionally vulnerable. So thatās birthing a lot of those terrible and annoying country songs, especially those awful breakup songs. These guys have heroes in classic country artists but donāt seem to want to acknowledge that a lot of them are crooners who cared about the difference between the pop-influenced Nashville sound, the rock-influenced Bakersfield sound, the Neo-traditional Texas sound, and the folksy Tulsa sound. They wanna be country stars without the heart that ties country, roots, and blues together. A lot of folks like country because of the grit of itāgravel in the throat, beat up guitars and banjos, wearing out your fiddle stringsāand some people interpret that as very masculine and tough, but what makes all that grit, and makes it good, is passion and emotion.
Iām gonna get a little soppy here, so forgive me. Nothing makes me believe in love, or grief, or community, or myself, quite like country music. My heroes have always been cowboys and coal minerās daughters, farmers and union workers, truck drivers who tear through police barricades and talk all night to kids who miss their dad. In my heart, a good country song tells a story. You keep listening because you get invested in what happens next. The murder ballad is a hallmark, and theyāre so good, but thereās so many more stories. As a genre, country is full of love and humour and heartbreak, murder and moonshining, holding your hand out to neighbors and strangers alike when they need a little help. Itās about living slow because you have to grow with the seasons, and getting old too fast as you break your back for scrip and shoes on your kids feet. Itās standing and screaming about how you can never settle down, and the joy of front porch sitting to watch the day go by. Itās life on the road desperate to get home, just 20 more miles, and wanting desperately to get out and make your name far from your small town roots. It tells you that being an outlaw means something. That being a rebel without a cause can be lonely but being a rebel with one isnāt. That if youāre gonna stand for something you better stand with your chest out, shoulders back, and head high.
Iām not unaware that part of my fondness is nostalgia. I remember catching crawdads in the river mud. I learned to ride a tractor before I ever got in the front seat of a car. I had friends who raised chickens and goats. Iām, to an extent, the intended audience of the genre. I grew up on it. The right country song at the right time makes me feel like Iām 7 years old again, sitting in the car with my dad, not yet aware of my body or the world or what it feels lose someone.
Having said that, I think people donāt really give country a chance. Preconceived notions, memes, the country pop radio stations, classism, thereās a lot of reasons, but if all you hear is songs from whiny men who are trying to make themselves feel better, youāre not really experiencing the genre. Some folks have there exceptionsāāI hate all country except Dolly/Miranda Lambert/Shania Twain/Willie Nelsonāābut thatās still not really giving the genre a chance. Do you like rock and roll? Post punk? Midwest emo? Iāve got some country songs for you. Jazz? R&B? Soul? Iāve got some country songs for you. Musical theatre and theatrical pop? Oh boy do I have country songs for you. Rap? Iāve got some country songs for you, too, though some of them will be more talking blues. Reggae? Iāve got a whole subgenre for you that pulls from calypso and reggae, and while Jimmy Buffett may be the most well known artist heās certainly not the only one. If your thing is industrial or electronica or metal, Iām gonna have a harder time but Iāll try. The Afro-fusion scene in country is woefully thin, especially considering how much of it is rooted in music from enslaved Africans, but the Latin-fusion scene is pretty good, especially the blending on the Texas sound and Tejano music. Point me in a direction and Iāll do my best to find something for you. Iāve got some issues with country pop, which I think is obvious, but Iāll plumb those depths too if you want. If your thing is classical Iāve got maybe 2 fiddle heavy recommendations but Iāll look for more. You like tearjerkers? I got plenty. You want something silly? Iāve got it. You wanna party? Donāt worry.
Thereās so much country music out there, and just like any other genre, it runs the gamut in quality, theme, and popularity. Itās no better or worse than any other genre, I just happen to love it and have a lot of opinions, and most people have only heard a small range.