Okay so before anything idk if this is a popular opinion or not, I js finished watching vol2, but from what I've been reading, I feel like people are completely missing the point of the Jancy breakup scene because theyâre treating it like âoh this proves endgame/not endgameâ when⌠thatâs literally not what the scene is saying at all.
First of all, yes, it was a breakup scene. But what made it so beautiful (and honestly kinda rare to see written this way) is that itâs not framed as betrayal or cruelty or âI stopped caring.â Itâs framed as two people who do love each other, but whose connection was built in a very specific context: survival, trauma, dependency, fear. They were each otherâs anchor when everything was falling apart. That love is REAL. That bond is REAL. But it doesnât automatically mean âand therefore they should stay together forever no matter what.â
They basically say it out loud: theyâre two different people who, in addition, don't even fully know what they want yet. Outside of the constant chaos, they donât actually share that muchâinterests, what they want their future to look like, expectations, all of it. And when the only thing holding you together is need (and the fear of losing what you survived together), it turns into pressure. It turns into drowning each other. They start protecting the relationship with lies, because the truth feels like it might break it. Thatâs not romance, thatâs a slow panic.
And Iâm sorry but⌠would people genuinely prefer they stay in something that requires them to keep lying out of fear? Like, a marriage thatâs basically âwe made it through hell together so now we owe each other a life we donât actually wantâ? Thatâs not a win. Thatâs tragic.
However, once again, the scene isnât suggesting that their love was meaningless. Quite on the contrary, this love mattered enough to be honest about what it is and what it isnât. Sometimes the healthiest thing you can do is admit that love alone isnât a plan. It doesnât make the love less importantâit makes it more human.
And also: itâs not even written like some dramatic FINAL door slam?? Itâs literally two young adults who donât know what comes next, choosing honesty over clinging. They might find their way back to each other later in life. They might not. But if they do, it wonât be because theyâre trapped in the trauma version of themselvesâitâll be because they actually choose each other as whole people. And that would be real.
Anyway. I'm actually so impressed. Like, the little symbolisms and references... I already kind of expected that neither Jancy nor Stancy would be endgame but that was like so fucking beautiful, I genuinely cried.
annaxmalina
2087
gummygunk
theartofmadeline
origamiaround
discoholicmusic
dededos
dailybridgerton
