Tutoring
The porch light at 412 Elm Street had a moth problem. Roger noticed this because he'd been standing on the stoop for forty-five seconds, and in that time, two moths had orbited the bulb in tightening spirals while he'd rehearsed what he was going to say. Good evening, Professor Alderman, I'm here to pick up the draft you marked up. Whenever it's convenient. That was it. Seven months of work in a manila folder somewhere inside that house, and Roger was more worried about the greeting than the notes.
He knocked. Three times. Measured.
The door opened, and Alderman looked exactly as he always did — rumpled cardigan, reading glasses pushed up into thinning hair, the faint yellow tinge of a man who graded papers until two in the morning. He blinked at Roger as though he'd forgotten the appointment, then stepped aside with a wave.
"Roger. Yes. Come in. It's on my desk somewhere."
The house smelled like old books and coffee. Roger had been here once before, for a department mixer at the start of the year, and it had been full of faculty members holding wine glasses and making small talk about accreditation. Now it was just a house. Quiet. Lived in. The hallway was dim, and Roger followed the professor past framed degrees and a bookshelf stuffed with monographs whose spines Roger recognized from his own coursework.
"Have a seat in the living room. I'll just be a moment."
Alderman disappeared down the hallway toward his study. Roger heard a drawer open, close. Open again.
Roger sat on the edge of the couch. He put his hands on his knees. He looked around the room and tried not to snoop. A coffee table with a stack of journals. A lamp with a green glass shade. A woman's jacket draped over the arm of the leather armchair.
He stared at the jacket. Denim. Small. Not the professor's size, obviously. Not his wife's either — Alderman was divorced, and Roger was fairly certain the ex-wife lived in Vermont. The jacket had a small pin on the lapel. Roger leaned forward. A university pin. The kind they sold at the bookstore for three dollars.
He heard the kitchen door swing.
A young woman came through it holding a mug of tea with both hands. She was wearing an oversized university sweatshirt that came down to mid-thigh. Bare legs. No shoes. Her hair was blonde and messy, like she'd been lying down, and there was a crease on her left cheek from a pillow. She saw Roger and didn't flinch.
"Oh," she said. "Hi."
Roger stood up. "Hi. I'm — Roger. I'm here to see Professor Alderman."
"I know who you're here to see. I live here." She said it with a slight smile, like she was enjoying his confusion. She walked past him to the armchair, picked up the denim jacket, looked at it, and put it back down. Then she sat in the chair and tucked her legs under herself, curling up like a cat.
Roger's brain was doing arithmetic. Young woman. Professor's house. Bare legs. Pillow crease. Lives here.
"You're a student?" he asked.
"Second year. Abigail." She extended her hand. He shook it. Her grip was firm. "You're the grad student. The one writing about labor policy."
"That's — yeah. How did you —"
"He talks about your draft. Says it's the best one he's read in five years." She sipped her tea. "He's been agonizing over your methodology section for a week."
Roger felt a flush of pride and then immediately a flush of something else. He didn't know what to do with his hands.
Alderman's voice echoed from the hallway. "Roger, I'm sorry — I can't seem to find my annotations. Give me five more minutes. Make yourself comfortable."
"Take your time, Professor."
Abigail watched Roger with an expression that was hard to read. Not quite amusement. Not quite pity. Something in between. She was completely at ease in a way that made Roger feel like he was intruding in someone else's home, which he supposed he was.
"So you're in the professor's seminar?" Roger tried.
"Undergrad. I took his intro course last year." She paused. "We have an arrangement."
Roger waited for her to elaborate. She didn't. She just sipped her tea and looked at him over the rim with those clear, steady eyes. Up close, she had the kind of face that belonged on a movie poster from another decade — sharp jaw, full mouth, brows that could arch in a way that made you feel like you'd said something stupid even when you hadn't.
Alderman returned, holding a manila folder thick with pages. "Here we are. I apologize. I left it in the kitchen." He handed it to Roger. "My notes are in the margins. Some of them are legible."
"Thank you, Professor. I appreciate the time."
"Of course. It's a strong piece, Roger. We'll discuss it in office hours next week."
Roger nodded, tucked the folder under his arm, and turned to leave. Abigail gave him a small wave from the armchair. Two fingers. Still curled up. Still holding her tea.
"Nice to meet you, Roger," she said.
"You too, Abigail."
He walked to his car, sat behind the wheel, and didn't start the engine for a long time.
The next day was warm for October. Roger sat on a bench near the humanities building, eating a sandwich and flipping through Alderman's notes. The margins were dense, almost claustrophobic — red ink in the professor's cramped handwriting, questions and challenges and the occasional grudging checkmark. Roger was so absorbed that he didn't notice Abigail until she sat down next to him.
"Red ink. He likes you."
He looked up. She was a different person in daylight. Denim jacket over a white t-shirt, corduroys that flared at the bottom, brown boots. Her hair was down, and she'd done something with it — not styled, exactly, but arranged to look like she hadn't arranged it. Sunglasses pushed up on her head. She looked like she'd stepped out of a photograph from a decade she hadn't lived in. Bridget Fonda, if Roger were the kind of person who made references like that. Which he was.
"I didn't recognize you with clothes on," he said, and immediately wished he hadn't.
Abigail laughed. A real one. "That's the nicest thing anyone's said to me today." She looked at the folder in his lap. "How bad is it?"
"Actually, it's good. He's tough but fair."
"He's a softy. He just plays tough because he thinks that's what professors are supposed to do." She said it warmly. Roger couldn't tell if she was fond of Alderman or just describing him accurately. Maybe both.
A group of students walked past, and Abigail waved at one of them — a girl who waved back without stopping. Abigail seemed to know everyone, or at least to be known by everyone.
"Can I ask you something?" Roger said.
"You're going to ask about last night."
"I'm going to ask about last night."
"Go ahead."
"What's the arrangement?"
Abigail turned on the bench to face him. She crossed her legs. She looked at him the way she'd looked at him in the professor's living room — that expression between amusement and patience.
"I told you. We have an arrangement. He helps me out. Recommendations, connections, a foot in the door. I help him out."
"Help him out how?"
"You know how."
Roger set his sandwich down. "I don't, actually."
Abigail tilted her head. "Roger. You're a smart guy. You're writing the best thesis he's seen in five years. You walked into his house last night and found a twenty-year-old in a sweatshirt with bare legs and a pillow crease on her face. Use your imagination."
Roger used his imagination. His imagination was very clear about what it was depicting.
"It's tutoring," Abigail said. She let the word sit there for a second, then smiled. "That's what we call it. Tutoring."
"You're using that as a euphemism."
"I'm using it because it's funny. And because it's technically true in a different way. But yes. By tutoring, I mean fucking."
Roger exhaled. He hadn't realized he'd been holding his breath. A guy on a skateboard rattled past. Somewhere across the quad, someone was playing guitar badly.
"And that's — you're both —"
"Consenting adults. Yes. He's fifty-three. I'm twenty. Both of age. Both interested. Both getting something we want." She said it without defensiveness, without apology. Just facts. "He's not a creep, Roger. He's lonely, divorced, and a little bit vain. I'm pretty, young, and I know how to have a conversation about books. It's not complicated."
"It's a little complicated."
"It really isn't. People make it complicated because they have feelings about sex they can't sort out. I don't have that problem."
Roger looked at her. She looked back. There was no challenge in her expression. She was just waiting for him to catch up.
"How did it start?" he asked.
"His intro course. Fall of last year. I went to his office hours a lot. I was genuinely interested in the material. He noticed. We talked. One day the conversation went somewhere it wasn't supposed to go, and I let it. I didn't fight it. I didn't cry about it. I decided it was a good idea and I went with it."
"And it's been going on since then?"
"When he's in town and I'm in town and we both feel like it. It's not a schedule. It's not a contract. It's just a thing that happens that we both like."
Roger picked his sandwich back up and took a bite because he needed something to do with his mouth that wasn't asking questions. Abigail watched him chew.
"You're doing that thing," she said.
"What thing?"
"The thing where you're trying to figure out if you should be okay with this. You don't want to judge me, but you're not sure you don't want to judge me. And you're definitely not sure what it means that you spent last night thinking about me in that sweatshirt."
Roger stopped chewing. "I didn't —"
"You did. It's fine. I would have too." She uncrossed her legs and stretched them out in front of her. "I'm not offended by men thinking about me. That would be like being offended by weather."
Roger swallowed. "You're very direct."
"I don't see the point in not being. Life is short and most people spend it pretending they don't want what they want. I don't have time for that."
A silence settled between them. Not uncomfortable. Just the particular quiet of two people recalibrating. Roger noticed the way the sun caught her hair. He noticed the way she sat — straight-backed, easy, like she owned the bench and the quad and the university and the whole concept of sitting in public.
"So what do you want?" he asked.
"Right now?"
"Right now."
Abigail looked at him. She pulled her sunglasses down over her eyes and then pushed them back up. It was a gesture that seemed to buy her a half-second of privacy, a moment behind a shield.
"Right now," she said, "I want to know if you're as interesting in bed as you are in print."
Roger blinked.
"Your thesis. I read some of it. He left it on the kitchen counter. You write well. You think clearly. I like that." She paused. "I also want to know if you're going to make that face again."
"What face?"
"The face you're making right now."
Roger tried to rearrange his face. He couldn't tell what it was doing.
"Come on, Roger. I'm not asking you to marry me. I'm not asking you to understand everything about my life. I'm asking if you want to spend an evening together. My dorm or yours. Beer. Conversation. See what happens."
"You're propositioning me."
"I'm suggesting a possibility. You can say no. I won't be weird about it. I'll still wave at you on the quad. I'll still tell you your thesis is good. But I think you'll say yes, and I think you'll say yes because you're curious. Not just about me — about what it's like to be with someone who isn't pretending."
Roger's mouth was dry. "My dorm. Tonight. Seven."
Abigail stood up. She brushed off her corduroys. "Seven. I'll bring beer."
She walked away across the quad, and Roger watched her go. She didn't look back. She didn't need to.
She knocked at 7:03. He'd cleaned the room, which was absurd — it was a graduate dorm, a single room with a twin bed, a desk, a bookshelf, and a poster he'd been meaning to take down for months. He'd changed the sheets. He'd hidden the laundry. He'd moved the books around to look more casual, which made them look less casual.
Abigail walked in carrying a six-pack of Pabst and a bag of tortilla chips. She looked around the room the way she'd looked around the professor's living room — taking inventory, making herself comfortable.
"Smaller than Alderman's place," she said.
"Most places are."
She set the beer on the desk and sat on the edge of his bed. She kicked off her boots. She was wearing the same denim jacket, the same white t-shirt. She looked at the poster on his wall — a Klimt print, the one everyone had.
"Everyone has that poster," she said.
"I know."
"Why don't you take it down?"
"I keep meaning to."
She smiled. "You're very you, Roger. I mean that as a compliment."
He opened two beers and handed her one. She took it, drank, and looked up at him. He was standing. She was sitting on his bed. The geometry was simple, and they both understood it.
"Sit down," she said. "You're making me nervous standing there like you're about to present a paper."
He sat next to her. Their shoulders were close but not touching. She smelled like soap and something faintly herbal — not perfume, just clean.
"Can I ask you something?" she said.
"You've been asking me things all day."
"One more. Why did you say yes?"
Roger thought about it. "Because you asked."
"That's it?"
"That's most of it. And because you're interesting. And because I don't really understand you, and I want to."
Abigail set her beer down. She turned to face him on the bed, pulling one leg up underneath her. "You want to understand me."
"Isn't that why people spend time with each other?"
"Some people spend time with each other because they're lonely. Some because they're horny. Some because they're bored. Understanding is a better reason than most."
She reached over and put her hand on the side of his face. Her palm was warm. She turned his head toward her and kissed him.
It was a specific kind of kiss — not tentative, not aggressive. Deliberate. She kissed him like she'd already decided this was going to happen and now she was simply executing the first step. Her mouth opened against his, and her tongue found his, and Roger felt the last of his resistance dissolve into something that felt like relief.
She pulled back. "You're a good kisser."
"You're — yeah. You too."
She laughed and pulled her t-shirt over her head. Underneath, a plain cotton bra. No performance. No lingerie. Just a woman getting undressed because she wanted to. She reached behind her back and unclasped it, and her breasts fell free — small, pale, nipples already tight from the air or from anticipation. She didn't cover herself. She didn't pose. She just sat there, topless, and looked at him.
"Your turn," she said.
Roger pulled his shirt off. He was thin, not particularly muscular, the body of a man who sat at a desk most of the day. Abigail looked at him the way she looked at everything — with frank, appraising interest.
"Come here," she said.
He moved closer. She put her hands on his shoulders and pulled him down on top of her. They kissed again, and this time it was deeper, messier. Her hands ran down his back. His hands found her breasts — tentative at first, then more certain. She made a small sound when he brushed her nipples, a sound that told him he was doing something right.
She unbuttoned her corduroys and pushed them down along with her underwear — a single motion, efficient, no awkwardness. She kicked the pile off the bed. She was naked now, and Roger pulled back to look at her. Slim hips, a thatch of dark blonde hair between her legs, a small scar on her left knee. She watched him look at her without embarrassment.
"See something you like?"
"I see a lot I like."
"Then stop staring and take your pants off."
He did. His cock was hard, and it jutted out from his body with a slight upward curve. Abigail glanced down at it and then back up at his face. She reached out and wrapped her hand around it. Her grip was firm. She stroked him slowly, almost thoughtfully, like she was getting a sense of him.
"Nice," she said. "Not too big, not too small. The Goldilocks of dicks."
Roger laughed, and the laughing made him relax. She pushed him onto his back and straddled him. She rubbed her pussy along the length of his cock — she was wet, slick, and the friction made him groan. She did it again, slower, letting the head of his cock catch against her clit. Her eyes were half-closed. Her mouth was open.
She reached between them and positioned him at her entrance. Then she sank down, taking him inside her in one smooth motion. They both exhaled.
"Fuck," Roger said.
"Yeah," she said. "That's the idea."
She started to move. Not fast — a slow, grinding rhythm that pressed her clit against his pubic bone with each stroke. She put her hands on his chest for leverage. Her breasts swayed with the motion. Roger held her hips and tried to match her pace, but she was running this. She set the tempo. She decided the depth. She was in control, and she was comfortable there.
"You feel good," she said. "Inside me. Right there."
Roger thrust up into her, and she gasped. Her rhythm faltered for a second, then she found it again. She leaned forward and kissed him. Her tongue moved in his mouth in the same rhythm as her hips.
"Roll me over," she whispered.
He did. He flipped her onto her back, and she pulled her knees up, opening herself wider. He drove into her, and she wrapped her legs around his waist, locking him in. The sound of their bodies was loud in the small room — skin on skin, the wet slide of his cock in her cunt, the creak of the cheap dorm mattress.
"Harder," she said. "I'm not going to break."
He fucked her harder. He braced his arms on either side of her head and drove into her with long, deep strokes. She grabbed the back of his neck and pulled his forehead down to hers. Their eyes were close, breath mingling.
"There," she said. "Right there. Keep doing that."
He kept doing that. Her breathing got faster, shorter. She bit her lower lip. Her pussy clenched around him, and he felt the orgasm move through her — a series of rhythmic contractions that pulled at his cock like a fist. She moaned against his mouth, and the sound of it — raw, unperformed — pushed him over the edge. He pulled out and came on her stomach, spurting across her skin in thick white ropes. She looked down at it, then up at him, and smiled.
"Good," she said. "That was good."
They lay there for a minute. Roger's heart was hammering. Abigail reached for the beer on the desk and took a long drink. Then she handed it to him. He drank too.
She didn't rush to clean up. She lay on his bed with his cum on her belly and her hair fanned out on his pillow, and she looked at the ceiling like she was thinking about something interesting.
"You want to know something?" she said.
"Always."
"You probably think I'm a dumb girl."
"I don't think that."
"You did when you first saw me. At the professor's house. You saw a pretty girl in a sweatshirt and you thought, poor thing, or lucky thing, or naive thing. You didn't think smart thing."
Roger was quiet.
"It's okay. I'm used to it. I've been dealing with it since high school. Pretty girls aren't supposed to be smart. Smart girls aren't supposed to be pretty. And pretty, smart girls are supposed to be hiding something — some damage, some dysfunction, some daddy issue that explains why they are the way they are."
She sat up. She wiped her stomach with his t-shirt, which she'd pulled from the floor. She didn't seem embarrassed about it.
"I'm not hiding anything, Roger. I grew up in a normal house. Two parents. Middle class. No trauma, no darkness, no secret pain. I'm just smart. And I'm pretty. And I like sex. And I see no reason to pretend any of those things are contradictions."
Roger sat up next to her. "So the professor —"
"The professor is a man. Men are not complicated. They want three things: to be admired, to be desired, and to be left alone when they're tired. I admire his mind. I desire his company. I leave him alone when he needs to work. In exchange, he writes me letters, introduces me to people, makes sure I have opportunities I'd have to fight ten times harder for if I were doing it the conventional way."
"That's transactional."
"Everything's transactional, Roger. Your relationship with him is transactional. You produce good work. He gives you a degree and a career. The only difference between us is that my currency includes my body, and yours doesn't. Why is that a problem?"
"I didn't say it was a problem."
"You were going to."
"I was going to ask if it's a problem for you."
She looked at him. "No. It's not. Because I chose it. I wasn't recruited. I wasn't groomed. I wasn't desperate. I walked into his office one afternoon and I thought, this man is lonely and useful and I could make both of those things work for me. And I did. And he's happier. And I'm further along. And nobody got hurt."
Roger studied her face. She was telling the truth. He could see it in the steadiness of her gaze, the lack of performance in her voice. She wasn't defending herself. She was explaining herself. There was a difference, and it mattered.
"And me?" he asked. "What am I?"
She smiled. "You're interesting. You're smart. You write beautifully. You're also a little lost, which I find endearing. And you're good in bed, which I find useful."
"Useful."
"Don't look wounded. It's a compliment. I don't waste time with people who aren't useful to me in some way. Useful doesn't mean I don't like you. It means I like you and you serve a purpose. Everyone serves a purpose. The trick is knowing what yours is."
"And what's yours?"
Abigail stood up. She found her underwear on the floor and stepped into it. She pulled on her corduroys and fastened them. She picked up her bra and put it on, then the t-shirt. She sat on the edge of the bed to pull on her boots.
"My purpose," she said, "is to get what I want. That's everyone's purpose. Most people just won't admit it. They dress it up in language — love, duty, ambition, service. I just call it what it is."
"And what do you want?"
"Right now? A degree. A career. A life that doesn't depend on anyone else's generosity. Sex with men I find interesting. Books. Good conversation. Beer." She looked at him. "In that order."
Roger lay back on the bed. He watched her lace her boots. She was fully dressed now, the same woman who'd sat down next to him on the quad bench that afternoon. Nothing had changed, and everything had changed.
"Will I see you again?" he asked.
"Probably. I like you. You're a good fuck and you ask good questions. That's rare." She stood and picked up the remaining beers. "I'll leave these. Drink one before your next class. You look like you need it."
She leaned down and kissed him. A quick one. The kind of kiss that was a promise, not a goodbye.
"Roger."
"Yeah?"
"Stop trying to figure out if you should feel guilty about tonight. You shouldn't. I wanted it. You wanted it. We did it. That's the whole story."
She opened the door and stepped into the hallway. She paused.
"And stop trying to figure me out. You won't. Not because I'm complicated — I'm not. But because I don't fit into any of the boxes you have. And that bothers you more than anything I've done."
She walked out. Roger heard her footsteps fade down the hall. He lay on his bed and stared at the ceiling and thought about the way she'd said useful — not as a weapon, not as a confession, but as a simple description of how the world worked when you paid attention.
He thought about Abigail crossing the quad right now, alone, in her denim jacket, walking toward whatever came next. She had a meeting with the professor later. She had a paper due. She had a plan.
She was twenty years old, and she knew exactly what she was doing.
The story wasn't about Roger. It had never been about Roger. He'd just been the one telling it, and he hadn't realized until now that the main character had been someone else all along.













