please talk about the molested theory, I’m dying to know why you think so, I always felt that there’s something more horrific behind the vagueness
Just to preface I am a psychology student, I work as a mental health support worker and have worked heavily with people from CSA and abusive backgrounds and CSA is in my family so I’m pulling from a few areas when I say some alarm bells go off.
Liam - “I’ve been hurt by men”
Oasis Interviews Archive: Noel & Liam Gallagher - Unknown - 1997
I thought this quote was earlier than it was. In the early days they seemed to be more open.
HOWEVER this is around the time Noel started having psychosis from drug use. One other idea I had was that Noel started having flashbacks, one thing about trauma is that when your brain finally recognises that you are safe it can start releasing blocked memories. This tends to happen around 10-15 years after someone has gotten away from the threat and the brain accepts that.
Noel Gallagher admits he felt lonely during Oasis and experienced psychosis and a debilitating anxiety disorder due to drug addiction. - Carlisle Eden Mind
He writes Untitled and If We Shadows, he's sober for the first time since he was like 12, 10-15 years after they left his father. He for sure was remembering some really repressed shit
I found a quote from Liam in an interview with him and Patsy where he mentions having flashbacks in the evenings, more related to the physical abuse.
Hyper sexuality - Liam champaign supernova performance
https://youtu.be/PAtU-TSG4qc?si=1L-weZEFXzlpppop
He is so blank faced for a majority of the performance and then randomly starts doing these aggressive sexual gestures. Its spooky
He’s a little dissociated and odd in between the sexual mimicking, he’s like blank in this not kinda relaxed way, he’s angry for sure.
https://youtu.be/3P-GPutiA90?si=mHYtcr-f-gRpjKBB
He has a very similar vibe in this interview where he makes an odd joke about being a sex worker as a teen.
Liam - Paula Yates - Liam jumping out of the car to be with her.
Liam has access to a plethora of groupies but something about the Paula Yates story kind of creeps me out. A few people were sexually aggressive with Liam and she was one. It kind of sounds like she overwhelmed him and he almost forced himself to be with her. Then he gets so overwhelmed and out of control he jumps out a car window.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Nhkay8MC6P0 Minute 6:20 in
My little theory about what happened here is that Liam was testing some sexual boundaries. Robbie who has said he believes he is on the spectrum and has some overt sexualityin the media. Bites on it in the above way, this freaks Liam the fuck out who then called Noel (or Noel picked up on something here and took charge) in to get him out of it.
Noel - Alan Mcgee relationship
From Tony McCaroll’s book.
(that last bit is a normal joke to make under the circumstances but you know, why not include it)
Liam’s groping of Noel so aggressively, vs the playful ones
The lyrics to Take Me are fucked in the head.
The lyrics to Untitled could mean anything. BUT it could be his perspective of it all. It's vague and more subtle than hinting than Liam’s style of writing so I could make the argument.
Only for the young is the things we might not know
Only for the young is the things we won't remember
And long ago I said to myself that I feel inside I know
Only for the young is the things I don't remember
Sitting here, I'm waiting
A cause without a name
Sitting here, I'm waiting
And I will feel
And down I will kneel
You were the one I never know
Living in sin
Is somewhere within
You were the one I never know
And I remember
Life without a name
And I remember
My life without a name, woo
The woo is interesting; he's relieved the song is over, maybe?
I can’t find the bloody recording of it but it's out there on Tumblr. Noel and Matt on the podcast were making these jokes about fingering dogs.
This might sound like, and very well be, boy-joke style stuff. HOWEVER the reason it stayed with me is that I supported a woman who was a CSA surviour and one of the things she would often compulsively do is hyper fixate on her pets 'bums and fingering them. So when I heard Noel say this is the cadence and phrasing it reminded me of her.
Both brothers do it but you can see examples from Noel where it feels very much like a put on https://youtu.be/t56eLQ9fQL4
Here for instance, Liam is angry and trying to punish Patsy and Noel almost sounds uncomfortable. He’s saying the right Lad thing to think towards breast, but something is off. He doesn't like it, and you could argue that Noel has little opposite sex attraction because of this but I don’t think so.
Liam’s cheating, in general, was done so brazenly and with little regard for Patsy and Nicole. Coming home in women's sunglasses, for instance, that Patsy would then rip off and break, his disregard for her sounds borderline cruel.
In ethical terms, he was cruising for a bruising.
Noel however sounds more subdued and careful about his on-tour affairs, at least till Sara which most likely had an overlap. We know Meg was worried about this because of her ‘bag of tricks’ comment.
"I truly don't think Noel was ever unfaithful to me. No one's ever been unfaithful to me in fact. Not that I've ever known of, anyway. That's because I'm so good in bed. It's possible to be in a long-term relationship and be monogamous if you've got a bag of tricks up your sleeve for the bedroom."
----Meg Matthews in the guardian's column "What I know about men" Sun 12 Feb 2006
Liam also seems to use sex as a weapon against people. Like with Justine-Damon, Kate Moss -Lisa Moorish-Peter Doherty (Noel???) Situation’s.
Speaking of which, this interview with Liam talking about being better looking is weird. He seems anxious (could be because of the interview but I think it's odd his tone and what he says, maybe all to do with Lisa) Liam Gallagher & Alan White Interview - 1995 - Paris, France at around 8:10 in
https://youtu.be/2kmWPPGI70g?si=EozG1tnkfGG-5MxB Noel is the only one of the three, or four, if I include Peggy, who has ever said anything remotely neutral about Tommy. He is the one most conflicted about his feelings for him, as evident in numerous quotes and videos from Noel.
Liam’s tweets are a misnomer, it's all performance now. Not initially but for the first 5 years it was more genuine.
But this one freaked me out. I had like a visceral physical reaction to the first tweet before he must have felt better and turned it into a joke. I don’t know, could be a reach. He may have been joking; he may have been referring to the overall attention from the media that he's been pretty vocal about disliking.
https://www.tumblr.com/oacest/770045711791292417?source=share This could mean anything, I suppose. Liam was often left alone as a small child, and so when that happens, children learn to self-soothe through rocking and other calming motions. So, it could be stimming (we have strong evidence he has ADHD, or maybe is on the autistic spectrum), or it could be self-soothing behaviour, but the motion is odd.
Side note this quote from Paul Gallagher's book
Kinda sounds like the three of them created their own little family/parenting structure. I imagine Noel picked that up from Peggy
prguitarman
2087
titsay
areudirty
origamiaround
tangentwithtanner
ellievsbear
