Beatles Iceberg Points - No 8 - 'The Fifth Beatle'
The fifth Beatle is an informal title that has been given to a person who once had a very strong association with the Beatles as band members. This term originated in 1964 with the American disc jockey Murray the K, who pronounced himself as the âfifth Beatleâ due to the amount of promotion and coverage he afforded the band on his radio programme.
Above: Murray the K, who named himself âThe Fifth Beatleâ.
In a film made in 2024 titled Beatles â64, which was directed by David Tedeschi and produced by Martin Scorsese, George Harrison is seen questioning Murray the Kâs original proximity to the group.
An early group member named Stuart Sutcliffe was the original bassist of the five-member Beatles. Sutcliffe played with the band while they were still a club act in Hamburg, West Germany. When the band returned to Liverpool in 1961, Sutcliffe remained in Hamburg. Sadly, he died of a brain hemorrhage shortly after. Instead of being replaced with a new member, Paul McCartney changed from rhythm guitar to bass. The band continued as a four piece.
Above: Stuart Sutcliffe, former Beatles bassist
Pete Best, an early drummer of the Beatles, played with the band during their time as a club act in both Hamburg and Liverpool. Best was in the band alongside Sutcliffe, McCartney, Lennon and Harrison. BEst played with the band until mid-August 1962, when he was subsequently replaced by Ringo Starr. Best played with the Beatles in 1995 on Anthology 1, where he commented: âLots of people have laid claim to being the fifth Beatle. I was the fourth, and now Iâm getting the credit for it.â
Above: Pete Best, who drummed for the Beatles before Ringo Starr
Chas Newby also has had the title âthe fifth Beatleâ in the past. When the Beatles returned from West Germany for the first time in 1960, they were short of a bass guitarist. Pete Best suggested Chas Newby. Newby has been with a group named the âBlack Jacksâ (which was Bestâs group) and was enrolled with university at the time, but was on holiday so agreed to play with the band. He appeared with them for four engagements in December 1960 (17th Dec, 24th Dec, 27th Dec and 31st Dec). Lennon had asked Newby to go with the Beatles to West Germany for their second trip, but Newby chose to remain in university. Lennon and Harrison both declined the role of bass guitarist, so McCartney reluctantly took the spot.
Above: Chas Newby, who played with the Beatles 4 times.Â
Drummer Jimmie Nicol played alongside the Beatles for the first eight shows of The Beatles 1964 world tour. Ringo Starr had become ill and the opening part of the tour was nearly cancelled as a result. Instead of cancellation, the Beatles manager Brian Epstein hired Nicol to stand in while Starr recovered. Nicol had played with the band in early June, in Denmark, the Netherlands, Hong Kong and Australia. Nicol made the most of his time with the band, where he signed autographs and gave interviews. Starr rejoined the band in Melbourne on June 14th, 1964.
Above: Jimmie Nicol, who subbed in for Starr in 1964
The bandâs manager, Brian Epstein, was crucial for the Beatles rise to global stardom. He became their manager in 1961 until his death in 1967. He âdiscoveredâ the band in Liverpool, saw their insane potential, and stayed committed to them. He purposefully restricted his oversight of the band, limiting himself to business matters and public image, and gave the band free creative rein in their music. With great determination, Epstein sought a record contract for the band in London at a crucial moment in their career.
Epsteinâs sad death marked the beginning of the Beatles' dissolution, later admitted by Lennon. Due to Epstein not being creatively involved with the band, Epstein was only sometimes regarded as âthe fifth Beatleâ. Over the years he and producer George Martin have been recognised as having the greatest impact on the groupâs career.
When the Beatles were awarded their MBEâs in 1965, Harrison said that a fifth medal should have been given to Epstein, since âMBE really stands for âMr Brian Epsteinâ. If anyone was the fifth Beatle, it was Brian.â
Above: Brian Epstein, manager of The Beatles
George Martin produced nearly all the Beatles albums (except for âLet It Beâ, songs âFree As A Birdâ and âNow And Thenâ. He also wrote the instrumental score for the âYellow Submarineâ film and soundtrack album, and the string and horn (and even some vocal) arrangements for almost all of their songs. His arrangement of the string octet backing for âEleanor Rigbyâ was widely noted. He had extensive music training and sophisticated guidance in the studio.
Above: George Martin, who worked alongside the band.