The Chair in the Vestibule
One day, after coming home from work, a man noticed that something had changed about his house’s vestibule: there was a chair against one wall. It had a high back, carved wooden paws for feet, and a very fine red cushion. He didn’t, however, think much about it, and assumed that his wife had made the purchase. But he couldn’t question her because she was away visiting relatives. So he simply went about things normally, and had his dinner, and put his son to bed, and so on and so forth.
A few days later, his wife saw the chair for the first time when she was stepping out for an appointment. She thought that it looked hideous, and that was enough for her to chalk up its presence to her husband’s bad taste. However, since she was late for her appointment, she didn’t have the time to ask him about it, and further engagements and distractions finally made her forget about the issue. In the meantime, he had also forgotten about asking her.
They went on, therefore, living for a week under the mutual misunderstanding that they had each bought the chair without the other’s consent (not that it mattered, though, since the chair was just a chair). But eventually the question came up when they were both passing through the vestibule together on their way out to a restaurant.
“By the way, where ever did you get that thing?” she asked him, pointing to it.
“Me?” he said. “I thought that it was yours.”
After which they both looked at each other, and then looked at the chair. But it just stood there, as chairs will.
“Well, if it isn’t yours,” he said, “and if it isn’t mine, then whose is it?”
“I have no idea. When did it get here?”
“At least five days ago.”
“And you didn’t buy it?”
After which they both looked at each other again, even more confused than they had been, before her husband went over and tried—for the first time—to actually sit on the chair. But it ambled away, and disappeared after walking through a wall.
More questions were raised than were answered by this incident.
Both husband and wife, who were not, it must be said, very religious, became very religious in a few days. They had to be, when demonic influence was the likeliest theory they could imagine. They cautiously arranged an interview with a local clergyman, and fell all over each other in conversation as they tried to awkwardly explain their problem to him. They felt very stupid, and it was obvious that the clergyman thought so too. However, he agreed to report the haunting—if it could be called that—to his superiors. Maybe, he told them, a good old-fashioned exorcism could be arranged; but the church never did follow through.
Having failed in that arena, both husband and wife agreed that someone still ought to investigate the situation’s paranormal aspects, and they hired a medium. But if they had felt foolish talking to the clergyman, they felt even worse when this “expert,” dressed in black crape, rang their doorbell and proceeded to wander aimlessly through their house looking for “hot spots.” That, though, wasn’t even the most embarrassing part, since the medium reported sensing nothing whatsoever.
They might have then given up their inquiry into affairs if they didn’t, late at night, still find themselves sitting up, talking about what had happened. If only one or the other had seen it, they might have been able to convince themselves that it had been a hallucination, but since they had both seen it, they couldn’t deny the event. Something would have to be done, they decided, no matter how much it cost their dignity.
So they hired a carpenter, and they hired an architect. They had the carpenter dismantle and scrutinize every other piece of furniture that they possessed. The architect they tasked with going over, in detail, their entire house, and especially the wall through which the enigmatic chair had disappeared. This took weeks, and they were up to their eyeballs in sawdust and blueprints before the carpenter was able to declare, with more than total certainty, how outstandingly normal their furniture was, and before the architect could confirm that their walls were, indeed, normal walls, built in the standard way. But these findings, of course, were not what the couple had wanted to hear.
At their wits’ end, they contracted a feng shui master to rearrange their house and see if anything—they dropped hints heavy enough to outweigh bowling balls—might have been “wrong” with it before. What they wound up with, however, was no answer to their question, and a rock garden in their living room.
“C’est la vie,” the wife could only say about that one.
By now they had started to, if not doubt what they had seen, doubt their own sanity. After all, what proof did they actually have that they weren’t both unstable? They went, for an opinion about this, to a psychiatrist, where the only thing particular about them, they were told, was that they thought something was particular about them.
Pushed, at last, to the brink, and left unaided by every professional they had consulted, the husband went out and bought tools with which he could tear down the vestibule wall by himself. And although the wall, soon after, did come down, when he and his wife peered into the vacancy behind it, they discovered nothing relevant. The chair was nowhere to be seen, or even to be imagined. Then, during this scene, their son’s tutor walked into the room.
They naturally had some explaining to do, and by now had condensed their experience into an expertly polished anecdote, which they delivered in answer to the young man’s inevitable questions. When they found him sympathetic to their situation, though, they did more than deliver that anecdote.
“It’s maddening,” the husband said.
“You can’t know what we’ve been through,” said the wife.
“No one believes us.”
“And no one knows what’s happening.”
“There’s no other point, no other reference, in reality that touches what we’ve seen. We don’t even know what’s happening.”
After saying that, they both stared at him with anticipation.
But he only responded with, “I don’t quite know either.”
“If you had to make a guess, though,” pressed the husband. “From all the possibilities—the paranormal, the philosophical, the architectural, even the medical—what would you say? How could, why did, that chair disappear through that wall?”
“As to how,” the tutor said, “I don’t think I can answer.”
“Then as to why...?” the wife ventured.
“Well, that seems easy enough: it didn’t want to be sat on. Would you?”