āĀ Sirius's first thought was that this Hall was a complete heap of rubbish. When one of the mirrors started growling -- when the mirror reflected a facsimile of Remus's werewolf form back at him -- that feeling intensified.
And then the reflection started speaking, and Sirius's vague irritation turned to outright anger.
This wasn't true. It wasn'tĀ remotelyĀ true. The things this reflection was saying were so ridiculously outlandish and obviously intended to hurt Remus that Sirius was struck by the vague, inane desire to shatter the glass with his fist. He scowled.Ā
"This is stupid,"Ā he muttered.Ā "It's just a cheap trick. Come on, Moony, let's -- Remus."Ā
Sirius jolted a little when he noticed the look on Remus's face: a look of dull, practiced despair. Sirius's narrowed eyes widened a bit, softening at the corners. Oh.Ā
He really believes it. Everything this reflection is saying. Everything about himself, and...everything aboutĀ me.
Sirius seized Remus's upper arm and dragged him away from the mirror, his own pulse thudding uncomfortably as they went. He felt vaguely sick. Were these reflections accurate representations of one's inner thoughts? If that was the case, then Sirius had no idea what to say. He had always considered himself a good friend, always hoped he was doing his duty to Remus and the others.
Sirius made the mistake of pausing in front of a lone mirror, and, as though it really had been reading his thoughts, the reflection displayed was warped and distorted -- until they faced the bloodied, gaunt figure of a fifteen-year-old Severus Snape. Sirius growled.Ā
This really was a cheap trick, after all.Ā
Severus's reflection sneered as he said it. Sirius half-expected him to turn to Remus, the probably source of those phantom wounds, but was surprised when Snape's attention remained fixated on Sirius himself.Ā
<Ā I hope you enjoyed this little prank. Hope it was worth the price of an innocent life.Ā >Ā
At that, Sirius actually rolled his eyes, unmindful of the prickling dread that spiked the hairs on the back of his neck.Ā "Please, Snivellus. You left that shack without a scratch on you."Ā He yawned for effect.Ā "Besides; I wouldn't precisely call yours an 'innocent' life."Ā
Snape's eyes flickered briefly in Remus's direction, then back to Sirius.
<Ā I wasn't talking about me.Ā >Ā
Sirius suddenly felt as though he'd been doused in ice water.Ā
<Ā Imagine what would have happened to your precious freak of a friend, had they discovered my lifeless, bloody body in that shack? Imagine what the ministry would have done to a fifteen-year-old menace, the monster that was Dumbledore's best-kept secret? A lifetime in Azkaban wouldn't have sufficed, surely; for him, I think...a Dementor's Kiss.Ā >
<Ā And for you, Sirius Black, the perpetrator of all thisĀ tragedy...Well, it would be safe to assume you would get no such punishment. You, with your perfect marks and your handsome face and your pureblood lineage. You'd have gotten off scot free. You'd have lived the rest of your successful life in the shadow of your friend's loss. And the knowledge that it was all your fault.Ā >Ā
Sirius opened and closed his mouth a few times, unable to produce an adequate retort. He...he wanted to contradict Snape, to tell him to piss off, to insist his words weren't true. Not true, not true at all.
But that felt like a lie, because it was one. And, perhaps for the first time ever, he found himself with nothing to say.Ā ā