Heart Eyes | Benjamin Poindexter
Benjamin ‘Dex’ Poindexter x Reader
a/n: this is a shorter one, it just didn’t fit as a hcs so here we are! loved writing this it was so cute 😖 (also, kind of had fbi!dex in mind while writing this, but still, i could also see ddba!dex being like this lol).
cw: Dex being Dex, fluff, stereotypical movie moment, first kisses, both of you are inexperienced, awkwardness, in the beginning stages of their relationship.
~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~
after a lovely night out, Dex drove you home from your third date together, quietly enjoying the ride as the radio played some random station. his freehand was anxiously on your thigh, just resting, his face calm and focused on the road, while mentally he was petrified of doing something wrong, he wanted to play it safe so as to not scare you off. but he was so overwhelmed with what he felt for you, that he couldn’t keep the dam sealed, small cracks allowing it to leak through.
when pulling up by your apartment building, he turned down the music, glancing your way before getting out, walking around the car, and opened the door for you, shyly smiling as he lent you his hand, and helped you out of the car. you thanked him, standing there in the gentle breeze, both unsure of what to say in the moment, you felt the awkwardness clawing at your chest when you chose to break that silence and opened your mouth, “i had a great time tonight.. um” fidgeting with your hands as you glanced away quickly biting back your smile, “yeah—? me too” he breathed out in relief, looking down at his shoes, his heart fluttering behind his ribs, realizing he’s still holding your hand, he brushed his thumb over the back of it. feeling that quiet affection, you look back to him, your face burning under your skin. he looked so flustered despite his put together exterior, always trying to look right, it was nice on him, and something you’ve come to appreciate a lot after having only been around slobs of men all your life who thought it was ‘feminine’ to look after themselves. Dex wasn’t like that, not even close, his cleanliness made him even more attractive than he already was, and just the way he carried himself, all the while still letting himself be vulnerable around you, maybe without even knowing it. you liked him a lot.
stuck at thought, you hadn’t noticed him looking back at you, with that look you’ve gotten quite acquainted with, soft, almost raw, like he’s looking at something he’s dreamed of for decades, something he’s been searching for his entire lifetime. but that couldn’t be it, right? your hand slipped from his, riding up the side of his arm, as you stood up on your tippy toes, leaning in, making Dex think you were about to kiss his cheek, but, there was a slight hesitance in your eyes before you seemingly decided against it, just giving him a hug instead, your nerves having won the minor battle in your mind. he ducked his head down into your neck, breathing you in, his arms carefully wrapped around you, no words shared between you as you just stood there soaking in each other’s warmth for a while. feeling your pulse spike against his cheek just as you slowly pulled back, pulling yourself together taking a breath, you looked him in the eye “‘kay… hope you sleep well” you smiled before turning to leave.
he grabbed your hand, stopping you where you were, you looked at him with such a sweet gaze, brows knit in slight confusion, giving him a polite smile, you were perfect, all of you, and just like that, his dam crumbled.
he brought his hand to your face, gently caressing your cheek as he leaned in, his lips meeting yours, making your eyelashes flutter in surprise. his every action felt hesitant and shy, even as he wrapped his freehand around your waist, the realization hitting you right there and then, oh this is actually happening. your heart pounding in your throat as you anxiously leaned into it, and the tension in his body immediately relaxed, relieved that you hadn’t pushed him off, he deepened the kiss, a surprised whimper slipped off your tongue, making his heart skip a beat, it was the most precious thing he’s ever heard, and he wanted more.
his confidence grew and he tightened his arm around your waist, pulling you closer, carefully pushing his way into your mouth, luring out more of your soft mewls, tongues clumsily tangling together, the inexperience clear in the both of you but was overshadowed by the neediness.
he almost couldn’t believe he’s gotten this far with you, thinking you would’ve ran for the hills by date one, maybe seeing something off about him that he hadn’t noticed, but you didn’t, you leaned into him more and he felt how much you wanted him too.
your hands snaking their way up his neck, fingers tangling with the short hairs at the nape of his neck coaxing a satisfied groan from his lips, your feet sank back onto the ground, his head following yours, not letting the kiss dissolve, he slid his hand up from your waist, lightly tracing up your back, as his hands cupped your face, “you’re s’perfect” he mumbled into your lips, his tongue lapped against yours as you melted into him.
time disappeared from him the needier the kiss got, barely noticing as your fingers gripped at his jacket as the both of you got lightheaded by the lack of air, he pulled back panting lightly as his eyes focused on you, seeing your eyes glazed over, pupils blooming with awe, a clear heat radiating off your cheeks. so much love in your eyes; it made his hands tremble, “sweetheart” he breathed out, thumb grazing over your bottom lip.
you were too precious for his heart to handle, feeling it thundering against his rib cage as your pupils focused in on him, a quiet groan leaving your mouth as you shyly hid your face in his chest, almost making him laugh in disbelief, his heartbeat still aching in his chest, he ran his hand down your hair in a comforting manner, just holding you until that shyness burned away, lifting your head back up, looking at him as he caressed your face once more. “you’re everything i’ve ever dreamed of” his whisper sprouted into your heart, your eyes big in awe you pressed a kiss onto his pulsing wrist.