The Night and Its Moon by Piper C.J.
My rating: 1 of 5 stars
The Night and Its Moon is advertised as a sapphic love story about star-crossed lovers, destined to be together but doomed to be apart due to tragic circumstances. In actuality, it's a convoluted pile of purple word salad, racism, and misogyny. It's also 100% Witcher fanfiction. I'm aware this is Piper CJ's debut novel, written in February 2022, but it reads very similarly to A Chill in the Flame and A Frozen Pyre, which came out in November 2024 and August 2025. Piper has shown little to no improvement in her writing craft whatsoever. Her editor is either not doing their job or is very, very bad at their job. I'm not sure which. Not only has the writing itself not improved, but Piper has clearly not unpacked her own internalised racism and misogyny because this is just as bad as her most recent publications.
The Night and Its Moon focuses on Amaris and Nox and their respective journeys. They both grew up in a child mill masquerading as an orphanage. Despite the church making regular visits to this orphanage, they somehow haven't discovered that the matrons are selling these orphans to do child labour, be child brides, or to brothels. Or if they have, they don't give a fuck. Very few of these children get to find a family and have a happy story.
Nox is the only person of colour in this orphanage/mill, described as bronze-skinned and tanned, but in the character art, she is depicted as South Asian. She is the serving girl to the head matron and Amaris's unofficial guardian. Amaris is albino, with lavender eyes and has such pure, pristine skin that the matrons refuse to let her do 'hard labour' because they don't want to mar her skin. (more on that later.) Eventually, Amaris is sold into a brothel, and she and Nox make plans to run away together. Things don't go according to plan, they separate, and Nox ends up going to the brothel in Amaris' place, while Amaris convinces a Reever(aka a Witcher) to take her away.
From this point onward, there is a lot of time-jumping. Amaris trains at Uaimh Reev to become a Reever, but all she actually does is run up and down a mountain. We jump from when she first arrived, to when she started training, to 3-5 years later, when she's 18 and ready to take her vows. Nox, meanwhile, has been living her life as a sex slave. I'm going to touch more on Nox and her arc a bit further down because I have a lot to say.
In actuality, there isn't much plot. After Amaris finishes training, she goes on her first dispatch, meets some faeries, and learns they're cursed, and then goes to try and talk to the queen, only to realise the queen cursed them, and is made to fight a dragon. While Nox just...searches for Amaris and has a ton of awful things happen to her. Over 500 pages in this book, and that is literally the entirety of the plot.
Oh, at some point, they go to a temple, which I guess is their church? And they worship an all-mother, yet everything is sexist as hell, despite there being a queen ruling and a female goddess as their main deity? There's a Black priestess who is only there to offer sage advice and magical wisdom; she's never even named. (But it's definitely giving Nenneke at the Temple of Melitele.)
CHECK MY GOODREADS FOR THE REST
View all my reviews