6 Best Compact Toasters That Actually Fit Small Kitchens (2026)
We’ve been living and working out of small kitchens for years. Counter space is basically a luxury item. So when our old toaster finally gave out last spring — a bulky 4-slice beast that took up roughly a third of the counter — we spent way more time than we’d like to admit researching the best compact toasters before replacing it.
Here’s what we found: most “small toaster” roundups online are just recycled spec sheets dressed up as reviews. Nobody actually talks about whether the thing fits next to a coffee maker, or whether the sourdough you picked up from the farmers market on Saturday will even slide into the slots.
We tested six models over about two months. White sandwich bread, sourdough, bagels, frozen waffles — the works. These are our honest picks for the best 2 slice toaster 2025 and beyond.
Quick Picks: Best Compact Toasters at a Glance
Breville “A Bit More”
Beautiful by Drew Barrymore
How We Tested These Compact Toasters
Each toaster went through five full batches: regular white sandwich bread, a thick slice of sourdough from our local bakery, a plain bagel cut in half, and a frozen waffle straight from the freezer. We ran each on medium shade and timed every cycle. We also pressed the outside of each unit after two consecutive rounds — because we’ve burned ourselves on a toast bread toaster before and we’d rather not repeat that.
For our eco evaluation, we looked at wattage, checked whether any models used PFAS-containing coatings, and noted whether the crumb trays toaster design was easy enough to clean that you’d actually do it regularly rather than let it become a fire hazard.
A few of these surprised us. One annoyed us. We’ll get to both.
What Actually Makes a Toaster “Compact”?
Slim vs narrow vs mini: what these terms mean in practice
Marketers use these words interchangeably, but they’re not the same. A slim toaster is narrow from side to side — it has a small width. A mini toaster is smaller in every dimension. A miniature toaster often just means a cheap one with smaller slots. And “space saving toaster” is basically whatever the brand wants it to mean.
What actually matters is footprint. Here’s a rough guide:
Standard toaster: ~11" wide × 7" deep. Slim/slimline toaster: ~6–7" wide × 6" deep. What most compact toaster searches are actually looking for. Mini toaster / tiny toaster: ~7" wide × 5" deep. Smaller overall but often with narrower slots.
If you’ve ever searched “my mini toaster” or “dash mini toaster” looking for something truly tiny, this is the size category you’re in. Just know that going smaller usually means giving up slot width.
A dorm room or apartment setup usually needs a best toaster for small spaces — something under 7 inches wide to sit comfortably next to other appliances. For an RV or office, weight matters too. A lightweight toaster under 2.5 lbs is worth looking for. Cord length also matters, and almost nobody lists it.
A quick note on compact toaster 4 slice and 4 slice toaster compact options: if you’re feeding more than two people regularly, a compact 4 slice toaster makes sense. The Cuisinart 4 slice compact plastic toaster is one of the better options in that category. But for most small kitchens, a compact 2 slice toaster is all you need and takes up significantly less counter space toaster real estate.
The 6 Best Compact Toasters of 2026 — Full Reviews
1. Bella 2-Slice Slim Toaster — Best Ultra-Compact Slim Design
Specs: 6.1"W Ă— 5.7"D Ă— 7.5"H | Slot width: 1.2" | Slot length: 10" | 900W | 6 shade settings | ~$25
The Bella is our pick for best slimline toaster at the budget end. It’s not going to blow you away with performance, but it fits in spaces where no other toaster we tested could go. We slid it into a corner between a coffee maker and the wall with about two inches to spare. As a space saving toaster, it genuinely delivers.
The 10-inch long slot toaster design is a real upside — our sourdough dropped in without any awkward angling. Browning was decent on white bread, and the bagel function works without fuss. At 900W it’s one of the more energy-efficient small toasters here, and the crumb tray rinses clean easily. Among slimline toasters, it’s hard to beat at this price.
Narrowest footprint of the group at just 6.1 inches wide
10-inch slot length fits longer sourdough and artisan loaves
900W energy-efficient operation
Easy-clean removable crumb tray
Very affordable at ~$25 — one of the very best budget toasters in this size class
1.2-inch slot width is tight — thick bread gets stuck
Basic compact plastic toaster build, not the most durable feel
Where to buy: Amazon (~$25), Walmart (~$24), Target (~$26)
2. Breville “A Bit More” 2-Slice — Best Overall Compact Performance
Specs: 7.5"W Ă— 6.9"D Ă— 7.8"H | Slot width: 1.5" | Slot length: 6" | 1800W | 6 shade settings | ~$110
We know $110 for a two slice toaster sounds like a lot. We thought so too. But after using it alongside everything else, the quality gap is not subtle. This is the highest rated two slice toaster we tested, and it earns that reputation.
The “A Bit More” button — which adds 30 seconds to the cycle after toast pops up — sounds minor until you use it every single morning and realize you’ll never go back. Browning evenness was noticeably better than everything else we tested. Even the edges of sourdough came out with consistent color. Frozen waffles were done in under two minutes, crispy without the dry cardboard texture you usually get from a bread toaster at this size.
As a best 2-slice toaster pick for performance, nothing here touches it. You can find it at a Williams Sonoma toaster section or on Amazon for the same price. The stainless steel toaster housing feels premium and built to last. That said, it’s the widest of the group at 7.5 inches and shows fingerprints constantly.
Best browning evenness of all six models tested
“A Bit More” button is genuinely useful every single day
Premium stainless steel 2 slice toaster build feels built to last
Bagel, defrost, and reheat all work reliably
Lift & Look feature lets you check progress mid-cycle
Top pick in our 2 slice toaster reviews for overall quality
Widest footprint here at 7.5 inches
Stainless 2 slice toaster exterior shows fingerprints constantly
1800W draws more power than the other models
Where to buy: Amazon (~$110), Williams Sonoma (~$115), Best Buy (~$110)
3. GE 2-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster — Best for Precise Browning Control
Specs: 6.9"W Ă— 7.7"D Ă— 7.3"H | Slot width: 1.5" | 800W | 7 shade settings | ~$49
The GE toaster 2 slice is quietly one of the best 2 slice compact toaster options at this price. Seven shade settings gives real control when switching between bread types — we use setting 3 for white, 5 for sourdough, and the bagel function handles itself. After a week with this good 2 slice toaster, we stopped thinking about it. It just does what you tell it.
What surprised us was single-slice performance. A lot of 2 slice toasters give uneven results when you only run one slot. The GE handled it consistently. At 800W it’s the best economical toaster pick here if electricity costs are on your mind, and its stainless steel toaster 2 slice build is solid at the price point. In our toaster reviews 2 slice testing, it was the most consistent mid-range performer we evaluated.
The exterior gets warm after back-to-back cycles — not hot enough to burn, but it’s not a cool-touch design, so keep that in mind around kids.
7 shade settings for the most precise browning control in this group
Excellent single-slice consistency — rare at this price
Lowest wattage (800W) — best economical toaster pick
Stainless steel 2 slice toaster build feels durable
Exterior gets noticeably warm after two consecutive cycles
Slightly deeper footprint than other slim options
Where to buy: Amazon (~$49), Walmart (~$47), Home Depot (~$49)
4. Hamilton Beach 2-Slice — Best Value Features Under $35
Specs: 7.3"W Ă— 6.1"D Ă— 7.3"H | Slot width: 1.5" | 850W | 6 shade settings | ~$31
This is what we’d recommend to most people asking for a best affordable toaster that doesn’t feel cheap. The Hamilton Beach toaster has bagel, defrost, reheat, and cancel — all the functions you actually use — and the build quality is better than the price suggests. We’ve seen more expensive thin toasters feel flimsier.
Browning was consistent on white bread and solid on sourdough. Not Breville-level, but at a third of the price that comparison isn’t fair. The wide slot toaster design at 1.5 inches handled bagels without complaint, and the defrost function actually adds proper time rather than just running a standard cycle with a different label. In our 2 slice toasters reviews, this was the standout pick for value. If you want the best two slice toaster without spending more than $35, start here.
Full function set (bagel, defrost, reheat, cancel) for under $35
Wide slot 2 slice toaster design at 1.5 inches handles bagels comfortably
Sturdier build than the price suggests
850W keeps energy use moderate
Our top pick for best budget toaster with full features
Wider than the slimmest options at 7.3 inches
Browning can be slightly uneven at the highest shade settings
Plain design — nothing exciting to look at
Where to buy: Amazon (~$31), Walmart (~$29), Target (~$32)
5. Beautiful by Drew Barrymore 2-Slice — Best Stylish Budget Pick
Specs: 6.6"W × 6.3"D × 7.5"H | Slot width: 1.4" | 1100W | 6 shade settings | ~$40–76 depending on color
We were skeptical. Celebrity-branded, pastel colors, touch-activated display. Felt like paying for aesthetics over function. It’s actually pretty good. Browning was even, touch controls are responsive, and it’s one of the better-looking small kitchen appliances toaster options we’ve put on a counter.
This is the best digital toaster pick at the budget end. The touch display makes it feel modern in a way that mechanical dials don’t, and it adds almost no learning curve — tap the function, tap the shade, done. If you want a 2 slice toaster white or pastel option that actually performs, this is it. Available as a blue toaster 2 slice and several other colorways too.
The 1.4-inch slots are a real limitation though. Thick bread is a gamble. Stick to standard sandwich bread and bagels and you’ll be fine. Also, prices vary wildly by color — check Amazon and Target and compare before buying.
Attractive design in multiple color options including blue toaster 2 slice variants
Touch controls are clean and easy to use
Best best digital toaster pick under $80
Compact 6.6-inch width fits tight counters
Consistent browning on standard bread
1.4-inch slots too narrow for thick or artisan bread
Price varies significantly by color — can feel arbitrary
Touch controls less responsive when hands are wet or cold
Higher standby power draw than mechanical designs
Where to buy: Amazon, Target, Walmart (prices vary by color — shop around)
6. Amazon Basics 2-Slice — Best No-Frills Compact Toaster
Specs: 7.5"W Ă— 6.1"D Ă— 7.3"H | Slot width: 1.5" | 1000W | 7 shade settings | ~$18
Sometimes you just want a simple toaster that makes toast, doesn’t die after eight months, and costs less than dinner. The Amazon Basics is the best simple toaster we’ve tested at this price. We’ve had one running in a second kitchen for over a year and it performs identically to day one.
No bagel setting, no defrost, no countdown timer. Just a shade dial, a lever, and seven settings. As a best inexpensive toaster pick, nothing here beats it. It’s also our top recommendation when people ask about 2 slice toasters at walmart alternatives — this performs just as well for less money. The slot toaster design is basic but functional, and the golden brown toaster results on medium shade are reliably good. For a bread toaster 2 slice that just works, save your money and get this.
Cheapest option at ~$18 — the best inexpensive toaster here
7 shade settings despite the low price
1.5-inch wide slot toaster design handles bagels fine
Consistent results after over a year of real-world use
Our pick for best 2 piece toaster when budget is the priority
No bagel, defrost, or reheat functions
Compact plastic toaster build won’t last as long as stainless options
Widest footprint tied with Breville at 7.5 inches
Nothing here for specialty bread or frozen items
Where to buy: Amazon (~$18), Walmart (~$17)
Side-by-Side Comparison: All 6 Compact Toasters
Compact Toaster Buying Guide
Measure your available counter space before ordering anything. Most compact toasters are 6 to 8 inches wide. That gap matters when you’re working with 18 inches of counter between the microwave and the backsplash. If you regularly make toast for more than two people, a compact toaster 4 slice is worth considering — the Cuisinart 4 slice compact plastic toaster is one of the better options in that format. For most small kitchens though, a toaster compact 2-slice model is all you need.
Bagels need at least 1.5-inch wide slot 2 slice toaster design. Artisan sourdough needs a long slot toaster — anything under 9 inches and your bread won’t fully submerge. The toasters 2 slice wide slot category exists for exactly this reason, and most budget models skip it to cut costs. Check both dimensions before buying. If you want the smallest 2 slice toaster possible, just know that usually means narrower slots.
Most compact toasters use nichrome wire elements. They work fine. Quartz elements heat faster and brown more evenly but show up mostly on higher-end models. If consistent golden brown toaster results matter to you, it’s worth paying for quartz. For everyday sandwich bread, nichrome is perfectly adequate.
Bagel function: yes. Defrost: yes, especially if you keep bread in the freezer. Reheat: occasionally useful. A smart toaster with a digital display sounds great until you’re half-asleep at 7am and the touchscreen won’t register your tap. Sometimes a simple toaster with a good dial is genuinely the better call.
Also worth mentioning: if you’ve ever considered a toaster oven small format instead of a slot toaster, the best small toaster oven options do offer more versatility. But for pure toast performance in a tight space, a dedicated 2-slice toaster wins every time on speed and footprint.
800–1000W is the sweet spot for a compact toaster 2 slice — fast enough to be practical, efficient enough not to spike your electricity bill. For PFAS concerns, look for stainless steel toaster interiors and explicitly BPA-free materials. The 2 slice stainless toaster options here — GE and Breville — are the safest bets on that front.
A quick note on the Cuisinart 2 slice toaster range, specifically the Cuisinart CPT 122 and the Cuisinart compact 2 slice toaster: these are solid alternatives worth comparing if none of our six picks fully click for you. The Cuisinart simplitouch XL 2 slice toaster is also worth a look if you want touch controls with a bit more slot length than the Drew Barrymore offers.
Under $25: Basic function, plastic build, no extras. Works. $25–$50: Where most people should shop. Better slots, full functions, more durable. $50–$110: Premium compact territory. Noticeably better browning and materials. Over $110: Unless you really care about toasters, it’s overkill.
Which Compact Toaster Is Right for You?
Apartments and studio kitchens: Go with the Bella if space is truly critical — it’s the best toaster for small spaces in this group — or the GE if you want better browning without sacrificing much footprint. Both are solid toaster compact options.
Dorm rooms: The Amazon Basics. Cheap, reliable, and easy to replace. The Bella’s tiny toaster form factor is great here too if you need to stash it in a cabinet between uses.
Office use: Hamilton Beach. Quiet enough not to annoy coworkers, wide enough slots for bagels and English muffins, and at $31 nobody’s going to be upset if it disappears from the break room. It’s the top rated two slice toaster pick for shared spaces.
Sourdough and artisan bread: The Bella’s 10-inch slot length is a surprise winner here despite the narrow width. For thick artisan loaves, the Breville’s 1.5-inch wide slot toaster design is the better call.
Comparing other options: If you’ve been looking at the KitchenAid 2 slice toaster, the Smeg two slice toaster, or the Whall 2 slice toaster, all three are legitimate picks — the Smeg especially for design. The T Fal toaster 2 slice is another budget-friendly alternative worth checking if you want something different from our six. And if you want the best 2 slot toaster in a retro form factor, the best two slot toaster category has some great options outside this list too.
Where to Buy a Compact Toaster
Amazon has the widest selection and usually the best prices on Breville, Hamilton Beach, and Amazon Basics. Price tracking is worth doing — the Hamilton Beach goes on sale regularly. It’s often the best place to find a best buy toaster deal on premium models too.
Walmart is the go-to for Bella and GE. Their in-store pricing on 2 slice toasters at walmart is often slightly below Amazon on the budget end.
Target carries the Beautiful by Drew Barrymore line and has better colorway selection than anywhere else. Also good for Hamilton Beach.
Best Buy is worth checking for the Breville if you want to see it in person before buying. Their open-box deals on small kitchen appliances toaster options can save you 20–30%.
We’re not a lab full of appliance engineers. What we are is a team that has lived and cooked out of small kitchens for years, tested these six models in a real kitchen over two months, and cares specifically about whether something is practical, built to last, and made from materials that aren’t going to leach anything into your morning toast. No products were sent for review. Every recommendation here came from actual use.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the slimmest 2-slice toaster you can buy?
The Bella 2-Slice Slim Toaster at 6.1 inches wide is one of the narrowest and best-value compact toasters available.
What’s the best compact toaster under $35?
Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Toaster offers the best value with solid performance, durability, and consistent toasting results.
Which compact toasters work for sourdough and artisan bread?
Choose a long-slot (9"+) or wide-slot (1.5"+) toaster like Breville Compact Smart Toaster or Cuisinart Long Slot Toaster for thick or long bread slices.
What’s the difference between a toaster and a toaster oven?
A 2-slice toaster is faster, compact, and ideal for bread, while a toaster oven offers more cooking versatility but takes more space and costs more.
6 Best Compact Toasters That Actually Fit Small Kitchens (2026)
Cramped counter? These 6 slim toasters deliver perfect toast without stealing your space. Tested, ranked & ready to buy.
6 Best Compact Toasters That Actually Fit Small Kitchens (2026)
We’ve been living and working out of small kitchens for years. Counter space is basically a luxury item. So when our old toaster finally gave out last spring — a bulky 4-slice beast that took up roughly a third of the counter — we spent way more time than we’d like to admit researching the best compact toasters before replacing it.
Here’s what we found: most “small toaster” roundups online are just recycled spec sheets dressed up as reviews. Nobody actually talks about whether the thing fits next to a coffee maker, or whether the sourdough you picked up from the farmers market on Saturday will even slide into the slots.
We tested six models over about two months. White sandwich bread, sourdough, bagels, frozen waffles — the works. These are our honest picks for the best 2 slice toaster 2025 and beyond.
Quick Picks: Best Compact Toasters at a Glance
Breville “A Bit More”
Beautiful by Drew Barrymore
How We Tested These Compact Toasters
Each toaster went through five full batches: regular white sandwich bread, a thick slice of sourdough from our local bakery, a plain bagel cut in half, and a frozen waffle straight from the freezer. We ran each on medium shade and timed every cycle. We also pressed the outside of each unit after two consecutive rounds — because we’ve burned ourselves on a toast bread toaster before and we’d rather not repeat that.
For our eco evaluation, we looked at wattage, checked whether any models used PFAS-containing coatings, and noted whether the crumb trays toaster design was easy enough to clean that you’d actually do it regularly rather than let it become a fire hazard.
A few of these surprised us. One annoyed us. We’ll get to both.
What Actually Makes a Toaster “Compact”?
Slim vs narrow vs mini: what these terms mean in practice
Marketers use these words interchangeably, but they’re not the same. A slim toaster is narrow from side to side — it has a small width. A mini toaster is smaller in every dimension. A miniature toaster often just means a cheap one with smaller slots. And “space saving toaster” is basically whatever the brand wants it to mean.
What actually matters is footprint. Here’s a rough guide:
Standard toaster: ~11" wide × 7" deep. Slim/slimline toaster: ~6–7" wide × 6" deep. What most compact toaster searches are actually looking for. Mini toaster / tiny toaster: ~7" wide × 5" deep. Smaller overall but often with narrower slots.
If you’ve ever searched “my mini toaster” or “dash mini toaster” looking for something truly tiny, this is the size category you’re in. Just know that going smaller usually means giving up slot width.
A dorm room or apartment setup usually needs a best toaster for small spaces — something under 7 inches wide to sit comfortably next to other appliances. For an RV or office, weight matters too. A lightweight toaster under 2.5 lbs is worth looking for. Cord length also matters, and almost nobody lists it.
A quick note on compact toaster 4 slice and 4 slice toaster compact options: if you’re feeding more than two people regularly, a compact 4 slice toaster makes sense. The Cuisinart 4 slice compact plastic toaster is one of the better options in that category. But for most small kitchens, a compact 2 slice toaster is all you need and takes up significantly less counter space toaster real estate.
The 6 Best Compact Toasters of 2026 — Full Reviews
1. Bella 2-Slice Slim Toaster — Best Ultra-Compact Slim Design
Specs: 6.1"W Ă— 5.7"D Ă— 7.5"H | Slot width: 1.2" | Slot length: 10" | 900W | 6 shade settings | ~$25
The Bella is our pick for best slimline toaster at the budget end. It’s not going to blow you away with performance, but it fits in spaces where no other toaster we tested could go. We slid it into a corner between a coffee maker and the wall with about two inches to spare. As a space saving toaster, it genuinely delivers.
The 10-inch long slot toaster design is a real upside — our sourdough dropped in without any awkward angling. Browning was decent on white bread, and the bagel function works without fuss. At 900W it’s one of the more energy-efficient small toasters here, and the crumb tray rinses clean easily. Among slimline toasters, it’s hard to beat at this price.
Narrowest footprint of the group at just 6.1 inches wide
10-inch slot length fits longer sourdough and artisan loaves
900W energy-efficient operation
Easy-clean removable crumb tray
Very affordable at ~$25 — one of the very best budget toasters in this size class
1.2-inch slot width is tight — thick bread gets stuck
Basic compact plastic toaster build, not the most durable feel
Where to buy: Amazon (~$25), Walmart (~$24), Target (~$26)
2. Breville “A Bit More” 2-Slice — Best Overall Compact Performance
Specs: 7.5"W Ă— 6.9"D Ă— 7.8"H | Slot width: 1.5" | Slot length: 6" | 1800W | 6 shade settings | ~$110
We know $110 for a two slice toaster sounds like a lot. We thought so too. But after using it alongside everything else, the quality gap is not subtle. This is the highest rated two slice toaster we tested, and it earns that reputation.
The “A Bit More” button — which adds 30 seconds to the cycle after toast pops up — sounds minor until you use it every single morning and realize you’ll never go back. Browning evenness was noticeably better than everything else we tested. Even the edges of sourdough came out with consistent color. Frozen waffles were done in under two minutes, crispy without the dry cardboard texture you usually get from a bread toaster at this size.
As a best 2-slice toaster pick for performance, nothing here touches it. You can find it at a Williams Sonoma toaster section or on Amazon for the same price. The stainless steel toaster housing feels premium and built to last. That said, it’s the widest of the group at 7.5 inches and shows fingerprints constantly.
Best browning evenness of all six models tested
“A Bit More” button is genuinely useful every single day
Premium stainless steel 2 slice toaster build feels built to last
Bagel, defrost, and reheat all work reliably
Lift & Look feature lets you check progress mid-cycle
Top pick in our 2 slice toaster reviews for overall quality
Widest footprint here at 7.5 inches
Stainless 2 slice toaster exterior shows fingerprints constantly
1800W draws more power than the other models
Where to buy: Amazon (~$110), Williams Sonoma (~$115), Best Buy (~$110)
3. GE 2-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster — Best for Precise Browning Control
Specs: 6.9"W Ă— 7.7"D Ă— 7.3"H | Slot width: 1.5" | 800W | 7 shade settings | ~$49
The GE toaster 2 slice is quietly one of the best 2 slice compact toaster options at this price. Seven shade settings gives real control when switching between bread types — we use setting 3 for white, 5 for sourdough, and the bagel function handles itself. After a week with this good 2 slice toaster, we stopped thinking about it. It just does what you tell it.
What surprised us was single-slice performance. A lot of 2 slice toasters give uneven results when you only run one slot. The GE handled it consistently. At 800W it’s the best economical toaster pick here if electricity costs are on your mind, and its stainless steel toaster 2 slice build is solid at the price point. In our toaster reviews 2 slice testing, it was the most consistent mid-range performer we evaluated.
The exterior gets warm after back-to-back cycles — not hot enough to burn, but it’s not a cool-touch design, so keep that in mind around kids.
7 shade settings for the most precise browning control in this group
Excellent single-slice consistency — rare at this price
Lowest wattage (800W) — best economical toaster pick
Stainless steel 2 slice toaster build feels durable
Exterior gets noticeably warm after two consecutive cycles
Slightly deeper footprint than other slim options
Where to buy: Amazon (~$49), Walmart (~$47), Home Depot (~$49)
4. Hamilton Beach 2-Slice — Best Value Features Under $35
Specs: 7.3"W Ă— 6.1"D Ă— 7.3"H | Slot width: 1.5" | 850W | 6 shade settings | ~$31
This is what we’d recommend to most people asking for a best affordable toaster that doesn’t feel cheap. The Hamilton Beach toaster has bagel, defrost, reheat, and cancel — all the functions you actually use — and the build quality is better than the price suggests. We’ve seen more expensive thin toasters feel flimsier.
Browning was consistent on white bread and solid on sourdough. Not Breville-level, but at a third of the price that comparison isn’t fair. The wide slot toaster design at 1.5 inches handled bagels without complaint, and the defrost function actually adds proper time rather than just running a standard cycle with a different label. In our 2 slice toasters reviews, this was the standout pick for value. If you want the best two slice toaster without spending more than $35, start here.
Full function set (bagel, defrost, reheat, cancel) for under $35
Wide slot 2 slice toaster design at 1.5 inches handles bagels comfortably
Sturdier build than the price suggests
850W keeps energy use moderate
Our top pick for best budget toaster with full features
Wider than the slimmest options at 7.3 inches
Browning can be slightly uneven at the highest shade settings
Plain design — nothing exciting to look at
Where to buy: Amazon (~$31), Walmart (~$29), Target (~$32)
5. Beautiful by Drew Barrymore 2-Slice — Best Stylish Budget Pick
Specs: 6.6"W × 6.3"D × 7.5"H | Slot width: 1.4" | 1100W | 6 shade settings | ~$40–76 depending on color
We were skeptical. Celebrity-branded, pastel colors, touch-activated display. Felt like paying for aesthetics over function. It’s actually pretty good. Browning was even, touch controls are responsive, and it’s one of the better-looking small kitchen appliances toaster options we’ve put on a counter.
This is the best digital toaster pick at the budget end. The touch display makes it feel modern in a way that mechanical dials don’t, and it adds almost no learning curve — tap the function, tap the shade, done. If you want a 2 slice toaster white or pastel option that actually performs, this is it. Available as a blue toaster 2 slice and several other colorways too.
The 1.4-inch slots are a real limitation though. Thick bread is a gamble. Stick to standard sandwich bread and bagels and you’ll be fine. Also, prices vary wildly by color — check Amazon and Target and compare before buying.
Attractive design in multiple color options including blue toaster 2 slice variants
Touch controls are clean and easy to use
Best best digital toaster pick under $80
Compact 6.6-inch width fits tight counters
Consistent browning on standard bread
1.4-inch slots too narrow for thick or artisan bread
Price varies significantly by color — can feel arbitrary
Touch controls less responsive when hands are wet or cold
Higher standby power draw than mechanical designs
Where to buy: Amazon, Target, Walmart (prices vary by color — shop around)
6. Amazon Basics 2-Slice — Best No-Frills Compact Toaster
Specs: 7.5"W Ă— 6.1"D Ă— 7.3"H | Slot width: 1.5" | 1000W | 7 shade settings | ~$18
Sometimes you just want a simple toaster that makes toast, doesn’t die after eight months, and costs less than dinner. The Amazon Basics is the best simple toaster we’ve tested at this price. We’ve had one running in a second kitchen for over a year and it performs identically to day one.
No bagel setting, no defrost, no countdown timer. Just a shade dial, a lever, and seven settings. As a best inexpensive toaster pick, nothing here beats it. It’s also our top recommendation when people ask about 2 slice toasters at walmart alternatives — this performs just as well for less money. The slot toaster design is basic but functional, and the golden brown toaster results on medium shade are reliably good. For a bread toaster 2 slice that just works, save your money and get this.
Cheapest option at ~$18 — the best inexpensive toaster here
7 shade settings despite the low price
1.5-inch wide slot toaster design handles bagels fine
Consistent results after over a year of real-world use
Our pick for best 2 piece toaster when budget is the priority
No bagel, defrost, or reheat functions
Compact plastic toaster build won’t last as long as stainless options
Widest footprint tied with Breville at 7.5 inches
Nothing here for specialty bread or frozen items
Where to buy: Amazon (~$18), Walmart (~$17)
Side-by-Side Comparison: All 6 Compact Toasters
Compact Toaster Buying Guide
Measure your available counter space before ordering anything. Most compact toasters are 6 to 8 inches wide. That gap matters when you’re working with 18 inches of counter between the microwave and the backsplash. If you regularly make toast for more than two people, a compact toaster 4 slice is worth considering — the Cuisinart 4 slice compact plastic toaster is one of the better options in that format. For most small kitchens though, a toaster compact 2-slice model is all you need.
Bagels need at least 1.5-inch wide slot 2 slice toaster design. Artisan sourdough needs a long slot toaster — anything under 9 inches and your bread won’t fully submerge. The toasters 2 slice wide slot category exists for exactly this reason, and most budget models skip it to cut costs. Check both dimensions before buying. If you want the smallest 2 slice toaster possible, just know that usually means narrower slots.
Most compact toasters use nichrome wire elements. They work fine. Quartz elements heat faster and brown more evenly but show up mostly on higher-end models. If consistent golden brown toaster results matter to you, it’s worth paying for quartz. For everyday sandwich bread, nichrome is perfectly adequate.
Bagel function: yes. Defrost: yes, especially if you keep bread in the freezer. Reheat: occasionally useful. A smart toaster with a digital display sounds great until you’re half-asleep at 7am and the touchscreen won’t register your tap. Sometimes a simple toaster with a good dial is genuinely the better call.
Also worth mentioning: if you’ve ever considered a toaster oven small format instead of a slot toaster, the best small toaster oven options do offer more versatility. But for pure toast performance in a tight space, a dedicated 2-slice toaster wins every time on speed and footprint.
800–1000W is the sweet spot for a compact toaster 2 slice — fast enough to be practical, efficient enough not to spike your electricity bill. For PFAS concerns, look for stainless steel toaster interiors and explicitly BPA-free materials. The 2 slice stainless toaster options here — GE and Breville — are the safest bets on that front.
A quick note on the Cuisinart 2 slice toaster range, specifically the Cuisinart CPT 122 and the Cuisinart compact 2 slice toaster: these are solid alternatives worth comparing if none of our six picks fully click for you. The Cuisinart simplitouch XL 2 slice toaster is also worth a look if you want touch controls with a bit more slot length than the Drew Barrymore offers.
Under $25: Basic function, plastic build, no extras. Works. $25–$50: Where most people should shop. Better slots, full functions, more durable. $50–$110: Premium compact territory. Noticeably better browning and materials. Over $110: Unless you really care about toasters, it’s overkill.
Which Compact Toaster Is Right for You?
Apartments and studio kitchens: Go with the Bella if space is truly critical — it’s the best toaster for small spaces in this group — or the GE if you want better browning without sacrificing much footprint. Both are solid toaster compact options.
Dorm rooms: The Amazon Basics. Cheap, reliable, and easy to replace. The Bella’s tiny toaster form factor is great here too if you need to stash it in a cabinet between uses.
Office use: Hamilton Beach. Quiet enough not to annoy coworkers, wide enough slots for bagels and English muffins, and at $31 nobody’s going to be upset if it disappears from the break room. It’s the top rated two slice toaster pick for shared spaces.
Sourdough and artisan bread: The Bella’s 10-inch slot length is a surprise winner here despite the narrow width. For thick artisan loaves, the Breville’s 1.5-inch wide slot toaster design is the better call.
Comparing other options: If you’ve been looking at the KitchenAid 2 slice toaster, the Smeg two slice toaster, or the Whall 2 slice toaster, all three are legitimate picks — the Smeg especially for design. The T Fal toaster 2 slice is another budget-friendly alternative worth checking if you want something different from our six. And if you want the best 2 slot toaster in a retro form factor, the best two slot toaster category has some great options outside this list too.
Where to Buy a Compact Toaster
Amazon has the widest selection and usually the best prices on Breville, Hamilton Beach, and Amazon Basics. Price tracking is worth doing — the Hamilton Beach goes on sale regularly. It’s often the best place to find a best buy toaster deal on premium models too.
Walmart is the go-to for Bella and GE. Their in-store pricing on 2 slice toasters at walmart is often slightly below Amazon on the budget end.
Target carries the Beautiful by Drew Barrymore line and has better colorway selection than anywhere else. Also good for Hamilton Beach.
Best Buy is worth checking for the Breville if you want to see it in person before buying. Their open-box deals on small kitchen appliances toaster options can save you 20–30%.
We’re not a lab full of appliance engineers. What we are is a team that has lived and cooked out of small kitchens for years, tested these six models in a real kitchen over two months, and cares specifically about whether something is practical, built to last, and made from materials that aren’t going to leach anything into your morning toast. No products were sent for review. Every recommendation here came from actual use.
