ƧERA she/her Bedsy’s gf(real). 90% of time I’d rather be with animals than people. John 14:8. I love music. Smiling and enjoying life. Hockey fangirl. I love Tate McRae. Mr.Brightside. Fear of God. Smallville lover. Broken down and hungry for your love౨ৎ Touch starved. I used to make up long speeches to you after you left. Dark mode user. Yearning. 🏒🍁.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Bought like 7 fifa card packs and didn’t get a single Jude card??? But then I remembered I have one from the 2022 World Cup that always sits in my wallet since then 👅
Happy birthday to MYYY bae!! 💗🥰🎉🫰👅Genuinely wish the best for him and hopefully he recovers quickly, and may this year won’t bring him any more injuries so we get to see Connor play rest of the season + hopefully no injuries the following seasons!! 🥹🫰
╰ In which You’re just obsessed with your boyfriends abs and muscles..
Warnings Fluff, no smut but some suggestive stuff implied, reader being touchy around Jobe’s family (not that they notice or smth), use of y/n, established relationship, muscle kink(?), use of pet names (barely), kissing abs, pda, 1.1k words
Jobe B. masterlist
Being on a vacation with Jobe felt like a dream, but having his entire family around didn’t exactly help the constant ache of neediness that pulsed through you whenever Jobe was near.
You really loved it, the opportunity to grow closer with his parents, to laugh with Jude and his girlfriend, and to experience Greece’s breathtaking islands from the deck of a private boat was something you’d cherish forever.
But sometimes, you wished the boat was just for the two of you, where you didn’t need to behave. Because right now, all you could focus on was your boyfriend.
And especially focus on his toned abs. And muscles.
Back home, Jobe was well aware of how much you enjoyed his abs and muscles, probably way more than he did himself. And he didn’t blame you one bit. In fact, he silently thanked football every single day for sculpting this body, because the way your eyes devoured him, it was worth every training session.
But what he wasn’t aware of was that you were thinking like this right now, surrounded by his family. He obviously had no clue.
Jobe stood at the railing in nothing but navy swim trunks, the sun kissing every inch of his body. When he pointed out a distant island to his dad and Jude, his muscles flexed naturally with the movement.
You had to bite your lip to stop yourself from staring too obviously, your cold iced tea sat forgotten in your hands as you tried your best to put your attention to his mother and Ashlyn talking, rather than staring at Jobe.
When Jobe and Jude finally sat down at the foredeck, leaning slightly back on their arms with their legs stretched out in front of them, their dad came over to join the conversation with you, his mom, and Jude’s girlfriend. You took the opportunity to excuse yourself from the group, murmuring something about the sun getting stronger.
You reached into your bag for the bottle of sunscreen and walked toward Jobe. He looked up at you with a smile as you approached. “You should put some sunscreen on.” You said softly, holding up the bottle.
“Oh yeah, thanks, babe!” Jobe replied, reaching out his hand to take it from you.
You smiled sweetly, pulling it back just out of reach. “I’ll help.”
His eyebrows lifted slightly in surprise, but he was more than happy to get your help. He moved a little, giving you more space. You started with his back to save the best for last, smoothing the lotion over his broad shoulders and the defined muscles along his spine.
Once his back was done, you moved around to face him. You squeezed a generous amount of sunscreen into your palms, rubbing them together before reaching for his stomach. The moment your palm made contact with his warm skin, Jobe instinctively squeezed his abs, the cool lotion making his muscles tense and ripple beneath your touch.
You bit back a grin, feeling every ridge and line move under your hands.
You used both hands now, spreading the sunscreen in smooth strokes. You tried to keep it subtle, tracing the defined squares of his sixpack, letting your fingertips glide along the deep cuts at his sides, but it was impossible to keep your hands away.
Just as you finished, Jude turned toward you. “Y/n, you doing full service today? Mind putting some on me too?”
You straightened up, wiping your hands on a towel, and gave him a playful eyeroll. “Fine..” you said, trying to sound nonchalant.
Later when you all were back at the beach, Jobe laid comfortably on a sunbed under a large umbrella. You sat right beside him near his thighs, the two of you talking quietly while his family laughed in the water a good distance away.
Without a thought, you reached out and placed your hand on his stomach again. You didn’t feel like there was a need to be careful now, your fingers traced the hard planes of his abs slowly, feeling the firm ridges move under your touch as he breathed.
Jobe continued talking about tomorrow’s plans as if nothing was happening. When he finished his sentence, you looked up at him with a soft smile. “You know you look so good today!” You complimented him.
Jobe’s grin widened, his eyes crinkling in a charming way you loved. “Really? Thank you, babe. You’re just as beautiful as you always are,” he cut himself off. “— Actually, even more with this sun on you.”
“Thank you, baby!” You replied, still running your palm over his warm stomach. “But really.. even your abs have got me so distracted today.”
He let out a low laugh, the sound vibrating under your hand. “Are you really this worked up with everyone around?” He teased lightly.
You jokingly glanced around, checking the shoreline. His family was still happily swimming. “I don’t see anyone around right now?!” You said innocently.
“Yeah, not right now.” Jobe replied, raising an eyebrow. “But on the boat? That was my whole family right there.”
“So?” you shrugged, a playful smile tugging at your lips.
You leaned down and pressed a soft kiss to the center of his stomach, then another, and another, trailing your lips over the defined muscles. Jobe’s hand found its way into your hair, holding it gently, his fingers threading through the strands as you worshipped his abs with kisses.
When you finally made your way up to his lips, he happily pulled you closer, his hand moving to the back of your head to deepen the kiss. It was sweet, his mouth moving against yours. When you started to pull away after a moment, he chased your lips with a few soft pecks, making you smile against him.
When he finally let you pull away after the few more pecks, you were both smiling. You leaned forward slightly on the sunbed and reached into the back pocket of your shorts, pulling out your phone. “Let me take a picture of you.” You said, already opening the camera app.
Jobe raised an eyebrow, still lounging back against the cushions. “Is there any particular reason you would need to take a picture of me right now?”
You grinned, tilting your head. “Do I have to have a reason to take a picture of my boyfriend?” you asked, deliberately dragging out the word ‘my.’
He shrugged. “I don’t know.. I’m just trying to understand if it’s because of how I look right now, or so you can stare at the abs in the picture later.”
You laughed softly, cheeks warming. “Well, I actually wanted to take a picture of you because you look really good right now.. but thanks for the idea. Now I’ll do both.”
He happily flexed his biceps for the camera, making sure to tighten his core at the same time. You snapped a few shots, adjusting the angle to capture the way the light kissed him. “Perfect!” You murmured.
— This is pretty boring, bec i didn't know what to write, but i wanted to post something for Jobe, so i would love to get sent in some requests for him !!
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Can you write a Quinn Hughes x reader with a shy reader and she is like the physical therapist or he gets injured and she is a nurse? And they meet and then they go on a date and he is really sweet with her even though she is shy and doesn’t talk about at first?
I don’t write for the Hughes brothers. I used to have Jack on my masterlist, but I deleted it a while ago. A quick check of my blog before sending a request would be really appreciated.
cw. canon rafe, unhealthy obsession, stalking, rafe and a one-sided crush (at first), angst, kissing, needy rafe, masturbation (m), meltdowns, confessions, lots of dialogue, inebriated sex, drugs, unprotected sex, semi public sex, breeding, size kink (rafe has a huge dick), dom/sub, possessiveness, light cumplay, reader is often pressured into acts with rafe. it is not entirely consensual.
synopsis. rafe has never had such intense feelings for someone until he met you. his problem is that he doesn't know how to get you to want him back.
Rafe watches you intently as you flit around the snack bar at the country club, serving a rich family overpriced ice creams. You'd been working at the concessions stand since summer started. No doubt a seasonal job to pay for college. He could pay your whole tuition and not bat an eye, and it's not like he hasn't offered on multiple occasions.
He'd been strangely offended when you'd gotten defensive and angry. You accused him of throwing money at you like you're a whore. You think the worst of him. He knows you do. He can see the way you behave around him.
He noticed your smile always faded when he entered your line of sight. You usually bolted with a weak excuse of being busy, or gave him clipped, terse responses if he managed to get you to speak to him. Even then, it felt like he was talking at you, and you were responding like you had a gun to your head.
Perhaps you thought you were too good for him. That fancy college you were going to was getting to your head. Maybe you were dating some douchebag econ major... He didn't even realize the family left and he was just staring at you. You're probably even more creeped out by him now. You have this odd look on your face and there's a stiffness in the way you stand now, like you're trying to shrink yourself without being obvious.
He takes a sharp breath in and walks over to you, hands sliding into his pocket to hold out the pretty necklace he bought you today. He was planning to ask you out. For the second time this week already.
He fidgets with the necklace in his pocket, running his thumb along the delicate little charm he'd picked out earlier that day. It reminded him of you, all soft and bright and way too expensive for someone scooping sherbet in the heat. He'd thought about just leaving it in your locker. But no, that'd be weird. Creepy, even. He wasn't creepy.
Your shift is almost over. He can tell by the way you've started glancing at your phone, counting down minutes. You don't look up when he stops at the counter. But you freeze for just a second. Your hand lingers too long on a napkin dispenser.
"I g-got you something," he mumbles, voice low and a little nervous, like a child speaking to their first love. He pulls the necklace from his pocket slowly, afraid you'll turn him away. You finally look up. Not at the necklace but at him. Your face is guarded.
"Rafe…" Your voice is soft, but there's weight behind it. You sound tired. "I told you not to-"
"You didn't let me finish last time," he says, setting the little box a little too hard onto the countertop. "You never… you never let me finish. I'm not trying to buy your attention. I just… think about you a lot." He swallows, tongue darting across the inside of his cheek. "You don't even have to wear it. I just thought it was pretty. Like you."
You blink, eyes scanning his face. It almost sounds like he's rambling, and your cheeks warm up at the compliment. Still, wearing something a man bought you is far too intimate for your liking. He notices your hands twitch slightly at your sides.
You shift your weight like you want to step back but don't want to make it obvious. The silence that follows is thick. Your eyes drop to the box, then lift again to meet his. You're not smiling. He wishes you'd smile at him. The cute one with a hint of a dimple. You're so adorable.
"I don't want to owe you anything," you say quietly. "And I don't want you thinking that this means anything. Because it doesn't. I don't feel that way towards you."
Rafe's feels his heart sink like a rock in a body of water, his eyes trained on you as you lower your head, gnawing on your plump lower lip. You're a coward. He thinks to himself. Mumbling that to him while being incapable of looking him in the eyes. He reminds himself that this happens every time he makes a move on you, but it still stings.
"Why not? How do I make you want me?" The words tumble out before he can stop them. He feels like such a loser. He's practically begging for your attention.
"You dont, Rafe." You mumble. You don't meet his eyes again as you gather up your things, shifting uncomfortably as you turn away. There's no venom in your voice, like he's not even worth the time or energy to get mad at. "Stop wasting your time with me and go hang out with the girls your speed."
He frowns, pushing his body against the counter as he watches you lock everything up. His eyes drift to the way your tits push against your thin polo when you lean forward to grab your phone charger. Fuck, he wants you.
His mind returns to your last couple words. "What do you mean my speed? You're my speed. I want you to be my speed."
You scoff lightly, shaking your head. You think he's clueless. He knows you do. As you slide out of the concessions stand and come around to roll down the security shutters and lock it. He stares down at you, admiring the way your body moves. You're not answering him, so he holds onto your upper arm and turns you with little to no effort so that he can look at you. You're just… so out of his league, and yet, he can't let go of this hope. This stupid, selfish hope that you'll turn to him one day. That you'll see him the way he's seeing you now.
"I don't know why you're doing this," he continues, his voice rougher than he means. "But I'm not the bad guy here, alright?" He steps closer to you, leaning in. His heart races, his voice low but urgent. "I know you... you don't want me anywhere near you. But I can't stop thinking about you. Every damn day. Every time I see you, I-" He pauses, his breath catching in his throat as the words spill out before he can stop them. "It h-hurts. It fucking hurts, you know?"
The silence between you two stretches, and Rafe's chest rises and falls rapidly like he's been holding his breath for too long. His hands shake. He's not sure if he's angry or desperate, but either way, he can't let it go. He needs something from you but he knows it's not something you can give so easily. You stare at him silently through long lashes, your brows furrowed. You hate him. "I'm going home, Rafe," you say, not acknowledging his desperation. "I suggest you give this a rest."
He watches as you tear your arm out of his grip to brush past him and head toward your dingy little car, hips swaying as you walk. The pretty necklace he bought you is still in his possession. Like he's out of his mind, he stalks after you from a distance just as you get into your car. He walks to his own truck and decides to tail you to your home.
-
Rafe shows up the next morning like he didn't follow you home the night before and sit in his truck outside your house for hours with his hands clenched tight on the steering wheel, replaying your voice in his head on a loop.
"I don't want you." "Stop wasting your time."
He'd been a fight with his dad this morning, and that, paired with yet another day going by with you refusing to open up to him, had pushed him over the edge. The fight had been loud, ugly, and violent and had left his voice hoarse and his knuckles raw from punching drywall. He'd stormed out without a plan, just his keys in hand and the necklace in his pocket.
You're working in the stupid concessions stand again, your face a little sleep ridden, but so so cute. He stares at you like it hurts to look and hurts worse not to.
When you see him storm up to the front, you frown immediately "I told you to stop coming here," you murmur softly, stepping back just a little, but you don't yell or swear at him.
"I know, I know," he rushes out, his voice low and breathless. "But I-I need this. I'm going through some shit right now, alright? I'm not okay. I swear I'll leave right after, I just.. fuck, I just need to hold you right now. Please."
You blink, staring at him from behind the counter with furrowed brows and pursed like you're unsure. Your voice is soft. "Rafe…"
He talks over you before you can turn him away "I'm not trying to pull anything. I'm not here to freak you out. I…" He drags a hand through his hair, pacing outside the snack shack like he's going to have a meltdown. "Please. I really, really need this. God, I miss you and I don't even have you yet."
That makes you pause, your brain scrambling to process the sheer desperation in his words. Your face is warm for a reason you don't comprehend right now. Your eyes flick up to his, and you sigh. "Fine," you whisper, stepping aside to move to the side door and open it. "Just for a bit." He's inside before you finish the sentence.
He practically throws himself on you, arms around your waist, head buried in your neck as he exhales into your skin. You stumble a little because he's so big and heavy, but he wraps his arms around you tighter to keep you steady. Your hands go instinctively to his shoulders, and he relaxes, grounded against you the second he has you in his arms. You're so warm and soft and you smell sweet, causing his body to relax against yours. He can finally breathe.
You tentatively reach up to touch his hair gently, voice unsure. "Did… something happen?"
He just hums, not answering right away, eyes fluttering shut against your collarbone. "You feel so good," he mumbles. "Shit… I don't know what's wrong with me…"
You don't respond. You just let him hold you, fingers threading through his hair, and for a moment, he actually feels calm. He doesn't even care that you're not kissing him or telling him you feel the same. This is enough for now.
He holds you for a long time. Too long, probably, but you don't push him off. Your fingers are still gently threading through his hair, and Rafe presses himself against you tighter like he can fuse the two of you together if he tries hard enough. Feels like he wants to be in your skin. He doesn't say anything for a moment, just soaks in the warmth of your body, the comfort of your scent, the softness of your voice when you ask, "Are you feeling any better?"
He is, really. Much, much better. So much better that he forgot all about Ward and all his other stupid problems, but he needs more. You've got him hooked. "Can I come hang out with you in the stand today?" he asks quietly, nuzzling into your throat. "I'll sit in the back, I swear I won't bother you, I swear."
You hesitate, and he feels it immediately in the way your fingers pause in his hair. You pull back slightly, and he lifts his head to meet your eyes, already expecting the no before you whisper it. "I can't, Rafe. I'll get in trouble. I can't have people hanging around,"
"But I'm not just people," he interrupts, frowning. "I'd be quiet. Just… just let me be near you, please. I can't go back there. Can't go home. Just wanna be with you."
"Rafe…"
"Okay," he says quickly, licking his lips and pulling his hand from his pocket. "Okay, fine. What about the necklace, then?" You blink as he holds out the box again, careful this time, not slamming it on a counter or shoving it in your hands. Just opening it slowly, almost reverently. "Will you wear it? Please?"
There's a pitiful look on his face that makes your resolve falter. His eyes are shiny, lips red and swollen from biting and licking, his face flushed. He's holding you tightly with his free hand. You sigh softly, giving in. "Fine. Just… just for today."
His whole face lights up. "Really? You will?" You nod, reaching for the box, but he stops you gently, one hand brushing yours. "C-can I put it on you?"
You hesitate again, and he's already behind you before you can think of a reason to say no. His fingers tremble a little as he pushes your hair aside, letting the soft strands fall through his hands like silk. You smell like something clean and dreamy, like vanilla and sunlight, and he swears it makes his head spin.
He hooks the necklace around your throat, clasping it carefully, and then just lets his hands rest on your shoulders for a second too long. You're wearing his necklace. Surely that means you're closer to becoming his, right? You're being so nice to him today, he thinks. "You look s'pretty, angel" he murmurs, eyes trained on your skin. "It looks perfect on you."
You turn to face him, not frowning so much anymore. "Thank you… but, seriously. You should go now, my boss does rounds in the morning, and-"
"I know, I know." He nods quickly, eyes dropping to your lips, voice barely above a whisper. "Do you... do you think I could kiss you? Just once?"
You pull back slightly, unsure. "I don't think that's a good idea…"
"Please," he breathes, his hands grabbing onto your arms to make sure you don't run from him. "I swear I won't ask again. Just once. I'm not okay, alright? I need to know what it feels like. Just one. I'm begging you."
You pause. He's looking at you like he's breaking and one kiss could fix something inside him. You furrow your brows, caught between your own better judgment and the way his voice sounds all wrecked and shaky when he speaks, and you know that he won't let this go, so yet again, you give in. "…Just a small one."
He doesn't wait, pressing his mouth to yours with such desperation it makes you reel back slightly. His hands come up to your face, thumbs grazing your cheeks like you're made of glass. He makes sure not to go too fast or try to shove his tongue in your mouth. He wants to savor every last bit of this before you pull away and go back to ignoring him. When his lips move against yours, it's reverent, and his lips seal around yours, making soft smacking sounds. He can't help the breathy groans that leave him. When you finally pull back, he's not all there.
You're warm in the face, wide-eyed, and still close enough that he can feel your breath fan against his lips. "Rafe…" you whisper, gently guiding him back by the shoulders. "You should go." He doesn't say anything, just nods, eyes still glassy and dazed, letting you push the door open and give him a soft little smile, biting your lip to hold it back, as he stumbles outside, like he's in a fog. The door shuts behind him.
He walks to his truck like he's drunk, heart pounding, lips tingling, mind still wrapped around the way your mouth felt on his. He's never felt this before. Not with anyone. He sits in his truck for a long time after that, tasting you on his lips and listening to his heart drum in his ears.
-
Rafe doesn't leave his room for hours after the kiss.
He's lying on his bed, shirt thrown onto the ground and breathing way too hard. The way your mouth felt on his feels like it's been carved into his brain. Burned into it, more like. He can't stop thinking about how it felt to hold you and press his lips to yours all desperate and sloppy no matter how many times he tries to get it together. He can still faintly taste your strawberry lip gloss on his mouth and hear the soft little moans you made when you kissed him back, even if they were quiet. Next time, he'll make you scream.
He turns over in his bed, running his fingers through his hair. He wonders if he's drowning. Nothing feels real right now. You kissed him. He didn't force himself on you or make you do anything you didn't want to. You gave yourself to him, and now he needs more, but you're so difficult. Sweet and soft but just out of reach like you like watching him go crazy.
He sits up too fast, legs bouncing with nervous energy as he grabs his phone and opens your social media so fast it feels like muscle memory. He scrolls through your posts until he finds one he's seen many times before. One where you're at a kegger with friends in a little crop top with shorts where he can see the bottom piece of your bikini underneath.
You look like his wet dreams come to life. He likes this picture because it looks like you were made for him. All sunkissed, wearing his favorite colors, smiling all cute and innocent, fuck…
He tosses his phone to the floor like it burns to hold it and closes his eyes until all he can see is your mouth parting against his, the way your lashes fluttered. The heat of your body under his hands, how easy it would've been to just keep going, to press you up against the wall and devour you like he wanted to. He can't breathe.
He's sliding his hand into his pants before he can think, not bothering to take off his shorts or boxers, just easing his cock out of their confines and groaning at its sensitivity, hunching forward and slowly beginning to pump his hand up and down. He thinks about you in his necklace, bending you over the counter of your dumb little snack store, kissing you again… God, he thinks you're it for him. You're all he wants..
He moans softly, quietly, the sound muffled into his pillow. His hips buck up into his fist, and it's not just lust driving him, it's panic. It feels like you crawled into his veins and rewired every cell of his body. "Shit… can't last…"
He fucks into his hand harder, chasing the feeling with a frustrated groan. It's not enough. It's not enough. He wants your voice in his ear, wants your thighs around his waist, wants your little breathy moans right against his mouth.
His hand moves faster, messier, thumb dragging over the tip just to feel the way his cock twitches, but it's not the same, not even close to how it felt when you touched him. He tightens his grip on his cock a little to try and imagine how it would feel being inside you for real. Wetter, he thinks, and he leans back to spit in his hand, then going back to milking his cock with his hand, forehead pressed into his pillow. His voice is quiet and wrecked, whispered little groans into the pillow as his hips twitch, fucking up into his fist like your pussy's the only thing that could calm him down. "Fuck... fuck... want you s'bad, angel, mngh"
His hand stutters, hips jerking, and he cums with a low, guttural groan that's more desperate than anything, thick, creamy spurts coating his fingers, his chest, his boxers, but the second it's over, the second he catches his breath, the ache only sharpens.
When he checks up on you the next morning like a routine at your place of work, he swears he's gonna puke when he pulls up to the country club and you're not there.
At first, he tells himself maybe you're just late. Maybe you overslept or your car broke down or you're inside and he didn't see you. But after he walks in and asks your manager, only to be told with a shrug that "she's taking a chill day," it's like the floor falls out from under him.
Why didn't you tell him? You gave him no explanation, no warning, no clue about what you're doing or or where you are or who you're with and his brain is going fucking crazy. He drives around for thirty minutes, chewing his nail and shaking his leg and refreshing your socials like a psycho, until finally he pulls up outside your house, parks crooked, throws it in park, and marches up the steps like a man possessed.
He knocks once. Then again, and quickly, he's pounding on the door, then with both fists. His heart is racing. His hands are sweating. And then you open the door and he just sags, a shaky breath leaving his chest. You're in a giant t-shirt with and little shorts, holding a spatula in one hand and blinking up at him like you just woke up. "Rafe?"
He's already crowding the door, peeking behind you like he's trying to find a way to barge in. "Why weren't you at work?" You frown up at him, still surprised at the sheer unexpectedness of his arrival. Why is it that he shows up wherever you go? "I... I just took the day off."
"Took the day off?" he echoes like you just told him you're moving to another continent. "Why?" You blink, stepping back a little because of how close he is. "Just wanted a day to myself. I'm going to a bonfire later and didn't wanna be tired."
"A bonfire," he repeats, stepping over the threshold without waiting for an invite. "With who?" His gaze flicks over to your exposed legs, then your thighs and your lips, plush and a little swollen. "You never take days off. Since when do you go to bonfires?"
You furrow your brows, confused and still kind of sleepy. "Rafe, what's going on? Are you okay?"
"No," he says immediately, eyes flitting over your face, down your neck, lingering on the dip of your collarbone, where the charm of the necklace he bought you is still resting. "No, I'm not. You weren't there. I-I didn't know where you were, cause you never told me."
Your expression softens as you see that he's not doing so good right now. Feels like he needs you. "I'm fine. I was just making pancakes."
"Who else is going?" he asks, voice hard and words coming out fast. "To the bonfire."
You pause. "I dunno. A few people."
"Guys?"
You blink. "Probably?"
His jaw clenches. "What are you wearing?"
You splutter again, this time caught off guard. "To the bonfire?"
"Yeah."
"Ah... not sure yet, I guess"
He stares at you like he doesn't believe you. Like you're lying just to mess with him. "Are you gonna drink?"
You finally realize the absurdity of his comments and scoff lightly. "Why are you acting like my boyfriend?"
Rafe takes a step closer to you, his breath coming out shaky, his jaw tight. His eyes are dark, gaze heavy with something you can't quite place. "Because I will be," he says, low and determined, like it's a promise. You're caught off guard, but you don't let him see that. You cross your arms over your chest, clearly trying to hold on to your composure. "What?"
His eyes never leave you. He looks dead serious; there's not a single flicker of hesitation in his voice. "I'm gonna be your boyfriend," he repeats, firm this time, almost like he's daring you to contradict him.
You stare at him, the weight of it settling over the room like a thick fog, and Rafe takes a step closer, like he's trying to prove something just by you letting him be so close to you.
"You can't just disappear like that, okay?" he says, sounding bossy. "I thought you were gone. Like...gone gone. I had to talk to your boss, cause I don't like when I don't know where you are," he rambles, eyes locked on yours. "I don't like not knowing who you're with, or what you're wearing, or if someone's getting you drunk and trying to take you home."
Alarmed by how he's starting to sound frantic, you think this would be a good time to give him some space and angle the door just enough that he can't get past it. "Rafe, go home." you say quietly, not looking him in the eye as you tuck the spatula behind you and lean into the door like a warning. "You're freaking me out."
Rafe's face twists, first in confusion, like he's still catching up to what you just said, and then in disbelief, then anger.
"How am I freaking you out, huh? You're just overreacting, like always. Trying to treat me like I'm a goddamn basket case."
"I don't like this," you continue, more firmly now, your pulse speeding up. "You show up at my house and start asking all these questions like you own me or something,"
"It's cause I care about you," he snaps, voice rising a little as his eyes burn into yours, his chest lifting with every breath. "You don't get it, do you? You think it's nothing, but it's not. You disappear, you don't text, and now you're telling me you're going out to get wasted with God knows who." His hands are clenching and unclenching rapidly and he keeps raking his hands incessantly through his hair.
"I don't owe you an explanation."
"Yes, you fucking do!"
You flinch, just slightly, and he sees how your fingers curl tighter around the edge of the door, and it makes him panic. He steps forward like he's going to force his way in and you push the door tighter with a hard look, shaking your head.
"I'm not doing this," you say, voice cold now, your tone clipped and unfamiliar. "I'm not gonna let you guilt trip me just because I wanted one night to myself."
"You're not just trying to have a night to yourself," he says bitterly, jaw tight as he takes a shaky breath, eyes wide and manic-like, as though he's about to unravel right in front of you. "You're going out so you can slut yourself out, right? So you can get drunk and let some random guy put his hands all over you, and then you're gonna let him fuck you."
"Excuse me?" you hiss, eyes wide as your entire body goes still.
"You think I don't know?" Rafe seethes, running a hand through his hair, pacing back like he's physically trying to keep from grabbing you. "You think I haven't seen the way you look when you're flirting? You get that sexy little look in your eyes like you're begging to be bent over. Like you want guys' attention. A-and you post shit, you wear tiny hooker shorts and laugh at every guy that breathes near you and then act like I'm the one who's crazy when I don't want to fucking lose you!"
"You are crazy," you snap, voice rising for the first time. "You're out of your fucking mind. You don't get to walk into my house and tell me what I can wear or who I can be around just because we kissed."
"IT WASN'T JUST A KISS!" he roars. "DON'T YOU FUCKING GET IT? YOU'RE EVERYTHING TO ME!"
You flinch back when he screams at you, and your breathing goes shallow, lips parting like you want to say something else, but nothing comes out. "Rafe," you say instead, voice low, scared. "P-please, you need to go."
"No," he whispers immediately, shaking his head like a child. "No, don't shut me out. Don't do this. You don't mean that-"
"Go away, Rafe!" you cry out, and slam the door in his face before you can change your mind. The sound echoes through your house, bouncing off the walls and rattling your chest. You lock it.
On the other side, you hear nothing for a long moment. And then the soft thud of his fist hitting the door once, twice. Not to knock, just because he doesn't know what else to do. Then footsteps. Then silence.
You slide to the floor and stare at the spatula still clutched in your hand, heart thudding against your ribs like it's trying to claw its way out, meanwhile he storms away to his truck, immediately driving at an obscene speed. He cruises down the road with one hand gripping the wheel and the other twitching restlessly on his thigh, his head pounding. The sun's going down and the sky is darkening, and all he can think about is you in some tiny little outfit, smiling at some guy who doesn’t fucking deserve it.
He goes home to pass the time with whatever helps take his mind off you. Lifting weights, doing jobs for his dad, golfing...
By nightfall he's buzzing and out on the road, headed to your stupid bonfire.
He hits the brakes too hard pulling into the dirt road leading to the beach. Gravel kicks up under the tires and his pulse doesn’t slow. He leans back in his seat for a second, staring out at the distant flames and silhouettes gathering around them, and he mutters under his breath.
He's met up with some friends, his pupils are blown wide and there’s a girl clinging to his arm, some mutual friend who laughs too loud at everything he says and keeps taking hits to impress him. He doesn’t even remember her name.
He’s already smoked, he did a line back at the house, and now everything feels loose and hazy except the fire and the blurry shape of you. He spots you instantly. You’re standing near the fire, laughing with someone he doesn’t recognize, hair tucked behind your ear, drink in your hand, face lit up by the flames.
He drops his arm from the girl like she’s heavy and annoying, snatches the joint from someone's hand without acting, and leans back into the circle of guys while his eyes never leave you.
Every time you smile, or tilt your head to listen to someone who isn’t him, it feels like his skin is burning. He’s bouncing his leg. Grinding his teeth. His fingertips twitch like he’s about to do something reckless, like walking up to you and grabbing your wrist and dragging you off to somewhere private.
The heat of his stare pricks at the back of your neck, even as you try to ignore it and keep sipping your drink, laughing with your friend and pretending you don’t feel your skin flush for no reason at all. But it gets worse with every passing minute. Every little sound around you starts to blur and all you can feel is him staring.
When you finally turn your head, you find him sitting with a group of guys by the fire, his legs bouncing.
You tear your gaze away and pretend you didn’t see, but it only takes a little while before you go off to talk to your friend and there's a warm, huge body pressing against your back, hands snaking around your waist. Music thrums in your ears, and you feel him nudging his hips against your ass as the scent of weed and expensive cologne fills your nose.
Rafe's voice comes out as a quiet slur against your ear. "M'sorry, angel" he mumbles, pressing his face into your hair. "Don't... d-don't want you mad at me. Couldn't stay home. You're not a slut, I didn't mean that...I swear I didn’t mean it."
You push his arm off, stepping away and whirling around to face him. "Rafe! Are you serious right now? You show up here with some girl all over you and now you’re grinding on me like nothing happened?"
His face twists up in shock or hurt. You can't tell. "No...no, what? No!" he says, voice cracking. "I'm not playing you, why the fuck would I be? I did not do anything with her, I just...fuck, I needed to see you. You slammed the door in my face and I thought-"
"Thought what?" you snap. "That you could get a rise out of me and show me how replaceable I am?" Your words make his eyes go all glassy, just for a second, then they darken. He looks feral. He's tired of you and your inability to understand him or his feelings. His jaw tightens and his breathing spikes, and all of a sudden, he snatches your wrist.
"Come here."
"Rafe, let go of me!"
He doesn’t listen. He’s pulling you off the beach, down the sand while ignoring your scattered protests, all the way until you’re stumbling up the wooden steps of a closed lifeguard shack just off the edge of the bonfire. You yank at his grip but he’s too strong, too frantic, like if he lets go, you’ll disappear entirely.
He opens the door and drags you inside, then slams it shut and locks it behind him. The noise of the party dulls outside. Inside, it’s just heavy silence and the sound of both your uneven breaths. You shove at his chest, not a fan of being in such an enclosed space with him. "You're being just as insane as you were at my house, Rafe. You're not even sober right now, are you?"
He stares at you like you just stabbed him. "You don’t get it," he mutters, almost to himself. "You don’t fucking get it."
"I do get it!" you bite back. "I get that you're a manipulative and controlling bast-" That’s when he loses it.
"You think I'm playing games with you?" He screams, grabbing you and shoving you up against the back wall. Your body slams back against the solid surface, and he gets up in your face, nose pressed into yours. "You think I'm playing games? You think this is some fucking joke to me? You have no idea what I feel when I look at you. I can't eat, I can't sleep, I can’t fucking think without you taking over every single last FUCKING one of my thoughts. I've never..!” His voice catches, and his breathing picks up so much that he sounds like he's hyperventilating. "I've never needed someone like this."
You gasp out loud, heart doing a little jump at his words. You dont know if you're confused or nervous or flustered, but he's starting to panic all over again, like he didn't mean to say that. Not in the way he did, at least.
Rafe stares at you like he’s just realized what he said. Like the words ripped out of him before he could pull them back. His eyes are huge, chest rising and falling fast.
“You need me?” you say, and your voice comes out soft. Disbelieving.
His lips part, and he nods, just once. "Yeah. Yeah, I do. I need you so fucking much I think it's killing me. And I know I act like an asshole, I know I say shit I don't mean, but when you slammed that door in my face I thought I was gonna lose my goddamn mind." His voice breaks at the edges again, cracking away. "And then I saw you laughing with someone else and I wanted to kill him. I couldn't take it. You're supposed to smile at me. Only me."
You're quiet for a beat, not knowing what to say. You know you should be more angry and hold your ground, but he's looking at you so desperately. Like always. He squeezes your shoulders and looks intently into your eyes. "I didn’t touch her," he says again, voice barely above a whisper. "I...I-I didn't kiss her, didn't want her. She was just...there. I didn't even look at her. I was looking for you."
Your heart pounds and he comes closer to you, needing a response. Your reaction is difficult to read for him, filling him with uncertainty. He knows you probably don't feel the same towards him, and it crushes him. The silence between you stretches long enough to make him nauseous. But then you ask, in a quiet little voice, "Tell me again."
His brows furrow. "What?"
"That you need me."
He steps in again, and this time his hand comes up, shaking slightly, to brush your cheek. "I need you," he says, firmer now. "I w-want and need you so bad it makes me do stupid shit. I'm sorry. I'm so sorry baby, I just... fuck-" He trails off by attaching his lips onto yours to show you how bad he needs you, lips slotting over yours as he moans at your taste. His hands slide up under your shirt like he has to feel your skin, making their way to your bra, which he lifts up over your breasts to squeeze the soft mounds under your shirt.
You whimper softly against his mouth at the suddenness of it, the heat of his palms rough and eager as they mold over you, and that sound makes Rafe groan from somewhere deep in his chest, kissing you harder and messier. He tastes faintly of mint.
"Missed you," he slurs into your mouth, thumbing over your nipples with clumsy desperation, like he's trying to memorize the shape of you through touch alone. His forehead knocks against yours as he breathes you in, the two of you barely able to catch a breath between kisses.
You jolt, moaning and halfheartedly pushing at his chest, but he pinches your nipple as a punishment, needing you against him. "Mnh! Rafe, we shouldn't," you gasp when his mouth moves to your neck, trailing open mouthed kisses over your pulse, and you feel him nodding against you like he agrees, even though he's still doing it.
He kisses a path down your throat, dragging his nose along your skin. His hands stay under your shirt, squeezing and cupping your breasts. You feel him shudder when you don't push him away again, when instead you tilt your head to the side, granting him more access to your neck. He groans low and desperate, hands smoothing down your waist to your hips, pulling you closer until there's not a sliver of space between your bodies.
You feel how hard he is, grinding against you with slow, needy rolls of his hips. His cock strains against his pants, pressing hotly against you through your clothes, and it makes your breath hitch in your throat.
"Fuck," Rafe hisses into your skin, voice wrecked. "Fuck, baby, please..." He presses his forehead against your shoulder, panting, grinding his hips against yours again like he physically can't help himself. "Want you so bad. Been losin' my mind thinking about you, can't stop." His hands grab at your hips, your ass, trying to feel everything he can at once, desperate and frantic.
He pulls back enough to catch your face in both hands, making you look him in the eye. His pupils are blown wide, hair a mess, chest heaving. "Tell me you want it," he says, low and rough. "Tell me you want me, angel. Please." His thumbs stroke your jaw.
You blink up at him, chest rising and falling in shallow breaths. You don't say anything at first, and that moment of silence just makes him even crazier, and he lets out a broken noise, grinding against you harder, hips stuttering like he's about to lose it just from this.
"Say it," he begs again, voice breaking. "Say you want me."
You finally oblige with a little nod, head spinning. "I-I want you, Rafe. I want it..."
The second the words leave your lips, it's like something inside him snaps. "Fuck," Rafe groans, diving back in to kiss you feverishly, his hands already fumbling at the hem of your shirt, yanking it up over your head. He's frantic, crazed, muttering under his breath: "so pretty, so fucking pretty", as he tosses your shirt somewhere behind him. His hands are everywhere, roaming your skin like he's starving, like he’s trying to devour every inch of you.
He makes quick work of your bra, practically ripping it off and letting it fall to the floor. His mouth drops open when he gets a look at you and he immediately ducks his head, mouthing hotly at the tops of your breasts, whining against your plush tits, moaning at the taste.
His hands can't decide where to stay, cupping your breasts, sliding down your sides, gripping your hips, your ass, he's frantic like he's scared you'll disappear if he lets go even for a second. His mouth trails desperate, sloppy kisses down your chest, tongue flicking out to circle one nipple before sucking it into his mouth with a greedy groan, like he needs it to breathe.
Your fingers find his hair without thinking, threading through the soft strands, and he moans into your skin at the contact, bucking his hips into you harder, unable to stop himself.
He ruts against you like he's in heat, hips grinding up into yours in slow, messy rolls as his cock strains painfully against the fabric of his shorts. Every desperate push of his hips presses his hard length right up against your core, and you feel the heat of him even through all the layers between you.
"Fuck," Rafe gasps, drooling on your tits. His hips jerk forward harder, and the friction makes you both groan. He drags his mouth up your chest, laving his tongue over your breasts and sucking hickeys onto your cleavage, all while rutting against you like he's trying to get off just from the contact.
You feel him shudder, breath hot and shaky against your throat, and his hands fumble clumsily at the waistband of your shorts. "Need you," he mumbles. "Need you now."
He doesn't even try to be smooth, just yanks your shorts down your hips in a couple frantic tugs, letting them fall around your ankles, tugging your panties next. You're helping him too, panting and moaning against his face as you tug down his pants and his boxers, freeing his fat, leaking cock, flushed an angry red from built up arousal. You give pause at the sheer size of his cock, resting heavily against his tummy, looking up at him with wide, glassy eyes. "I-it's big, Rafe... " You trail off, nervous.
He shakes his head and pushes you back onto the wall and hovers over you. "It's okay, it's okay... I'll make it fit. Won't hurt my angel." He slides a hand under your thigh, lifting it so you have no choice but to let him grind against your bare pussy, the length of him dragging right along your slick folds.
"Fuck, fuck, fuck," he groans, rutting against you slow and messy. He's trying to savor you but can't stop how badly he wants you, and so his cock ends up slipping and sliding against you, catching between your wet, flowery folds with every other thrust. "Rafe" Your eyes flutter as you call out his name, clinging onto him. It feels so good that you're starting to leak wetness down your thighs. "You feel that?" Rafe pants, forehead pressed to yours, eyes fluttering closed as he rocks against you harder. "Feel how bad I want you? How fucking crazy you make me?"
You nod, breathless, overwhelmed, and Rafe lets out a wrecked little moan, rubbing his cock along your soaked slit again and again, like he's trying to carve the feeling into his memory forever. "Angel..." he moans out, voice loud and unrestrained. You wonder if people can hear you two inside the shack.
He continues holding onto your thigh with one hand and his cock with the other, sliding back and forth against your sopping little pussy. "I'm gonna put it inside you, okay?" He whispers, making direct eye contact with you. "Won't hurt you," he restates, voice low and sincere. You don't see how excited he is deep down to finally have you to himself. He's going to finally fuck you. Then, he's going to make you his girlfriend and never let you out of his sight again. You nod, whining softly and angling your body so he's lined up completely with your pretty pussy.
When the tip notches in your tight hole, you cry out at the intrusion, tears sparking in your wide eyes with the discomfort of having something so big beginning to fill you, so he presses his forehead against yours and coos softly, stroking your hair. "I got you, I got you. Shh... almost halfway," he uses the phrase to coax you, even though he's only got his bulbous head and an inch of his length in you. By the time it's really halfway, you can't take anymore and push on his shoulders. "Rafe! 'm too full, I can't..."
"You can, see? Look at me, look." He cups your cheek, nodding to you and slowly thrusting in and out to get you accommodated, nearly bottoming out entirely. Then, he shoves and stretches you out inch by inch, kissing you deeply to keep you distracted, and he feels you squirming and whining loudly as he gets deeper and deeper, and then he feels the wet squelch of his pelvis against your pussy, and he knows he's filled you up all the way.
You're so goddamn tight, and he lets out a low, drawn out moan. He looks down at where his cock disappears into your stretched out, dripping cunt. He can't believe he actually managed to fit the whole fucking thing inside you. Your little pussy is so goddamn tight, gripping him like a vice now that he's buried to the hilt inside you. Your thighs are trembling, and your back's arched off the wall because of the fullness of him inside you.
Rafe grunts as he slowly starts to thrust, his hips jerking forward to spear his rigid length deeper into your pliant body. Your slick walls flutter around him, trying desperately to accommodate the thick girth stretching you out. The way you feel is incredible, your pussy gripping him like you never want to let him go.
"That's it," he grunts, his voice rough and gravelly with arousal. "Angel, shit... your pussy was made for my cock." He starts thrusting faster, driving into you with more force as he enjoys the way your tits bounce with each snap of his hips. You're barely holding yourself up, legs quivering as he spears into you and angles you so he can hit every sweet spot in your warm, gummy pussy.
The thick length of his cock, pulsing and throbbing, spears into your soaked, gripping walls over and over again. He slams into you and grinds his pelvis against yours, his heavy cock burying to the hilt with each thrust inside your flutter walls. "Feels so good, Rafe," You whines softly, panting into his ear. Your praise fuels him and encourages him to fuck you harder, better. He rolls his hips against yours, stirring his huge length around in your stuffed hole.
Rafe fucks into you deep and you can feel him in your stomach, stretching you out, claiming every inch of your body. He's fucking you like he wants to fucking destroy your pussy and rebuild it to be a perfect mold of his cock. "Mhm? Feels good?" He pants, fucking into your cunt and grabbing your jaw with his free hand so he can see your cute, fucked out expression.
"You feel so good. So fucking good...only for me, right?" He demands, wanting your reassurance, and you nod, throwing your head back and moaning when he bumps against a really sensitive spot way too deep inside you.
He grits his teeth, sweat dripping from his forehead, his whole body working just to keep himself from cumming too fast because you're squeezing the life out of him. "You're fuckin' mine," he rasps against your cheek, thrusts getting sharper, rougher, more desperate.
His cock drives deep, grinding right against that sensitive spot again and again until you’re crying out for him, fingernails digging into his shoulders, your eyes glossy with unshed tears. "Say it," he breathes, grinding his hips up into you so deep you swear you can feel him in your ribs. "Tell me you're mine, angel."
"M'yours," you mewl helplessly, clinging onto him, and Rafe groans louder. He keeps pounding into you with a rough, messy pace, dragging his cock against every sensitive spot inside you. Your pussy clamps down harder around him, spasming, and Rafe lets out a wrecked moan, feeling you start to fall apart around him.
"Shit, gonna cum, angel. Gonna cum inside you so everyone knows who you belong to," he says, thrusts getting sloppier as his balls hit your ass slow and lazy, and he moans, eyes fluttering shut as he spills inside you, heavy, thick cream filling you completely. He doesn't stop until every last drop is buried inside you, and even then, he's still thrusting all rough all slow so you feel every ridge and vein on his heavy cock as he pumps you full. He won't stop till you cum too, and he rolls two fingers over your hardened clit, licking up your throat until he gets to your lips, and slides his tongue over yours.
One last bump of his fat cockhead on your womb has the coil in your tummy snapping, and with a loud moan, you cum all over his cock, splurting pearlescent juices on his cum covered cock. He groans, feeling his cock twitch inside you as you squeeze him impossibly tighter while you cum.
His eyes are glassy as he looks at you, lips parted, and he's still buried deep inside your pussy and holding your jaw, but his voice is gone. During the silence, you notice a flicker in his eyes, the way his pupils dilate as his eyes bore into yours. His mouth keeps opening and closing, making it clear he wants to tell you something.
He wants to say he loves you.
But he doesn't.
He pulls out, making sure your panties and shorts are on as he pulls out, letting his cum slip out of your pussy and rest in your clothes. He grins at the mess between your thighs, wiping off any residue to ensure that it isn't too obvious that you've got his load in you. He kisses your forehead and grins through low eyes, nuzzling your forehead. "Keep it in so you've got a part of me in you all through the rest of this fucking party."
╰ Synopsis You and Caleb stayed loyal to each other after casa amor, and thought everything was perfect until he told you he might see if there’s still something there with Kenzie. Now you’re left wondering if you were really his first choice.
tags/contains Caleb McDaniel x fem!reader. Angst, Caleb making Y/n feel insecure, no happy ending, jealousy (?), use of Y/n, flashbacks are in Italic font, 3.7k words, requested.
➺ from Sera, to you📨. I’m so happy Trinity and Bryce won👅
masterlist ᥫ᭡ please reblog this fic if you enjoyed it!
“Okay, Y/n.” Ariana’s voice cut through the silence of the villa, pulling you back to the moment. Your heart was already hammering against your ribs like it was trying to escape. “You’re next.” She said, offering you a warm smile.
You muttered a quiet “fuck” under your breath, the word slipping out before you could stop it. “Please stand up.” Ariana continued.
You rose slowly, smoothing down the silky fabric of your dark blue dress. Ariana tilted her head, smiling gently. “Before casa amor, you were coupled up with Caleb. And it really felt like the two of you were headed in a good direction. You chose each other at the letter recoupling, and things seemed solid between you since then.” She paused. “How have the last few days been for you?”
You let out a long sigh, trying to keep your voice steady even though your hands were trembling at your sides.
“The last few days have been.. good,” you started, trying to choose the right words. “But it’s definitely tested things. I spent the past couple of days getting to know all the new guys, and they were nice, but Caleb never left my mind. You know, I slept outside every single night, wondering what he was doing over there. And every conversation just brought me back to him..” you swallowed hard. “Then we got the mail and.. it didn’t feel great seeing whatever it was but I just hope what we had was strong enough for him to stay loyal. Even though he’s definitely got some explaining to do when he gets back.”
A ripple of laughter moved through the girls behind you. “Well,” Ariana said, leaning forward slightly, “it’s now time for you to make a choice. Do you want to stay loyal to Caleb and hope that he’s done the same.. or would you like to couple up with one of these new boys?”
The question hung in the air, and you could feel every eye on you. Part of you wondered if it would be easier to pick someone new, but you knew that wouldn’t be right for you. Your heart wouldn’t let you.
You shook your head, a small, determined smile tugging at your lips. “I’m going to stay loyal to Caleb. And just hope he’s smart.”
Ariana nodded, pleased with your answer. “Okay, Y/n. You’ve decided to stay loyal to Caleb..” She let the words settle before continuing. “But has Caleb decided to stay loyal to you?”
You shrugged, nerves wrecking you from the inside out. All you wanted was to see him. To feel his arms around you. But you knew that would only be if he’d chosen you.
“If he walks in with one of these girls from casa amor, you will be single and vulnerable,” Ariana explained. “But if he returns on his own, he’s all yours.”
You exhaled shakily. “Wish me luck” you said, quietly. You closed your eyes, silently praying. The villa grew so quiet you could hear your own heartbeat echoing in your ears.
Every second stretched painfully long. The footsteps grew closer and your eyes stayed squeezed shut, too scared to look. The girls behind you suddenly gasped, excitement exploding out of them.
You finally opened your eyes to see Caleb. And he was alone. Relief crashed over you so hard your knees nearly buckled. You let out a breath you didn’t realize you’d been holding. “Thank God!” You muttered, a breathless laugh escaping as he got closer. He looked incredible, his eyes locked straight on you. And you couldn’t tear your gaze away either.
“Look!” Kayda pointed out excitedly. “Y’all are matching too!”
You glanced down; your dark blue dress and his shirt were almost the exact same shade. The realization made your smile widen as the rest of the islanders erupted into loud, happy awwws.
“Have you ever doubted him?” Zach called out, grinning ear to ear, clearly happy for the two of you.
You didn’t get a chance to answer before Ariana spoke again. “Welcome back to the villa!” She turned toward Caleb. “How are you doing, Caleb?”
He let out a big sigh, but it was full of relief, his eyes never leaving yours. “I’m so great. I’m so happy to see her.. and more especially that she’s standing alone.” Caleb let out a soft laugh, as the islanders cheered for you two again.“I just missed you so much.”
“I missed you too.”
“Every day in there,” he continued, “I spent my time thinking about you. I missed having you next to me while I slept. And I really didn’t think it would be this hard..” He cut himself off, shaking his head, thinking of how ridiculous he probably sounded. “Oh, fuck- I’m just glad we’re back.”
Ariana smiled at the both of you, clearly happy with the two of you. “Since you both have decided to stay loyal.. you are still in a couple!” She gestured between you. “Caleb, you can go get your girl!”
The next morning started just like it used to. You felt his lips first, gentle kisses trailing across your shoulder, then up your neck. “Morning, beautiful.” Caleb whispered, his voice still full with sleep.
You smiled, stretching lazily as he continued his gentle assault of kisses. It felt so normal and so right. When he eventually dragged you out of bed and parted your ways, him going to the kitchen and you went upstairs to the dressing room. You couldn’t lie; you’d missed his breakfast almost as much as you’d missed him. The casa boys had nothing on his cooking.
Everything felt fine, actually better than fine. You two were laughing, touching, looking at each other like lovesick idiots as you carried your plates to soul ties for a morning chat. The sun was warm today, the villa peaceful after yesterdays madness, and you let yourself believe the worst was behind you.
Then Caleb sat down beside you, setting his plate down. “I was just thinking..” He paused, softly putting his palm on your leg. “Maybe since Corbin and Kenzie are done.. maybe I should see if there’s still something with Kenzie?”
The words hit you like a slap. You froze, fork halfway to your mouth. “What?”
He stayed quiet for a second, staring at the bed rather than at you. Everything had felt amazing between the two of you and now, just because Kenzie was suddenly single, even tho technically she was coupled up with Dylan, he wanted to explore her again?
Every worst case scenario raced through your mind at once. What if he’d only stayed loyal because he thought if Corbin came back with Parmida, Kenzie would be still single? What if the connection you thought was so strong was just convenient? Tears burned at the back of your eyes as you swallowed the hard lump rising in your throat.
“Yeah, I don’t know..” Caleb continued. “I just wanna see if there’s something.”
You stared at him, the breakfast you’d been enjoying now sitting like lead in your stomach. “Yeah.. okay. Whatever.”
It was all you could manage. What else were you supposed to say? Jump up and down with excitement at the idea of him chasing after Kenzie who was the same girl who always seemed to keep multiple guys orbiting her like one wasn’t enough?
You stood up abruptly, needing distance from him and whatever he was planning on doing. Your mind immediately went to Melanie. You just wanted to find her and talk before you fell apart in front of everyone.
“Y/n, come on. Are you mad?” Caleb got up quickly, following you.
He reached for your hand. You pulled it away, not trusting yourself to speak without crying. “I’m not happy either..” you said, voice tight, “but do whatever you want.”
You kept walking, heart cracking with every step. Part of you desperately hoped he’d reach for you again. That he’d stop you, and pull you back, tell you it was a stupid thought and he didn’t mean it. But he didn’t and you hated how much it hurt.
You found Melanie on one of the daybeds near the pool, sitting with Sincere and talking. The last thing you wanted to do was interrupt, but you couldn’t hold it together much longer. A few traitorous tears had already slipped down your cheeks on the walk over, and you quickly wiped at them with the back of your hand.
“Melanie?” you called out.
Both of them looked up. Melanie’s expression changed instantly from relaxed to concerned the second she saw your face. Sincere noticed too, “I’ll leave you two.” He said gently, giving Melanie’s shoulder a light squeeze before standing up. “Take care, yeah?”
You managed a “thank you” as he walked off. Then you sank down onto the daybed beside Melanie, shoulders slumped. “What happened?” she asked immediately, turning fully toward you.
The tears you’d been fighting finally spilled over. You wiped at them again, but more kept coming. “It’s Caleb..” you sobbed. “We were just sitting up there in soul ties, everything was fine, and then he told me that he wants to see if there’s still something between him and Kenzie. Just because her and Corbin aren’t coupled up anymore.”
Melanie’s eyes widened. “He said that?”
You nodded, your voice cracking. “Yes. After everything he just casually says that. I feel so stupid. I really thought he came back single for me. But clearly he didn’t. I’ve just been following him around like a lost puppy this whole time, waiting for him, thinking we had something real. And the second Kenzie becomes available again..” your breath hitched. “It feels like I was never really his first choice.”
Melanie didn’t hesitate to pull you in for a tight hug, one arm wrapping around your shoulders while her other hand gently wiped the tears from your cheeks.
“Y/n, you’re not stupid.” She said firmly, rubbing soothing circles on your back. “If anything, he’s the one that’s stupid. You should never let a man make you feel like that.”
You nodded against her shoulder even though you didn’t really believe her. The insecurity sat heavy in your chest, whispering things you shouldn’t be thinking of.
Melanie pulled back to look at you, keeping her hands on your arms. “Listen to me. You should just see what he does now. If he actually goes and pulls her, or if he doesn’t seem to care that you’re hurting, then don’t give him the time of day. You deserve someone who chooses you without thinking twice. Not someone who keeps one eye on the door just in case someone else walks through it.”
Her words settled over you, a small comfort even if the pain was still there. You pulled her in for another hug, and she gave it back just as strongly to let you know she was there for you.
Sincere walked off to find Caleb after leaving you and Melanie on the daybed. He wasn’t the type to get in the middle of drama, but seeing you cry like that, he didn’t like it.
He found Caleb in the kitchen, alone, washing dishes after his breakfast with you. “Hey.” Sincere said, leaning against the counter.
Caleb glanced up. “What’s up?”
Sincere didn’t waste time. “Did you know Y/n came crying to Melanie?”
Caleb’s hands stilled under the water. He looked up fully, brow furrowed. “She did?”
Sincere nodded, arms crossed. “Yeah. She was pretty upset, man.”
“Fuck..” Caleb muttered, shaking his head. He turned off the tap and dried his hands on a towel. “What’d you do?” Sincere asked, pulling out one of the stools at the counter and sitting down.
Caleb sighed heavily, leaning back against the sink. “I guess I messed up..”
“Clearly you did, if she’s crying?!” Sincere replied bluntly while trying not to sound too aggressive.
Caleb ran a hand through his hair. “We were sitting up in soul ties and I just told her that I might try to see if there’s still something with Kenzie. Since her and Corbin are done now.”
Sincere stared at him for a second, genuinely surprised. “Dude? You did mess up. Kenzie literally played you in your face last time and you’re trying to see if there’s something there?”
Caleb shrugged, not really having a good answer. He looked conflicted, eyes dropping to the counter. Sincere shook his head. “I mean, do whatever you want. It’s your life but just know Y/n really liked you. And Kenzie..” He paused, obviously not wanting to say anything. “Well, Kenzie is Kenzie.“
Later that night, the girls headed down together, and the guys were already waiting at the bottom of the stairs for their couples. Even though you didn’t want to, you still walked over to Caleb.
“You look beautiful!” He said softly, eyes tracing over your outfit.
“Thanks.” You replied quickly, offering a polite smile before stepping past him.
When the group gathered around the table where fresh drinks were waiting, you deliberately stood across from Caleb instead of beside him like you normally would. You made small talk with the others, and you could feel Caleb’s gaze on you, but you refused to meet it. He needed to feel even a fraction of how uncomfortable and unwanted his words had made you feel.
As some islanders started drifting off to different areas of the villa and others stayed chatting at the table, you stayed hyperaware of Caleb’s movements.
The second you saw him making his way over toward you, you stood up and slipped away, heading in no particular direction. “Y/n?” He called after you. He caught up quickly, falling into step beside you. “Do you wanna go talk?”
You kept walking, legs carrying you forward on pure emotion. “Don’t even..” you said, edged with frustration. Was it petty? Yes. But did he deserve to sit in the discomfort for a while after that? Also yes.
“But we have some things to talk about. Seriously..” he pressed, still keeping pace.
You finally slowed just enough to glance at him. “I mean.. we’ll talk at some point.”
Caleb stopped following you. You heard him mutter a quiet “Okay” before his footsteps retreated back toward the group.
You kept going until you reached the fire pit. It was quiet and empty. You sank down onto the cushioned seat, the weight of the day pressing on your shoulders. You didn’t know what to do with yourself. Pulling out your phone, you started scrolling even though there was nothing to see.
You opened the camera app, flipping it to the front facing lens, just to look busy. You checked your makeup, dabbed at the corner of your eye where mascara might have smudged, then took a couple of random pictures of the fire and the dark villa backdrop, just anything to keep your hands occupied and your mind from spiraling too hard.
You sat there alone at the fire pit for what felt like fifteen minutes, you tried to stay distracted with your phone, but eventually your eyes wandered.
And you actually hated the timing because that’s when you saw Caleb pulling Kenzie for a chat. Your gaze followed them as they walked together, heading toward one of the more private corners of the villa where the others couldn’t easily see or hear. Kenzie laughed at something he said, and Caleb pointed at whatever they were looking at.
It was surely a sight for sore eyes.
You stood up quickly, tears already filling your eyes again. You dabbed at your cheeks as gently as possible, trying not to ruin your makeup, but it was a losing battle. Blinking rapidly, you made your way upstairs to the dressing room, praying no one would notice. Luckily, the others were still scattered around the villa, and you slipped inside unnoticed.
The second the door clicked shut behind you, you sank down in front of the big mirror, shoulders shaking as quiet sobs slipped out. You felt sick, no matter how hard you tried to stop, the tears kept flowing, hot and relentless.
After a few minutes, you forced yourself up and grabbed a paper towel from the counter, gently wiping underneath your eyes and cheeks.
You pulled out your phone again, fingers moving almost on autopilot. You opened your camera roll and went straight to the album of photos with Caleb.
The first picture you found in the folder was right after the letter recoupling. The two letters sat open in your lap in the photo, the paper slightly wrinkled. You zoomed in on Caleb’s letter. In your mind, you slipped back to that day.
You had opened your mailbox with a nervous smile not knowing if you’ll receive a letter back, your heart was racing the moment you saw the letter. You read it out loud in front of everyone:
“Dear Y/n,
From the moment I walked into this villa, there was just something about you that pulled me in. It wasn’t just how beautiful you are, although I’d be lying if I said I didn’t notice that first, but it was the way you carry yourself. The way you make everyone around you feel comfortable, the way you laugh without holding back, and the way your smile somehow manages to make even the hardest days feel a little lighter.
You’ve got the kindest heart I’ve ever come across. You’re so caring, so patient, and you always seem to know exactly what to say without even trying. Whenever I’m feeling overwhelmed, you’re the first person I want to be around. Somehow, just being next to you makes everything feel okay again.
One thing I admire most about you is how openly you communicate. You’ve never made me feel judged for expressing how I feel. Instead, you’ve shown me that honesty and openness can actually bring two people closer together. You’ve created a space where I feel safe enough to be completely myself, and that’s something I’ll never take for granted.
You’ve become my best friend in here, but somehow you also became so much more than that. Every day I find myself falling for you a little harder, and I honestly can’t imagine doing this experience with anyone else by my side.
Sincerely, Caleb.”
You finished reading the words on your screen, the memory fading as the dressing room came back into focus. You didn’t understand how he could write something so beautiful, and then turn around and say he wanted to see if there was still something with Kenzie.
All those sweet words, had they just been temporary? Easy to say when things were good, but apparently easy to forget the second another option appeared. He had such a sweet way with words, a way of making you feel truly seen. But now you knew he could hurt you just as deeply.
You swiped to the next picture, Caleb was holding you bridal style, both of you smiling like idiots while someone snapped the photo.
You had come downstairs with the girls that night, as usual the guys waited at the bottom of the stairs. The second you spotted Caleb, you practically threw yourself at him. Your arms wrapped around his neck as he pulled you in by the waist, lifting you slightly off the ground in a tight hug. He looked so good; he was wearing a black jean jacket, black jeans, and cowboy boots.
You glanced down at your own outfit and laughed. “Wait, we’re matching!”
You were wearing a black laced dress with white cowboy boots, the perfect complement to his look. Caleb grinned, clearly pleased. “We really are.”
Later, you sat in his lap at the table while a few other islanders chatted about random things. Kayda suddenly spoke up. “Hold on, Y/n, let me take a picture of you two.” She said, already standing up with a big smile. “Y’all look so cute right now.”
You and Caleb both agreed instantly. He handed you his black cowboy hat, carefully placing it on your head before standing up with you. In one smooth motion, he scooped you up bridal style. You squealed in surprise, laughing as you right arm went around his neck for balance, your left arm thrown in the air, and your white boots dangled in the air.
“Smile!” Kayda called, holding up your phone. Caleb held you securely, both of you beaming at the camera.
You continued scrolling through the pictures, your tears slowly drying as you moved from one memory to the next. The more you looked, the more the ache disappeared. The heavy sobs gave way to softer, bittersweet smiles.
There you were after a silly challenge together, covered in paint and laughing. Another photo showed you two cuddling on the daybeds, his arm around you while you rested your head on his shoulder. Picture after picture reminded you how good it had been.
For a little while, you let yourself cherish those moments instead of drowning in the pain. You had shared something special, even if it was starting to feel one sided now. And at the end of the day, if Caleb wanted to get to know Kenzie more, there was nothing you could do about it.
You couldn’t force him to choose you. You could only decide how you carried yourself through it.
The door to the dressing room opened suddenly. You looked over your shoulder and saw Melanie and Aniya walking in.
“Y/n?” Melanie said softly, concern clear in her voice as they both headed straight toward you.
They sat down on either side of you, their eyes immediately landed on your phone, the screen still glowing with the photo of you and Caleb. “Oh, baby..” Melanie murmured.
Without another word, they both pulled you into a tight group hug. Aniya rubbed your back while Melanie rested her head against yours. You let yourself lean into them, the warmth of their support easing some of the tightness.
“We saw you disappear upstairs..” Melanie said gently after a moment. “And we saw Caleb pulling Kenzie.. we figured it wasn’t good.”
You nodded against them. “You don’t deserve to be sitting here crying alone.” Aniya added, pulling back to look at you. “We’ve got you. Whether he comes to his senses or not.”
I specifically chose this name for this fic, because I imagine the producers putting this song over this scene😔😭
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Caleb and reader were coupled up before casa amor and they stayed loyal to each other at the casa recoupling and they r SO GOOD together. After casa caleb told reader that he wants to pull kenzie for a chat and try again with her since her and Corbin r not together anymore. Reader felt like shit and kept thinking what if he came back single from casa because of kenzie and not her