Hey I just wanted your opinion on this: me personally as much as I did enjoy the wembley production of starlight express, when you combine it with the 2018 changes, the 2000s UK tour changes, 2013 bochum, 1993 London, 1987 Broadway changes etc etc. at what point does SO MUCH about starlight express change that it's just not starlight anymore?? I'm not against change. Particularly when it comes to more outdated aspects of the original London production, but those who say starlight has to constantly evolve, at what point does that evolve into basically an entirely different show?? Will it take a version of the show where rusty just doesn't exist anymore for people to realize that Andrew has just gone too far away from the OG material?
Yeeaaahhh... for me it was the 2018 changes that turned it into a show that's just - not the same show. I think it's that it's no longer telling the same story - Trevor Nunn's allegory for systemic racism just isn't there anymore.
Controversial opinion but - Andrew Lloyd Webber is one of the best composers in the world. Arlene Phillips is an amazing choreographer. I wouldn't ask either of them to engineer the sound design, because it's not what they're experts in. So why are they directing the show? And not even touching on "Creative Dramaturg"! How much did Luke Sheppard get to decide on the Wembley show with the influence of the "Creative Dramaturg"? Because it didn't feel like Wembley had a strong story to tell, and more than the 2018 show had. So many questions, so many plot holes. So many undefined characters...
What's so frustrating was Andrew Lloyd Webber talking about "stripping the show back to its 1984 roots" - YES that's what you need to do! But did you do it? NO! I'm pretty sure that the original score, libretto, notes, all the references, were lost in the storage fire in the mid-1990s, and the only material they had to work with for the update was the 1984 cast recording, the 1993 cast recording, and the 2012 touring script! Because the fan community has bootlegs, and we KNOW that, for example, Rolling Stock was NEVER that slow onstage, it just weirdly ended up slow on the recording. the 1984 recording is what, 3/4 of the show? and all the recit, the story telling, is cut.
The 1984 show wouldn't really work now, it needed some tweaks. the 2012 show DESPERATELY needed work, it was not a good version! (apart from orchestrations, it did sound good!) But where we are now is so far from the original it's hard to recognise, because it's just not telling a big story the way Trevor Nunn did.
















