When I went to school in Ithaca, one of the few places a I grew to adore was Castaways. A dive bar/ music venue with a whole lot of character (and even better music and staff), Castaways has been an amazing part of the Ithaca community. I bring this up because I just found out that their lease is not being renewed, so their perfect little spot on the waterfront will no longer be theirs come summer. Very sad news to hear.Â
I spent a great deal of time there during my second semester senior year, as I chose it as the place I wanted to have my immersion journalism experience. I spent any time I could there, alone or with a group. I grew to love the atmosphere and the people.
In honor of this eclectic piece of Ithaca, I thought I might share a never before published piece that I wrote about it, the result of my immersion into its culture.
Cheers, Castaways; you won't be forgotten.
Itâs All Love in the House Tonight
 Josh Lambert knew this day was coming for a few weeks. May 3rd, the day he would certainly never forget, dubbed Slamfest 2009.
           Castaways was filled with people by 2pm. The bands were setting up on the stage across from the bar. Icicle lights strung behind the stage matched the string lights that wrapped around the outer dock entrance opposite the main parking lot. Inside, a merchandise table was set up with shirts and stickers. Outside the grill. Everyone was preparing for an epic event.
Joshâs two sisters, Mama and Papa Lambert and some of his extended family had been planning the benefit for weeks. But not without the help of the Castaways crew, specifically Elliot, event booking guru at Castaways, and one of Joshâs best friends. Benefit concerts are quite frequent there. Josh would normally help in their execution. But on that specific Sunday, the Slamfest benefit was for him. All he had to do was show up.
âRum, coke and a lime please,â shouts a stumbling brunette at the bar. âNo spiced rum, a lighter one.â
âThatâll be five dollars.â Josh shouts back, leaning over the bar with a snow-white towel over his shoulder. The towelâs a staple when he works.
A tiny sip. âMmm yea, Iâll have two more of those.â
He glides back to the cocktail glasses stacked next to the 12-inch 1970 Panasonic TV behind him. Its glow mimicking the neon Castaways sign outside atop the building.
His movement behind the bar is fluid, every step transforming into the next, hair never moving in the process. Every night the bartenders are first-on, second-on, or third-on, depending on skill level and time theyâve been there. Josh has been bartending for about nine years, six of which have been at Castaways. Naturally, tonight heâs first-on.
Within 30 seconds, the drinks sit in front of the brunette, Joshâs hand out waiting for the crumpled dollar bills. The sound of the cash register is silent, blurred underneath the roar of a growing crowd of nearly 200 people and the deep bass of the opening local reggae band on stage.
Itâs going to be a big show tonight. The Skatalites, an internationally known ska band whoâve been playing since the 60s, are the main performance.
But first the openers play on stage, hyping the crowd of dread locks and fedoras, face tattoos and leather jackets, for the main attraction. Opposite the bar, the usual hollow semi circle forms on the rough wooden dance floor in front of the band. No one ventures in to dance just yet, as an overwhelming fear of judgment infects the crowd.
The blond in the group of three college-age girls to the right of the stage sips a brown cocktail in the outer layer of the circle, shifting awkwardly from one leg to the next.
Across on the other side, one of the two young guys in white t-shirts and jeans, stands looking compulsively at the surrounding crowd as he pushes his shaggy dark brown hair out of his eyes. No dancing yet. Give it ten minutes and the crowd begins to slowly move into the their own versions of the reggae bob.
The most sporadic movement comes from a woman with long gray hair by the bar. The bar is generally not a dancing zone, but she doesnât care. She waves her arms in a flowing motion and with each beat of the bass drum sticks her chin out and lifts one leg. It resembles a very well-choreographed chicken movement.Â
âHow was your party last night?â says the second-on bartender cleaning a few glasses.
âYou went home!â Joshâs throw his hands into the air and his head jerks forward. The movement doesnât move his hair though. Itâs a perfect replica of the iconic Elvis quaff. It competes with the Elvis bust sitting at the end of the bar. Itâs certainly one of the first things people notice about him.
âYea man. I know.â His voice sounds ashamed as he takes an order.
Josh fake dances with him from behind, arms waving as he does a hip-thrust in his friendâs direction, snickering silently as he does. A lull at the bar when the bands start always means time for play.
Watching from the door, Bill zips up his faded black Carhartt jacket as he looks at his 200th ID for this 20 degree, snowy night. Four or five nights a week heâs the gatekeeper for Castaways, marking visitors with a green dragonfly stamp if youâre over 21 or an X if underage. He goes through IDs and stamps quickly so as to get visitors out of the cold and into the stuffy, muggy air of the venue. Theyâre sent to the visiting cash register at the end of a makeshift barrier. Crumpled $20 bills only accepted with a stamp or an X.
As the space on the dance floor shrinks, the unique scent begins to take its form for the night. Tonight itâs a mix of cologne, alcohol, weed, and incense. Itâs heaviest near the band. The dance floor is now in motion, like growing waves about to be unleashed by a coming storm.
The thunder of bass shakes the tattered sheets above them on the ceiling and forces the corset shaped lamps near the bar to shimmy. Behind the band dance rows of twinkling icicle lights. The glimmer of each jumps from instrument to instrument, creating a sparkling aura on the stage.Â
           âYo Ithaca! How you all feelinâ tonight?â The screams of a few pierce the dull roar of the cramped venue.
âCominâ at ya!â The Skatalites take the stage, the two lead vocalists with white beards and aged faces enter last. One with a knitted sweater on. The other with a button up shirt.
âThe two vocalists are around 70,â Mariah, the PR rep says. Itâs her job to know everything about the bands before they come. âThis will probably be the last time they play here.â Not because of disinterest, but because of age most likely. Sheâs done her research. She was sure the show would sell out.
Sheâs really only worked at Castaways for five months, since September, but sheâs been frequenting here since she was 16 as an Ithaca native. Itâs like a second home to her and itâs one of the reasons she left her full time job in Albany for a part time PR job here. Itâs in the family.
It was around 3pm when Josh got to Slamfest, a benefit to raise money for his future medical bills. A little over two years before tonight, Josh âSlambertâ as some of his friends call him, was diagnosed with Hotchkins Lymphoma, the âgood kindâ of cancer he thought.
If it had a name, it meant it was treatable. 98 percent cure rate. He knew he was lucky too because he neglected that weird lump in his throat for about a year and a half before seeing a doctor.Â
His sister, aunt, and uncle arrived with him. All paid donations as they walked in, except him of course. And even though Castaways was already full of all his family and friends and he knew heâd be the center of attention, he never hesitated.
Technically, Slamfest started at 2pm, but the music wouldnât start until around 3:30. His hour late arrival allowing the Lambert family to have a little more time to finish setting up.
Josh knew he would spend the entire benefit thanking people for coming out, shaking hands, kissing babies, and throwing his sweat rags on people that they would then sell to benefit him for the fight against cancer. Okay, so the last part wasnât realistic, but certainly a funny thought that passed through his mind.
With a white button up shirt and a dark pair of aviators, Josh entered the bar with a slightly different look about him. The clothing was normal, but if you werenât a regular and hadnât seen the chemoâs impact, the hair might look different.
Elvis was gone. His hair was buzzed thin, though sideburns still crawled down is face, down past near-invisible eyebrows. And then there was the burn.
Everyday throughout the week, nearly 200 liquor bottles span out on either side of the basketball game playing on the Panasonic behind the bar. Among them, the knick-knacks. A Pope figurine. A cowboy doll. A maraca. A pink stuffed gorilla. A few troll dolls. Mimicking the toys, sits a human size Barbie doll on a waist height stool at the bar, sipping her cocktail.
âMy friend came earlier and dropped off some of my stuff, which happened to include this and my Halloween costume,â Mariah says snickering, glancing at the wig. She pats the fly aways of the blond wig to put them back in place and decides to wear the wig for the rest of the night.
Which one are you going to be?
Which one are you going to be?
Itâs a slow Wednesday night, with an artist that doesnât really have a following around here. Mariah teamed her up with a local accapella group, hoping to bring in some new fans. The result was less than desirable: 13 people. Maybe it was the snow outside.
But whether itâs 13 visitors or 300, this is what Mariah wants to do: help out local artists to get their jump in the community. During her college days, she founded and ran the Rebels for a Cause radio show to do just that.Â
âI wasnât just playing music,â she would say later. âI worked really hard to make sure every week I had a local band in there and I was doing live performances at the studio and band interviews. I like really trying to connect the local community.
A degree in womenâs studies with a concentration in media justice, led the way. Sheâs passionate about keeping independent music alive, even if there are more empty wooden floors than people sometimes, like tonight.
By the time the short brunette on stage finishes her last song, the crew has already begun to goof around.
âCheck out the back!â Josh suggests from the bar.
âFishes.â Mariah lifts the back of her shirt as the others gather around examining her tattoo. âLook at the detail! Carol spent a lot of time on that.â
Immediately another bartender, Paul, hops onto the pool table behind him and strips his shoe and sock off.Â
âMy buddy drew that one. Thatâs my favorite,â he says enamoring over it.
âYou going to my art show?â Mariah asks. She makes eye contact with him, but glances down every few seconds to take a look at his foot art. The show is an opportunity to showcase at Castaways the work of a local artist, accompanied by some tunes by a local DJ. The combo is Mariahâs brainchild.
âThatâs when I work!â Paul jumps up and claps in excitement. Double win: gets paid and gets to support part of the crew.
The radiation did a number on the left side of Joshâs neck. The skin looked a dark tan, but treatment had finished and it would soon turn to a normal tone. The missing patch of hair on the lower back of his head that had been burned completely off by radiation would grow back soon.
It was overwhelming and kind of surreal to have everyone there because of him. And everyone there was family: Mama and Papa Lambert, sisters, aunts and uncles from out of town, cousins young and old, friends, and the Castaways crew.
He said some hellos and went to the bar to grab a beer. Guinness. He knew heâd be drinking this most of the night. During chemo and radiation, his taste buds were affected and shit got fucked up. Hops tasted like garbage, red wine like iron. It just had this metallic weird flavor to it.Â
But somehow Guinness tasted amazing. Jameson Irish whisky, too. Thatâs what he planned on sticking to for the night, knowing everyone would continue to be impressed by his drinking ability with having just finished radiation five days ago.
           âWhat can I get for you guys?â Josh asks the three band members in fedoras at the end of the bar. They speak in soft tones, muffled even more under the loud Pandora station playing from the speakers above. He returns in an instant with three beers, all dark amber, a quarter of an inch of foam on each.
           He chats with one of the tech guys about the mood lighting for the night, essentially no different than other Saturday nights at 8:30. Itâs dimly lit, the bar with the most light so the bartenders can see their work.     Â
âYou want a drink?â he asks, leaning on the bar toward him.
âSure,â the tech guy heading toward a seat at the bar.
âIâm gunna come and join you.â Heâs on break. The bar is dull at this time.
Mariah walks over giggling, âSome girl just wrote âYea JoshâŚâ with a heart around it and her number in the bathroom stall.â
âO yea? She leave her number?â
Josh and Mariahâs relationship is essentially a Castaways romance. It actually made those who worked at Castaways a little hesitant about letting Mariah on because they thought if they broke up, it would mess up the dynamic of the work environment. Jobs at Castaways are normally given to âfamily."
Elliot convinced them she was a good fit though. âYou want Mariah,â he told the owners. âSheâs gunna kick ass, and Iâm sure if her and Josh didnât work out, that would be fine."
Fortunate for Mariah, everyone said yes, because if she didnât work at Castaways hers and Joshâs relationship would be near nonexistent. Her regular workday as an elderly dog sitter for a nice lesbian couple in town runs from 6am until 6pm. Two hours later, Josh starts his shifts bartending, on busy nights, until 4am. Their relationship is able to exist because of Castaways.
âIn that sense its like us working together here really makes it work,â she says. âBasically, I just walked into town, got an awesome job at Castaways, get to chill with my boyfriend, and itâs not usually that easy.â
All through his treatments Josh was never one to feel bad about himself. He would later say he buzzed his head because he felt bad going into the chemo ward with everyone who had lost their hair.
âI felt like a fucking asshole. I have a lot of hair. Six rounds of chemo is nothing compared to the people who are on it for a year.â
But his Medicare was up and he still had two years of check-ups to pay for. Thatâs where the benefit came in. As he looked around, Castaways had truly transformed into Slamfest. Nearly half the people there were wearing light gray âI <3 Slambertâ t-shirts that his sister made and sold for $10 each. And stamped across pants and t-shirts were white bumper stickers with black letters that read, âCancer can suck it!â
That made him laugh. The year before when he called his sister and told her he had cancer, she started crying on the phone. Josh, from day one, tried to stay upbeat about things. âCancer can suck it,â he told her. His motto was sold that day for $5 each.
Itâs 12:04 am on a Friday night; the smoke from the fog machine lingers in every nook of the venue. The air is thick, surrounding the band members with a hazy glow of red, blue, and yellow that strobe infrequently. Another show of the Gunpoets at Castaways.Â
Mariah, in short jean shorts and stockings, walks aimlessly carrying a tray of piping hot fries, the stream of steam quickly dissipating behind her. She hunts for the fry owners on her toes, her neck arched. Without luck she shrugs and turns back to the bar.
Tonight she takes on the role of waitress for the few in the crowd demanding food. Not drinks though. She doesnât venture behind the bar. Josh is working today and on nights like this, when the band is popular, the bar is always busy and heâs first-on, heâs all work and no play.
âI wouldnât want to work for him behind the bar because on busy nights when thereâs like 400 people in here, heâs like scary,â she would later say laughing as Josh brushes by giving her shoulder a rub.
Itâs all love in the house tonight.
I looked inside of the heart of an old man,
so drunk he could barely stand.
A white t-shirt with the sleeves cut off and a flat-rimmed hat dances around the stage, hands waving as he raps a simple melody.
Dozens of powerful fists sore up. The dance floor suddenly resembles a dominant moment in the fields at Woodstock, guests screaming about free love and dancing like no one is watching.
The fists nearly touch the ceiling and the bass vibrates the nose and sternum. The fresh air is minimal as the building is near capacity with sweat-drenched dancers and all sets of doors closed.
Itâs nearing 1 am. âLast call yaâll!â the drenched t-shirt yells into the mic. âSo go get your last drinks and be patient, the bartenders are doinâ a great job.â
O, canât fight it no more.
Livinâ on nine to five.
After a final chorus, the Gunpoets are done. They were technically supposed to end two songs ago, but the shouts of the eager âOne more song!â from the flat-rimmed hat in the front of the crowd triggered the encore. One more song always means two.
Within seconds, the lights turn on and doors open, and eyes struggle to see. Everyone has seen nothing but dark and smoke the whole night. Castaways is nearly half empty in a matter of five minutes, the sound of broken glass getting kicked around as people scuffle to get their jackets, purses, and merch.
There are now five working behind the bar, skating around each other to quickly clean up and get out of there, most likely heading to the after party at someoneâs house on East Hill. Everyone pitches in.
Itâs 1:37 am. No booze. No music. No smokers on the dock. The only people left are Josh, Mariah, other bartenders, the Gunpoets, friends, and a few too drunk to know itâs over. A group of 20 empty beer bottles sit in a clump at the bar, waiting to be packed into boxes for recycling.
âBarâs closed!â yells Bill. His voice is normally soft spoken, but heâs been a bouncer here for 11 years and means business when heâs on duty at a busy show. âIf youâre the band, you can stay. If youâre not, fucking go!â
At this point, it doesnât matter if youâve got a dragon fly stamp or not. Partyâs over. This is the crewâs first opportunity to breathe and hang all night. Mariah walks out of the bathroom and B-lines for the bar, a disgusted look on her face.
âGirls bathroom? Vomit? Shit? Someone passed out?â Josh asks her.
Mariah is still silent and disgusted, quite different from the same night last week when she exited the bathroom and poked fun at her boyfriend for the âJosh is so hot!â chalk writing on the bathroom stall. No fun sayings tonight though. Just vomit.
âSee, I told you the girls bathroom is always more disgusting than the guys!â He laughs as he walks to other end of the bar, wiping a glass dry with his still-white towel. His comments are always light and with a smile.Â
Throughout the day of Slamfest, everyone who played was a friend of his. If they were going to play at his benefit, than he damn well was going to be there for every second, even if he was still a little droopy from treatments. Makepeace Brothers. Steve Brown and his son and daughter. The Gunpoets. DJ Capel spun for a while. And at around 6pm Papa Lambert sang Beautiful Boy to him while his friend Colin played piano.Â
This is kind of weird, Josh thought. But it was solely weird because everyone was crying. He sat up front so no one could see him cry, or at least, thatâs what he continued to tell himself as the song continued. He did cry though.
Elliot was the MC for the benefit. Throughout the night he announced raffles that were donated by local businesses, in between band sets. All the money for the raffles went directly to the Slamfest fund. Outside, Joshâs uncle cooked food on the dock, everything sold to benefit his nephew.
As the night dwindled on, drinks continued and memories of the rest of the night got blurrier and blurrier. Hundreds of people poured in and out, right through till 1am.
By the end of the night, the chalkboard walls of the girlâs bathroom were covered in pink words of encouragement for Josh.
âJosh, nobody deserves success more.â
âI love you Joshy Poo!â
âI was here. Slamfest 2009. Auntie Tina.â
âMama Slambert thanks you all.â
           âWhatâs that called?â The man in the flannel looks quizzically at the beer tap.
           âThatâs Cascazilla.â
           âO, Casca..zilla?â
           âYea we got a gorge and a Cascadilla street here and this is made with Cascade hops from Ithaca Brewery. Not sure where the 'zilla part came from.â Josh pours him a glass just as a man with an Ithaca Beer Company shirt walks in with a box. âO whatâd you bring?â
           âI got âzilla and Groundbreak.â He pulls a 64-ounce brown growler with the Ithaca Beer Company logo out to show him. After bringing the box into the back kitchen, he comes out a few seconds later with one of the four growlers and tasting cups.
âWould you like to try some Ithaca beer while youâre here?â he asks the blond middle-aged woman at the end of the bar.
He continues to travel around the bar giving tastings to thirsty visitors. The last time he was here, he also brought free t-shirts for the bartenders, âswaggerâ as they called it. No merchandise tonight though, just booze.
Things like this donât happen at other bars in Ithaca, like Silky Jones where Josh works one night a week.
A half hour later, Mariah sits at the bar, grabbing the drink that Josh just put in front of her. âCastaways is not Silkyâs or whatever. Itâs Castaways. And you have to appreciate it all the way for being a dive bar music venue. Thatâs what we are.â
A few minutes later Josh emerges from behind the bar to stand by Mariah. âPeel back the layers and you will find a beautiful love story,â he laughs. She does too.
At around 1am, Slamfest was officially over. Josh watched as every bartender who had worked for free the whole day, regardless of whether they were first, second, or third-on, dumped their tips into the Slamfest fund.
Anyone left over, which ended up being quite a lot of people, headed over to Joshâs house on East Hill for a small bonfire and more partying. Josh was still drinking Guinness, still shaking hands and still kissing babies.
âThey talk about going to support groups, but it was apparent to me that what I needed was to be around family and friends, people that have been around my whole life,â Josh would say later.
The next day, the Lambert family and friends tallied their earnings from the epic Sunday benefit. Through door donations, t-shirts, bumper stickers, grilled food, tips, and raffles, and through the combined effort of friends, family and his extended family at Castaways, Slamfest 2009 raised $8,000 for him.
The most successful benefit at Castaways was the one they held for their own.